There are 248 users in the forums

49ers Head Coach Kyle Shanahan Thread

Shop Find 49ers gear online

49ers Head Coach Kyle Shanahan Thread

  • DrEll
  • Veteran
  • Posts: 7,822
Originally posted by genus49:
Originally posted by DrEll:
It's these millennials. Everything is sugar coated for them. Lose a SB…hey at least we won the NFCCG. Lose the NFCCG…hey at least we made it there. Mix that in with "our coach is awesome" and "blame player X", and that pretty much describes the current fan base.

In the good ole days, SB winning coaches were fired or forced into retirement for coming up short. But even that is spun into "EddieD was a criminal, can't believe anything he did".

By all means give us an example of this…

George Seifert.
  • DrEll
  • Veteran
  • Posts: 7,822
Originally posted by genus49:
Originally posted by 49erFaithful6:
Originally posted by captveg:
Washington's Joe Gibbs after losing to the Raiders with one of the most unprepared teams in a SB of all time.... Oh, wait. Never mind. They kept him and he won two more in the next eight seasons.

Not a single HC that lost a SB was fired before the next season in 1980-1990. I even threw in the 1979 season since the SB was in Jan 1980. But, you know, pesky facts.

Joe Gibbs? Gibbs had a ring year 2. No surprise they kept him.
by year 7 (Shanny's years) Gibbs had 2 rings
Seifert was forced out, we all know it

Seifert was forced out after back to back loses in the divisional round to the Packers including a 1 and done situation at home when we had a dominant team on both sides of the ball.

Not sure why you're even bringing that up when we knew Seifert just ran with the team Bill put together and even then his personal stuff pushed us into making moves like trading Haley to Dallas and soon as the salary cap came into play suddenly he's not winning playoff games…almost like it's not that easy?

Either way not quite a SB losing, let alone SB winning HC getting fired is it?

Nice spin. He was fired for coming up short 2 years after winning a SB. And everyone knows the pressure EddieD put on Bill Walsh, and probably factored into his retiring after winning one.

the lengths some of you will go just to defend Kyle is amazing. You'll bring down any great head coach just to level him with Shanahan. Bill Walsh won 3 SBs. Your response…yea but he lost on another potential 4-5, therefore he's just like Kyle.

Seifert got fired for losing in the playoffs. Your answer. Seifert inherited a loaded offense from Bill Walsh. Kyle started from scratch therefore 2 SB losses are justified.

Just awful fanhood
Originally posted by DrEll:
Originally posted by genus49:
Originally posted by 49erFaithful6:
Originally posted by captveg:
Washington's Joe Gibbs after losing to the Raiders with one of the most unprepared teams in a SB of all time.... Oh, wait. Never mind. They kept him and he won two more in the next eight seasons.

Not a single HC that lost a SB was fired before the next season in 1980-1990. I even threw in the 1979 season since the SB was in Jan 1980. But, you know, pesky facts.

Joe Gibbs? Gibbs had a ring year 2. No surprise they kept him.
by year 7 (Shanny's years) Gibbs had 2 rings
Seifert was forced out, we all know it

Seifert was forced out after back to back loses in the divisional round to the Packers including a 1 and done situation at home when we had a dominant team on both sides of the ball.

Not sure why you're even bringing that up when we knew Seifert just ran with the team Bill put together and even then his personal stuff pushed us into making moves like trading Haley to Dallas and soon as the salary cap came into play suddenly he's not winning playoff games…almost like it's not that easy?

Either way not quite a SB losing, let alone SB winning HC getting fired is it?

Nice spin. He was fired for coming up short 2 years after winning a SB. And everyone knows the pressure EddieD put on Bill Walsh, and probably factored into his retiring after winning one.

the lengths some of you will go just to defend Kyle is amazing. You'll bring down any great head coach just to level him with Shanahan. Bill Walsh won 3 SBs. Your response…yea but he lost on another potential 4-5, therefore he's just like Kyle.

Seifert got fired for losing in the playoffs. Your answer. Seifert inherited a loaded offense from Bill Walsh. Kyle started from scratch therefore 2 SB losses are justified.

Just awful fanhood

Man shut up. You offer nothing to these conversations and can't even phrase your statements properly to avoid confusion.

Bill Belichick was just fired so those good ol days you're talking about literally happened a few months ago. If coaches aren't performing up to standards they get fired. That will happen with Kyle either.

And it's not taking anything away from Seifert to say he had Montana and Young on the roster and got handed the keys to a Ferrari from Walsh.

I'm pretty sure had Shanahan had either QB he'd have at least 1 SB to show for it by now if not 3+.

You know what Kyle hasn't done without HOF QBs and dealing with the salary cap? Lose in the wildcard or divisional round or go 1 and done in the playoffs.

So your comment is way off the mark again and completely ignorant of the state of today's NFL.

