49ers Head Coach Kyle Shanahan Thread

Originally posted by thl408:
This is my comprehension of why The Catch was even brought up. It's to show that some moments are forgotten had it not been for another event taking place. No one would care about The Catch had it not been for the 49er defense clutching up to secure the win. If we are talking about specific moments from the recent SB as an example, I rarely read any mention of the double throw Jennings touchdown pass to CMC - a holy s**t trick play moment. But none of us care because the game was an L for the 49ers.

I AM NOT COMPARING THAT JENNINGS THROW TO THE CATCH.
I AM NOT COMPARING THAT JENNINGS THROW TO THE CATCH.
I AM NOT COMPARING THAT JENNINGS THROW TO THE CATCH.
I AM NOT COMPARING THAT JENNINGS THROW TO THE CATCH.
I AM NOT COMPARING THAT JENNINGS THROW TO THE CATCH.

JJ just mightve been the MVP had the D made an OT stop.

IM NOT COMPARING JENNINGS TO JERRY RICE!!!!!!!
IM NOT COMPARING JENNINGS TO JERRY RICE!!!!!!!
IM NOT COMPARING JENNINGS TO JERRY RICE!!!!!!!
IM NOT COMPARING JENNINGS TO JERRY RICE!!!!!!!

Originally posted by SmokeyJoe:

Originally posted by 49erFaithful6:
It's a writing comprehension issue. Why even bring up The Catch? You want to mention us taking the lead with Moody is like The Catch game and the d didn't hold up. Don't be upset with me for laughing at nonsense.

Multiple people are telling you that you're missing the point. Perhaps intentionally. The point of referencing the game was clear. You briefly touched on it yourself:

'there was less than 60 seconds to respond.. Mahomes had effectively unlimited game clock, the game would have gone into 6 quarters and flipped field. this is nonsensical comparison.'

Unfortunately that was sandwiched between your complaint about a comparison to a singular play, over multiple posts, which wasn't actually made.

i'm not talking about the singular play, I'm talking about comparing that game to this game. I see zero comparison. SB 58 and The Catch game have nothing to do with each other folks. if you want to talk about the manner of the final score, or the position the D was in, or the time remaining, it's all very different. to compare the two you have to zoom so far out the comp is meaningless, like they are both NFL teams, on D, late game after a lead change.. that's the comp.. ok well you don't need to invoke that game, to talk about our SB 58 overtime D.

Originally posted by 49erFaithful6:
i'm not talking about the singular play, I'm talking about comparing that game to this game. I see zero comparison. SB 58 and The Catch game have nothing to do with each other folks. if you want to talk about the manner of the final score, or the position the D was in, or the time remaining, it's all very different. to compare the two you have to zoom so far out the comp is meaningless, like they are both NFL teams, on D, late game after a lead change.. that's the comp.. ok well you don't need to invoke that game, to talk about our SB 58 overtime D.

Lol. Jesus christ, man.

Originally posted by SmokeyJoe:

Originally posted by 49erFaithful6:
i'm not talking about the singular play, I'm talking about comparing that game to this game. I see zero comparison. SB 58 and The Catch game have nothing to do with each other folks. if you want to talk about the manner of the final score, or the position the D was in, or the time remaining, it's all very different. to compare the two you have to zoom so far out the comp is meaningless, like they are both NFL teams, on D, late game after a lead change.. that's the comp.. ok well you don't need to invoke that game, to talk about our SB 58 overtime D.

Lol. Jesus christ, man.

from now on when a team concedes late game, after going up, naturally I will think of The Catch game, where that didn't happen.. makes total sense

Originally posted by :

from now on when a team concedes late game, after going up, naturally I will think of The Catch game, where that didn't happen.. makes total sense

.

We do love eating our own.

Seems to me that with all of this catch talk it seems to suggest A) we didn't have our catch or score a td thus the offense didn't do it's job and put up 7 when they absolutely needed to(twice) B) we still got points but the defense didn't do it's job when they needed to. C) maybe if the special teams does it's job A and B are irrelevant. We failed in all 3 aspects of the game when we had every chance to win. A+B+C=head coaching

Originally posted by 49erFaithful6:
i'm not talking about the singular play, I'm talking about comparing that game to this game. I see zero comparison. SB 58 and The Catch game have nothing to do with each other folks. if you want to talk about the manner of the final score, or the position the D was in, or the time remaining, it's all very different. to compare the two you have to zoom so far out the comp is meaningless, like they are both NFL teams, on D, late game after a lead change.. that's the comp.. ok well you don't need to invoke that game, to talk about our SB 58 overtime D.

