49ers Head Coach Kyle Shanahan Thread

Originally posted by 49erFaithful6:
amen, I don't think Patty found the endzone in the bowl vs Brady.

to be fair, the narrative that Mahomes hasn't played well last year and this is false. he won rings both times. they just don't have great wideouts. but he keeps getting the plays when they have to have them. he's doing some of his finest work. no one sees the field as well as Mahomes right now and he has a rocket arm and moves well to boot.

Brady was out there covering wide receivers?

Originally posted by Afrikan:
Tomlin's approach to decisions/coaching. And I don't mean mainly about starting Russ over Fields, but just players in general.

I like the quote "in this league you better have your foot on the gas at all times"

Why not stick w Justin Fields?
Whole answer from #Steelers Mike Tomlin pic.twitter.com/TNx1d7piXx

— 93.7 The Fan (@937theFan) October 15, 2024

now this isn't a Tomlin > Kyle type of thing, but I'm not sure Kyle gives off the same mentality when it comes to players and depth chart, or moving up in the depth chart.

how is Kyle not doing this? We had multiple rookies playing last game and making plays.

I like Tomlin he's a good coach, he inherited a Super Bowl winning roster, won super early in his career. He was handed a first ballot HOF QB. Then nothing after that.

His roster, which he has a massive say in…isn't remotely close to as good as SF's currently. He can toss around the roster and change QBs or whatever. He will go 9-8 and do nothing, much like it's been for him for over a decade.

I know this isn't a Kyle vs whomever thing, but how long does a SB win last for a HC? If Kyle won a SB in 2008 and nothing since then…would everyone in here love him as much as some do with Tomlin? No f**kng way,

Originally posted by SanDiego49er:
We have been over this a million times. You pick the QB that is available. Not always the best one. He had trash ownership (a little better now - learned lessons), terrible GM, garbage scouting department. It was all Harbaugh. The whole show. No support there. Justin Smith and Aldon Smith were both injured going in. We couldn't get pass rush. Flacco was throwing bombs. Had they been healthy we win. Flacco was hardly bad in that time period. He was a very good QB actually.

With this super team Harbaugh wins. Which Shanahan can't. That's the difference.

Why'd it take him 9 years to win at Michigan then? Dont go for the no talent excuse as Brady Hoke had two top 5 recruiting classes before he was fired. Talent wasn't lacking.

Harbaugh was telling his father before the draft Kap was the guy he wanted. He was 100% all in.

Originally posted by 9ers4eva:

Originally posted by SanDiego49er:
We have been over this a million times. You pick the QB that is available. Not always the best one. He had trash ownership (a little better now - learned lessons), terrible GM, garbage scouting department. It was all Harbaugh. The whole show. No support there. Justin Smith and Aldon Smith were both injured going in. We couldn't get pass rush. Flacco was throwing bombs. Had they been healthy we win. Flacco was hardly bad in that time period. He was a very good QB actually.

With this super team Harbaugh wins. Which Shanahan can't. That's the difference.

Why'd it take him 9 years to win at Michigan then?

Harbaugh was telling his father before the draft Kap was the guy he wanted. He was 100% all in.

Harbaugh won the Championship at Michigan. A team that hadn't won anything in decades. He won the Championship at University of San Diego Torreros. Never won anything before him. At their division level when he was there. Shanahan never won anything. Just fancy shifts and motions.

Originally posted by SanDiego49er:
Harbaugh won the Championship at Michigan. A team that hadn't won anything in decades. He won the Championship at University of San Diego Torreros. Never won anything before him. At their division level when he was there. Shanahan never won anything. Just fancy shifts and motions.

Didn't take Kirby Smart 9 years and Georgia hadn't won anything in decades.

Triple A football also doesn't equal the NFL.

Originally posted by 9ers4eva:

Originally posted by SanDiego49er:
Harbaugh won the Championship at Michigan. A team that hadn't won anything in decades. He won the Championship at University of San Diego Torreros. Never won anything before him. At their division level when he was there. Shanahan never won anything. Just fancy shifts and motions.

Didn't take Kirby Smart 9 years and Georgia hadn't won anything in decades.

Triple A football also doesn't equal the NFL.

Come on man. SEC has a lot more talent and recruiting base than what he was working with. Be real here. He did it as a labor of love. His school. Him and Brady wanted to return Michigan to winning. They both talked about that. He wins multiple in a good SEC program with that recruiting ground they got. He would have better athletes there. It's amazing he was able to win at Michigan.

