49ers Head Coach Kyle Shanahan Thread

Originally posted by Bringbackedjr:
Let resume the discussion when we are 5-7. We are looking at 3 for sure losses. Detroit packers bills. We seem to always f**k up against the bears. Maybe we beat the fish. There is one more win. Cards and LA already beat us but I will play along and say we win one of those. Not enough for the post season. Not enough for a winning season. Best realistic case 8-9. Highly possible 7-10. Possible 6-11.

if the Niners beat GB this weekend will you stop posting for the rest of the season?

Originally posted by Bringbackedjr:

Originally posted by 49AllTheTime:

Originally posted by Bringbackedjr:
The film shows the team failing. The record proves that. The film shows him calling the same busted plays. The film shows his team making stupid errors.. repeatedly.. the film does not show him doing anything different. Past success is just the past.. it's not what matters right now. Today. This season. In case you missed it we are not in the playoff picture let along a conference championship. Again, you dismiss facts and lay it all on execution. Ok. Why is his team not executing? What is he doing to change that? I can live with that if it's because we don't have talent. But we do have talent. A lot of talent and we aren't doing s**t with it. It's his role to maximize the talent. Do you think he is doing that this year?

you know that's BS right.. just in the Purdy thread it shows how wrong you are and the plays are there.. just not executed

also 5-5 is not failing. we were 5-5 in 2021 also and had 500 or <500 the year before when starting out the season. So it's not entirely over.

Let resume the discussion when we are 5-7. We are looking at 3 for sure losses. Detroit packers bills. We seem to always f**k up against the bears. Maybe we beat the fish. There is one more win. Cards and LA already beat us but I will play along and say we win one of those. Not enough for the post season. Not enough for a winning season. Best realistic case 8-9. Highly possible 7-10. Possible 6-11.

which could happen and the odds show it favorably happening.

But this season wasn't/isn't the seasons like before. It was doomed before training camp started. Kyle's scheme is heavily decisive on the QB ability. Hopefully next year we get back to normal

Originally posted by 49AllTheTime:

Originally posted by Bringbackedjr:

Originally posted by 49AllTheTime:

Originally posted by Bringbackedjr:
The film shows the team failing. The record proves that. The film shows him calling the same busted plays. The film shows his team making stupid errors.. repeatedly.. the film does not show him doing anything different. Past success is just the past.. it's not what matters right now. Today. This season. In case you missed it we are not in the playoff picture let along a conference championship. Again, you dismiss facts and lay it all on execution. Ok. Why is his team not executing? What is he doing to change that? I can live with that if it's because we don't have talent. But we do have talent. A lot of talent and we aren't doing s**t with it. It's his role to maximize the talent. Do you think he is doing that this year?

you know that's BS right.. just in the Purdy thread it shows how wrong you are and the plays are there.. just not executed

also 5-5 is not failing. we were 5-5 in 2021 also and had 500 or <500 the year before when starting out the season. So it's not entirely over.

Let resume the discussion when we are 5-7. We are looking at 3 for sure losses. Detroit packers bills. We seem to always f**k up against the bears. Maybe we beat the fish. There is one more win. Cards and LA already beat us but I will play along and say we win one of those. Not enough for the post season. Not enough for a winning season. Best realistic case 8-9. Highly possible 7-10. Possible 6-11.

which could happen and the odds show it favorably happening.

But this season wasn't/isn't the seasons like before. It was doomed before training camp started. Kyle's scheme is heavily decisive on the QB ability. Hopefully next year we get back to normal

I don't know what you have posted in other threads.

Why was this season doomed before training camp started?

You said "Kyle's scheme is heavily decisive on the QB ability". Are you a Brock supporter or do you not like him?

Thanks in advance for elaborating and explaining your opinion.

Originally posted by boast:

Originally posted by Bringbackedjr:
Let resume the discussion when we are 5-7. We are looking at 3 for sure losses. Detroit packers bills. We seem to always f**k up against the bears. Maybe we beat the fish. There is one more win. Cards and LA already beat us but I will play along and say we win one of those. Not enough for the post season. Not enough for a winning season. Best realistic case 8-9. Highly possible 7-10. Possible 6-11.

if the Niners beat GB this weekend will you stop posting for the rest of the season?

No. If we win Sunday I will still post. I will be here rain or shine speaking my mind. Post when we win. Post when we lose. Post when we tie. Deal with it.

Originally posted by Heroism:
Fantastic discussion and explanation of the current issues by the most knowledgeable football media member in the Bay Area.

Bump. I don't want this video to get lost in the shuffle. Any Niner fan wanting to learn more about the current struggles needs to watch this.

Some of the ignorance and shortsightedness of the people that think Kyle can easily be replaced for someone better is laughable. And in my opinion has no common sense to realize the actual success that we are experiencing as fans as well as the 49ers franchise.
Let's start with who do you think he can be replaced with.
Bill belichick: washed and out of date. a total product of Tom Brady sucked as a coach before Brady and then again after.
Mike Vrabel: really good coach, sure, but did he bring the Titans more success than Kyle has brought to the Niners. No. What is he going to do here bring here to bring the the team to the next level? And why didn't he bring the Titans to that level.
Ben Johnson: he's been a great OC for the Lions no doubt. Now explain to me his head coaching acumen/ philosophy? Why is he going to be better than Kyle?
Here is also some food for thought. Andy Reid, god's gift to coaching has only been this great since Patrick Mahomes. I don't know if he ever went to the Super Bowl as a head coach before Mahomes let alone win one.
Another thing to think about, take the coaches that are or will soon be available and ask yourself, what team would take one of those options over Kyle if given the option? Few to none.
to take it to the next step. How many teams right now would drop their current Head Coach for Kyle ? I'm willing to bet the majority would.
Is he perfect . No, but if you think you can do better you better be certain about who you are going to replace him with.