Literally no one compared that game to this game besides you. The whole point was about football being a complementary game, game of inches and individual plays that shape a game in some way, shape or form.

Many of the iconic plays in history of football, let alone 49ers, don't happen if the other side (ie, defense or offense) didnt make some plays or things go their way.

Immaculate reception may not happen/matter if Stabler doesnt fumble inside his own 25

The David Tyree catch doesnt happen/matter if Asante Samuel catches the ball

The Drive might never happen if Montana's pick doesnt get dropped at the start of the fourth quarter

and so on and so forth

You for some reason focused on The Catch as direct comparison to this game, and while people are trying to tell you this you're covering your ears and keep going lalalalalalalalalalalalala

Originally posted by the_dynasty:

Originally posted by 49erFaithful6:
i'm not talking about the singular play, I'm talking about comparing that game to this game. I see zero comparison. SB 58 and The Catch game have nothing to do with each other folks. if you want to talk about the manner of the final score, or the position the D was in, or the time remaining, it's all very different. to compare the two you have to zoom so far out the comp is meaningless, like they are both NFL teams, on D, late game after a lead change.. that's the comp.. ok well you don't need to invoke that game, to talk about our SB 58 overtime D.

Literally no one compared that game to this game besides you. The whole point was about football being a complementary game, game of inches and individual plays that shape a game in some way, shape or form.

Many of the iconic plays in history of football, let alone 49ers, don't happen if the other side (ie, defense or offense) didnt make some plays or things go their way.

Immaculate reception may not happen/matter if Stabler doesnt fumble inside his own 25

The David Tyree catch doesnt happen/matter if Asante Samuel catches the ball

The Drive might never happen if Montana's pick doesnt get dropped at the start of the fourth quarter

and so on and so forth

You for some reason focused on The Catch as direct comparison to this game, and while people are trying to tell you this you're covering your ears and keep going lalalalalalalalalalalalala

Pretty much par for the course with the man.

We clearly live in alternative universes.

No wonder Marvel's latest movies are so crap and hard to understand.

Originally posted by genus49:

Originally posted by the_dynasty:

Originally posted by 49erFaithful6:
i'm not talking about the singular play, I'm talking about comparing that game to this game. I see zero comparison. SB 58 and The Catch game have nothing to do with each other folks. if you want to talk about the manner of the final score, or the position the D was in, or the time remaining, it's all very different. to compare the two you have to zoom so far out the comp is meaningless, like they are both NFL teams, on D, late game after a lead change.. that's the comp.. ok well you don't need to invoke that game, to talk about our SB 58 overtime D.

Literally no one compared that game to this game besides you. The whole point was about football being a complementary game, game of inches and individual plays that shape a game in some way, shape or form.

Many of the iconic plays in history of football, let alone 49ers, don't happen if the other side (ie, defense or offense) didnt make some plays or things go their way.

Immaculate reception may not happen/matter if Stabler doesnt fumble inside his own 25

The David Tyree catch doesnt happen/matter if Asante Samuel catches the ball

The Drive might never happen if Montana's pick doesnt get dropped at the start of the fourth quarter

and so on and so forth

You for some reason focused on The Catch as direct comparison to this game, and while people are trying to tell you this you're covering your ears and keep going lalalalalalalalalalalalala

Pretty much par for the course with the man.

Originally posted by GoreGoreGore:

Sums up most of faithful arguments quite well.

Originally posted by 9ers4eva:

Originally posted by GoreGoreGore:

Sums up most of faithful arguments quite well.

lol

We live in a society where people want immediate gratification and feel obliged that they deserve what they want. This is only exemplified by social media and the internet which has produced constant dopamine highs in our brains a bit like being addicted to cocaine. We have de-evolved into a crazy lunatic race of monkeys that thinks that all it needs to do is shout and scream and hold our collective breath and we will get what we want. Life doesn't work like that. It's hard. it requires hard work and is full of constant disappointments that seemingly haunt us. But it is imperative in the human psyche to keep going. to keep trying to climb Mt Everest. To keep working hard, every morning getting out of bed with a smile on your face and just happy at the little things, happy at just being alive and pressing on regardless.

Originally posted by GoreGoreGore:

Personally I don't really subscribe to the whole thing about the majority always being right...in this case the poster just mischaracterized what was being said and for whatever reason is still trying to argue against an argument no one was making.