Originally posted by SanDiego49er:
Come on man. SEC has a lot more talent and recruiting base than what he was working with. Be real here. He did it as a labor of love. His school. Him and Brady wanted to return Michigan to winning. They both talked about that. He wins multiple in a good SEC program with that recruiting ground they got. He would have better athletes there. It's amazing he was able to win at Michigan.

Michigan is the winningest school of all freaking time. Yah what a tough job.

Originally posted by 9ers4eva:

Originally posted by SanDiego49er:
Come on man. SEC has a lot more talent and recruiting base than what he was working with. Be real here. He did it as a labor of love. His school. Him and Brady wanted to return Michigan to winning. They both talked about that. He wins multiple in a good SEC program with that recruiting ground they got. He would have better athletes there. It's amazing he was able to win at Michigan.

Michigan is the winningest school of all freaking time. Yah what a tough job.

Not in recent times until Harbaugh came there. They were way down, going through coach after coach, never winning anything. But they won when he got there. Says it all.

Originally posted by SanDiego49er:
We have been over this a million times. You pick the QB that is available. Not always the best one. He had trash ownership (a little better now - learned lessons), terrible GM, garbage scouting department. It was all Harbaugh. The whole show. No support there. Justin Smith and Aldon Smith were both injured going in. We couldn't get pass rush. Flacco was throwing bombs. Had they been healthy we win. Flacco was hardly bad in that time period. He was a very good QB actually.

With this super team Harbaugh wins. Which Shanahan can't. That's the difference.

No one told him to move up for Kap. Harbs loved him.

https://www.usatoday.com/story/gameon/2013/02/01/colin-kaepernick-2011-draft-jim-harbaugh-jack-coaches-show/1885181/

Jim legit thought he was the best player in the 2011 draft.

So hold on….you get to provide context to why Harbs blew his SB BUT you can't don't that with Kyle?

Joe Flacco is NOT Mahomes. Baltimore didn't have a 1K receiver on that team in 2012. SF was the favorites to win that SB in 2012. They HAD the better team.

give me a f**king break. You're being so god damn hypocritical. I swear you have to be trolling.

The one time Harbs won anything he cheated and had to leave college football because of it. Dude has complete control of everything wherever he goes.

Originally posted by 9ers4eva:
Didn't take Kirby Smart 9 years and Georgia hadn't won anything in decades.

Triple A football also doesn't equal the NFL.

Jim cheated and left because of it when he won we gonna talk about HS football too 🤣

Originally posted by 9ers4eva:

Originally posted by SanDiego49er:
Harbaugh won the Championship at Michigan. A team that hadn't won anything in decades. He won the Championship at University of San Diego Torreros. Never won anything before him. At their division level when he was there. Shanahan never won anything. Just fancy shifts and motions.

Didn't take Kirby Smart 9 years and Georgia hadn't won anything in decades.

Triple A football also doesn't equal the NFL.

Nothing wrong with winning on that division level. They are all on an equal playing field. They were worse before he got there and after he left. They won when he was there. Says it all.

Originally posted by SanDiego49er:
Not in recent times until Harbaugh came there. They were way down, going through coach after coach, never winning anything. But they won when he got there. Says it all.

Same with Georgia. And yes he won after nearly a decade. After pulling an epic choke job to a vastly inferior TCU. Yet somehow Kyle should be fired for losing to a dynasty.

Shoudlnt take elite coaches 13 years in college to win a title. To then pretend that guy could win 3 SBs is even more ridiculous.

Originally posted by SanDiego49er:
Not in recent times until Harbaugh came there. They were way down, going through coach after coach, never winning anything. But they won when he got there. Says it all.

If he ever comes back to college football he will be suspended for being a cheater. That's the dude you're defending.

Originally posted by SanDiego49er:
Nothing wrong with winning on that division level. They are all on an equal playing field. They were worse before he got there and after he left. They won when he was there. Says it all.

Didn't say there was. But it's AAA football. The vast majority of top pro coaches would dominate the college game. See Nick Saban.

Originally posted by 9ers4eva:
Same with Georgia. And yes he won after nearly a decade. After pulling an epic choke job to a vastly inferior TCU. Yet somehow Kyle should be fired for losing to a dynasty.

Shoudlnt take elite coaches 13 years in college to win a title. To then pretend that guy could win 3 SBs is even more ridiculous.

He couldn't even beat his brother with a vastly superior team vs Joe Flacco lol.

never mind the RZ s**t show vs Seattle in the NFCC.

dude can't be defending Jim and s**tting on Kyle. The most hypocritical s**t ever.

Jim is a college HC anyway. Problem is he can't coach there anymore.