There are 340 users in the forums
Originally posted by SanDiego49er:
He's far better than Shany who NEVER won anything. Shany needs 3 solid Super Bowl victories to surpass him. We both know that will NEVER happen. Not in 100 years.
Originally posted by SanDiego49er:
Siefert > Shanahan
Harbaugh > Shanahan
Belichick > Shanahan
Payton > Shanahan
It is what it is.
Originally posted by NYniner85:
Originally posted by SanDiego49er:
He's far better than Shany who NEVER won anything. Shany needs 3 solid Super Bowl victories to surpass him. We both know that will NEVER happen. Not in 100 years.
Harbs NEVER won s**t when he was here…you f**king love him.
Quit being dumb
Originally posted by captveg:
It's reasonable to be disappointed that Shanahan hasn't pulled off a SB win, and even to think there may be a guy out there who could do better.
It's irrational to say Shanahan is a bad coach, that pretty much any other coach could do better, and to think Shanahan has no chance of ever winning a SB. Again, people said this in Philly about Reid around 2009 after losing 4 NFC CGs and a SB. The ability is clearly there with Shanahan, and nobody knows the future, but any reasonable person would see his odds of winning a SB vs. the average coach candidate is better.
It's outright trolling to claim Harbaugh is a better NFL coach because of college victories.
Originally posted by SanDiego49er:
Coach Jim Harbaugh won the CHAMPIONSHIP at multiple different levels. USD Torreros and Michigan. He also made the NFC Championship and Super Bowl with KRAP and AL_EXCUSES. Which is beyond incredible. You should not be able to do that.
Shany = participation trophy. Never won anything anywhere. Always chokes away leads in the big games. Lost 3 solid Super Bowls with leads.
Originally posted by NYniner85:
How many championships did he win here? No one cares what he did in the pioneer league. No one cares what he did 9 years after he left here. Even though he lost 6 straight bowl games
what did he do when he was the HEAD COACH of the 49ERS?! Answer me.
he choked in the biggest games that's what.
Originally posted by SmokeyJoe:funny that SD was full homer on Smith.. the way he was with jimmy
Originally posted by NYniner85:
How many championships did he win here? No one cares what he did in the pioneer league. No one cares what he did 9 years after he left here. Even though he lost 6 straight bowl games
what did he do when he was the HEAD COACH of the 49ERS?! Answer me.
he choked in the biggest games that's what.
He rid of us of Aleck Smith on the fly, while winning games. That felt like the equivalent of a 3-peat at the time, lol.
Originally posted by SmokeyJoe:
Originally posted by NYniner85:
How many championships did he win here? No one cares what he did in the pioneer league. No one cares what he did 9 years after he left here. Even though he lost 6 straight bowl games
what did he do when he was the HEAD COACH of the 49ERS?! Answer me.
he choked in the biggest games that's what.
He rid of us of Aleck Smith on the fly, while winning games. That felt like the equivalent of a 3-peat at the time, lol.
Originally posted by SanDiego49er:
Siefert > Shanahan
Harbaugh > Shanahan
Belichick > Shanahan
Payton > Shanahan
It is what it is.
Originally posted by NYniner85:
Originally posted by captveg:
It's reasonable to be disappointed that Shanahan hasn't pulled off a SB win, and even to think there may be a guy out there who could do better.
It's irrational to say Shanahan is a bad coach, that pretty much any other coach could do better, and to think Shanahan has no chance of ever winning a SB. Again, people said this in Philly about Reid around 2009 after losing 4 NFC CGs and a SB. The ability is clearly there with Shanahan, and nobody knows the future, but any reasonable person would see his odds of winning a SB vs. the average coach candidate is better.
It's outright trolling to claim Harbaugh is a better NFL coach because of college victories.
AND when your whole fire shanahan debate is based around "choking" BUT you love Harbs and defend him at all costs….for losing 2 NFCCs and a SB while the HC of SF. Has to be trolling, no one is that dumb.
Originally posted by DrEll:
Originally posted by SanDiego49er:
Siefert > Shanahan
Harbaugh > Shanahan
Belichick > Shanahan
Payton > Shanahan
It is what it is.
Seifert won 2 SBs. He was the defensive architect for most of those SB teams. Give Kyle those rosters I'm willing to bet he botches those chances. But again, it was predictable that the Shanahan supporters would go ahead and attack a 2 time SB winner. Not to mention 2 additional SB trophies as DC of the Niners. It's quite pathetic what the Kyle cult has become. Bashing EddieD. Bashing Seifert. Bashing Harbaugh.
Originally posted by SanDiego49er:
Siefert was far better than this. He won twice. You never win with Shanahan. But yeah it's dumb to keep bringing up Harbaugh. Who is a hands down better coach. Just to prop up their guy who can't win. It just ends up making him look even worse.
Originally posted by SanDiego49er:
He's far better than Shany who NEVER won anything. Shany needs 3 solid Super Bowl victories to surpass him. We both know that will NEVER happen. Not in 100 years.
Originally posted by SanDiego49er:
Siefert > Shanahan
Harbaugh > Shanahan
Belichick > Shanahan
Payton > Shanahan
It is what it is.
Originally posted by SanDiego49er:
Coach Jim Harbaugh won the CHAMPIONSHIP at multiple different levels. USD Torreros and Michigan. He also made the NFC Championship and Super Bowl with KRAP and AL_EXCUSES. Which is beyond incredible. You should not be able to do that.
Shany = participation trophy. Never won anything anywhere. Always chokes away leads in the big games. Lost 3 solid Super Bowls with leads.
Originally posted by Bringbackedjr:
The best predictor of future performance is past performance. This is not absolute especially if one learns from past mistakes, adjusts and improves. I personally would love for him to do that but he hasn't so all we have to go on is his actual performance which does include post season success sans a championship but it also includes ongoing mismanagement of games and failure to perform when coaching matters most-Close games of major consequence. Kyle disciples think Kyle criticism is limited to this forum.. Sorry to say it's not. Take a look at cbs coach rankings. ESPN. Etc etc. they credit his accomplishments but they also share his weaknesses including his inability to win the big game. His reputation as a genius is fading. At some point ownership will lose patience and move on. And for all of you who just repeat the same talking point— and who would you want to replace him——
bill belacheat
Ben Johnson
Bobby Slowik
Mike Macdonald
Brian Flores
spags
Kyle is not the one and only for the 49ers. There are choices now and there will be choices in the future so please stop repeating that played out, weak ass threat.
Originally posted by SanDiego49er:
Coach Jim Harbaugh won the CHAMPIONSHIP at multiple different levels. USD Torreros and Michigan. He also made the NFC Championship and Super Bowl with KRAP and AL_EXCUSES. Which is beyond incredible. You should not be able to do that.
Shany = participation trophy. Never won anything anywhere. Always chokes away leads in the big games. Lost 3 solid Super Bowls with leads.
