49ers Head Coach Kyle Shanahan Thread

Originally posted by SanDiego49er:
Shana_FANS missed the MONUMENTAL collapses he had in 3 solid Super Bowls. With leads. Shany is DIRECTLY responsible for each collapse.

Stop trolling.

Originally posted by captveg:

Originally posted by SanDiego49er:
Shana_FANS have NOTHING to stand on. So the point to previous coaches thinking they got something there. If they actually had wins they could point to they would point to that.

Stop trolling.

Sadly he's not trolling

Originally posted by Hoovtrain:

Originally posted by captveg:

Originally posted by SanDiego49er:
Shana_FANS have NOTHING to stand on. So the point to previous coaches thinking they got something there. If they actually had wins they could point to they would point to that.

Stop trolling.

Sadly he's not trolling

Nah, he is. Having a point of view is one thing. Having a delusional point of view when you have also shown reasonable thought on other topics is trolling.

Originally posted by DrEll:
Why are Kyle's fans bashing on Jim Harbaugh ? If the best defense for Kyle is "well Jim lost a SB too", that's pretty sad. But it's a fair comparison bc Kyle doesn't not belong in the upper echelon of the 49er coaching tree. If anything he'll go down in infamy similar to Marv Levy…

One of the first things you've got right here. Accidentally of course, lol.

Jim Harbaugh was and is a very good coach. So is Kyle Shanahan.

Originally posted by captveg:
Nah, he is. Having a point of view is one thing. Having a delusional point of view when you have also shown reasonable thought on other topics is trolling.

no coach has 100 approval rating from the fans. even some KC fan is probably saying time to move on, for some reason. 100 approval is pretty much impossible.

Originally posted by 49erFaithful6:

Originally posted by captveg:
Nah, he is. Having a point of view is one thing. Having a delusional point of view when you have also shown reasonable thought on other topics is trolling.

no coach has 100 approval rating from the fans. even some KC fan is probably saying time to move on, for some reason. 100 approval is pretty much impossible.

It's reasonable to be disappointed that Shanahan hasn't pulled off a SB win, and even to think there may be a guy out there who could do better.

It's irrational to say Shanahan is a bad coach, that pretty much any other coach could do better, and to think Shanahan has no chance of ever winning a SB. Again, people said this in Philly about Reid around 2009 after losing 4 NFC CGs and a SB. The ability is clearly there with Shanahan, and nobody knows the future, but any reasonable person would see his odds of winning a SB vs. the average coach candidate is better.

It's outright trolling to claim Harbaugh is a better NFL coach because of college victories.

Originally posted by CharlieSheen:

Originally posted by DrEll:
Why are Kyle's fans bashing on Jim Harbaugh ? If the best defense for Kyle is "well Jim lost a SB too", that's pretty sad. But it's a fair comparison bc Kyle doesn't not belong in the upper echelon of the 49er coaching tree. If anything he'll go down in infamy similar to Marv Levy…

28-3, 10 point leads, record in close games. if Kyle doesn't win he will surpass all the others. He will be sitting on the throne with our teams f**king logo on his hat. I don't get why people think that's something we want to deal with

Exactly. Just find it comical to bash Jim Harbaugh just to make Kyle look better. I guess they'll go for Seifert next. Not a good coach just had good players around him to win SBs.

as pointed out, Kyle is competing for worst tenure on a championship caliber team. He's starting creep toward Marv Levy…

Originally posted by DrEll:

Originally posted by CharlieSheen:

Originally posted by DrEll:
Why are Kyle's fans bashing on Jim Harbaugh ? If the best defense for Kyle is "well Jim lost a SB too", that's pretty sad. But it's a fair comparison bc Kyle doesn't not belong in the upper echelon of the 49er coaching tree. If anything he'll go down in infamy similar to Marv Levy…

28-3, 10 point leads, record in close games. if Kyle doesn't win he will surpass all the others. He will be sitting on the throne with our teams f**king logo on his hat. I don't get why people think that's something we want to deal with

Exactly. Just find it comical to bash Jim Harbaugh just to make Kyle look better. I guess they'll go for Seifert next. Not a good coach just had good players around him to win SBs.

as pointed out, Kyle is competing for worst tenure on a championship caliber team. He's starting creep toward Marv Levy…

Siefert was far better than this. He won twice. You never win with Shanahan. But yeah it's dumb to keep bringing up Harbaugh. Who is a hands down better coach. Just to prop up their guy who can't win. It just ends up making him look even worse.

Originally posted by DrEll:

Originally posted by CharlieSheen:

Originally posted by DrEll:
Why are Kyle's fans bashing on Jim Harbaugh ? If the best defense for Kyle is "well Jim lost a SB too", that's pretty sad. But it's a fair comparison bc Kyle doesn't not belong in the upper echelon of the 49er coaching tree. If anything he'll go down in infamy similar to Marv Levy…

28-3, 10 point leads, record in close games. if Kyle doesn't win he will surpass all the others. He will be sitting on the throne with our teams f**king logo on his hat. I don't get why people think that's something we want to deal with

Exactly. Just find it comical to bash Jim Harbaugh just to make Kyle look better. I guess they'll go for Seifert next.

what's comical is you're too ignorant to know the difference

Originally posted by SanDiego49er:
Siefert was far better than this. He won twice. You never win with Shanahan. But yeah it's dumb to keep bringing up Harbaugh. Who is a hands down better coach. Just to prop up their guy who can't win. It just ends up making him look even worse.

Seifert was along for the ride. he wasn't on the KS level

Originally posted by 49erFaithful6:

Originally posted by SanDiego49er:
Siefert was far better than this. He won twice. You never win with Shanahan. But yeah it's dumb to keep bringing up Harbaugh. Who is a hands down better coach. Just to prop up their guy who can't win. It just ends up making him look even worse.

Seifert was along for the ride. he wasn't on the KS level

He's far better than Shany who NEVER won anything. Shany needs 3 solid Super Bowl victories to surpass him. We both know that will NEVER happen. Not in 100 years.

Originally posted by 49erFaithful6:
i needed a laugh today thanks

That's when you know you have no rebuttal. Good talk. Moving on.

Originally posted by SanDiego49er:

Originally posted by 49erFaithful6:

Originally posted by SanDiego49er:
Siefert was far better than this. He won twice. You never win with Shanahan. But yeah it's dumb to keep bringing up Harbaugh. Who is a hands down better coach. Just to prop up their guy who can't win. It just ends up making him look even worse.

Seifert was along for the ride. he wasn't on the KS level

He's far better than Shany who NEVER won anything. Shany needs 3 solid Super Bowl victories to surpass him. We both know that will NEVER happen. Not in 100 years.

Seifert inherited maybe the best NFL team of all time. that team was practically coaching itself in 89. in 90, 91, 92, 93, we came short. it took some HOF and PB level mercenaries saddling up with us to win 94. Seifert we saw him leave SF he was like 1-15. Kyle can coach circles around him, imo. I was happy we moved on from Seifert, it was time. Mooch was pretty fun and some fresh air.

Originally posted by captveg:

Originally posted by Hoovtrain:

Originally posted by captveg:

Originally posted by SanDiego49er:
Shana_FANS have NOTHING to stand on. So the point to previous coaches thinking they got something there. If they actually had wins they could point to they would point to that.

Stop trolling.

Sadly he's not trolling

Nah, he is. Having a point of view is one thing. Having a delusional point of view when you have also shown reasonable thought on other topics is trolling.

Siefert > Shanahan

Harbaugh > Shanahan

Belichick > Shanahan

Payton > Shanahan

It is what it is.