Shanahan just had this team in the SB, a game we lost in OT to a dynasty level team. Expecting or wanting him to get fired is definition of being a delusional fan.
Originally posted by DrEll:
Nice spin. He was fired for coming up short 2 years after winning a SB. And everyone knows the pressure EddieD put on Bill Walsh, and probably factored into his retiring after winning one.

the lengths some of you will go just to defend Kyle is amazing. You'll bring down any great head coach just to level him with Shanahan. Bill Walsh won 3 SBs. Your response…yea but he lost on another potential 4-5, therefore he's just like Kyle.

Seifert got fired for losing in the playoffs. Your answer. Seifert inherited a loaded offense from Bill Walsh. Kyle started from scratch therefore 2 SB losses are justified.

Just awful fanhood

Also…nobody bashed Bill. Learn to read.

Then again maybe you're self projecting. I can see you posting in here(had the internet been a thing) after the Vikings loss in 87

"get rid of Walsh not winning a SB is unacceptable, the old man lost it!"
Originally posted by genus49:
Man shut up. You offer nothing to these conversations and can't even phrase your statements properly to avoid confusion.

Bill Belichick was just fired so those good ol days you're talking about literally happened a few months ago. If coaches aren't performing up to standards they get fired. That will happen with Kyle either.

And it's not taking anything away from Seifert to say he had Montana and Young on the roster and got handed the keys to a Ferrari from Walsh.

I'm pretty sure had Shanahan had either QB he'd have at least 1 SB to show for it by now if not 3+.

You know what Kyle hasn't done without HOF QBs and dealing with the salary cap? Lose in the wildcard or divisional round or go 1 and done in the playoffs.

So your comment is way off the mark again and completely ignorant of the state of today's NFL.

Shanahan just had this team in the SB, a game we lost in OT to a dynasty level team. Expecting or wanting him to get fired is definition of being a delusional fan.

Don't worry bro, your guys gonna be here for the next 10 years.
History however will judge him harshly, regardless of what his disciples think of him.

The guys a choke artist and history will label him as such. He didn't just lose a couple of super bowls. Because of his hard headedness he has pissed away what could have potentially been another dynasty.
[ Edited by maximusdecimus on Mar 29, 2024 at 8:40 AM ]
Originally posted by genus49:
Also…nobody bashed Bill. Learn to read.

Then again maybe you're self projecting. I can see you posting in here(had the internet been a thing) after the Vikings loss in 87

"get rid of Walsh not winning a SB is unacceptable, the old man lost it!"

there he goes again comparing Kyle to Bill Walsh
Go follow another team already
  • Koldo
  • Veteran
  • Posts: 4,574
Originally posted by GoreGoreGore:
Go follow another team already

Fighting ghosts again, Gore?
Originally posted by Koldo:
Originally posted by GoreGoreGore:
Go follow another team already

Fighting ghosts again, Gore?

You went a whole day without crying about Kyle. New record congrats
Kyle and tge Niners lost 2 SBs to the Chiefs. They just happen to have one of the great coaches of our time and probably the best QB of this era. Sorry Tom. You played longer and won those titles but Mahomes can do things you never could dream of.
Originally posted by CatchMaster80:
Kyle and tge Niners lost 2 SBs to the Chiefs. They just happen to have one of the great coaches of our time and probably the best QB of this era. Sorry Tom. You played longer and won those titles but Mahomes can do things you never could dream of.

At this rate 7+ does not look so far away. God I hate that. If we can stop him/them from winning another one that would be great.
[ Edited by 49er-from-Yavin-IV on Mar 29, 2024 at 1:33 PM ]
Originally posted by 49er-from-Yavin-IV:
At this rate 7+ does not look so far away. God I hate that. If we can stop him/them from winning another one that would be great.

The AFC is just stacked though. It helped them that there were major QB injuries (Burrow/Rodgers) last year and I would expect the Chargers to be really competent really soon.
Originally posted by DrEll:
Nice spin. He was fired for coming up short 2 years after winning a SB. And everyone knows the pressure EddieD put on Bill Walsh, and probably factored into his retiring after winning one.

the lengths some of you will go just to defend Kyle is amazing. You'll bring down any great head coach just to level him with Shanahan. Bill Walsh won 3 SBs. Your response…yea but he lost on another potential 4-5, therefore he's just like Kyle.

Seifert got fired for losing in the playoffs. Your answer. Seifert inherited a loaded offense from Bill Walsh. Kyle started from scratch therefore 2 SB losses are justified.

Just awful fanhood


I remember when you guys wanted Harbaugh fired for Tomsula.
Originally posted by TheWooLick:
I remember when you guys wanted Harbaugh fired for Tomsula.

Wouldn't be surprised if that was true. Have yet to see an intelligent argument. Mostly just crying, bad predictions, and insults to generations instead.
Originally posted by SmokeyJoe:
Originally posted by TheWooLick:
I remember when you guys wanted Harbaugh fired for Tomsula.

Wouldn't be surprised if that was true. Have yet to see an intelligent argument. Mostly just crying, bad predictions, and insults to generations instead.

Plenty of reasonable arguments, you have the blinders on if you don't see em
There's good with Shanny and bad also, it's not black and white as most ppl portray
Share 49ersWebzone