Originally posted by Andra:
Here is also some food for thought. Andy Reid, god's gift to coaching has only been this great since Patrick Mahomes. I don't know if he ever went to the Super Bowl as a head coach before Mahomes let alone win one.

Reid went to five NFC Championship Games with the Eagles: 2001, 2002, 2003, 2004, 2008. Only won the 2004 game, then lost the SB to the Patriots. McNabb was the QB for all five.

Originally posted by captveg:

Originally posted by Andra:
Here is also some food for thought. Andy Reid, god's gift to coaching has only been this great since Patrick Mahomes. I don't know if he ever went to the Super Bowl as a head coach before Mahomes let alone win one.

Reid went to five NFC Championship Games with the Eagles: 2001, 2002, 2003, 2004, 2008. Only won the 2004 game, then lost the SB to the Patriots. McNabb was the QB for all five.

Reid is an great coach. I don't get why anyone tries to argue that.

Originally posted by captveg:

Originally posted by Andra:
Here is also some food for thought. Andy Reid, god's gift to coaching has only been this great since Patrick Mahomes. I don't know if he ever went to the Super Bowl as a head coach before Mahomes let alone win one.

Reid went to five NFC Championship Games with the Eagles: 2001, 2002, 2003, 2004, 2008. Only won the 2004 game, then lost the SB to the Patriots. McNabb was the QB for all five.

Got it. Thanks for the info!

Originally posted by Cisco0623:

Originally posted by captveg:

Originally posted by Andra:
Here is also some food for thought. Andy Reid, god's gift to coaching has only been this great since Patrick Mahomes. I don't know if he ever went to the Super Bowl as a head coach before Mahomes let alone win one.

Reid went to five NFC Championship Games with the Eagles: 2001, 2002, 2003, 2004, 2008. Only won the 2004 game, then lost the SB to the Patriots. McNabb was the QB for all five.

Reid is an great coach. I don't get why anyone tries to argue that.

I agree and I don't think anyone would argue that. My point was that before Mahomes he and Kyle are the about the success wise. Meaning I think Kyle is a great coach as well

Originally posted by Andra:
Some of the ignorance and shortsightedness of the people that think Kyle can easily be replaced for someone better is laughable. And in my opinion has no common sense to realize the actual success that we are experiencing as fans as well as the 49ers franchise.
Let's start with who do you think he can be replaced with.
Bill belichick: washed and out of date. a total product of Tom Brady sucked as a coach before Brady and then again after.
Mike Vrabel: really good coach, sure, but did he bring the Titans more success than Kyle has brought to the Niners. No. What is he going to do here bring here to bring the the team to the next level? And why didn't he bring the Titans to that level.
Ben Johnson: he's been a great OC for the Lions no doubt. Now explain to me his head coaching acumen/ philosophy? Why is he going to be better than Kyle?
Here is also some food for thought. Andy Reid, god's gift to coaching has only been this great since Patrick Mahomes. I don't know if he ever went to the Super Bowl as a head coach before Mahomes let alone win one.
Another thing to think about, take the coaches that are or will soon be available and ask yourself, what team would take one of those options over Kyle if given the option? Few to none.
to take it to the next step. How many teams right now would drop their current Head Coach for Kyle ? I'm willing to bet the majority would.
Is he perfect . No, but if you think you can do better you better be certain about who you are going to replace him with.

Your right that's what so frustrating....

Originally posted by GoreGoreGore:

Originally posted by RiceOwensStokes:

Originally posted by Hoovtrain:

Originally posted by DrEll:

Originally posted by GoreGoreGore:

Originally posted by Kolohe:

Originally posted by DrEll:

Originally posted by Kolohe:

Originally posted by 9erson3:

Originally posted by DrEll:

Originally posted by Kolohe:

Originally posted by DrEll:

Originally posted by 49AllTheTime:

Originally posted by 49erFaithful6:

Originally posted by PatandBow:
100% agree. Makes you wonder if the Super Bowl's we were in would have had a different outcome if the NFL was against betting.

i don't wonder about that. we got beat.

Due to some ref influence

Will blame the refs.
Won't blame the head coach.

wow

Tell me are you allowed to call two timeouts in a row?

No you're not. I'm not saying refs are infallible, but to me the more concerning stat is:

125 coaches have had 40+ regular season games decided by 7 points or fewer. #49ers coach Kyle Shanahan's .396 win percentage in those games ranks 118th

— Josh Dubow (@JoshDubowAP) November 18, 2024

118th out of 125. That's damning.
Not sure why that doesn't irk some of you

If we have to rely on a single ref call to win a game we have greater issues. How bout we get better on offense and score more points. The ref whining each week is insane.

Who says we have to rely on calls, we're talking about the fact that a back to back timeout was allowed. Aren't you whining all the same coming in here whining about scoring more points?

No, he's right. Blaming the refs for a single call when we could've ended this game multiple times in the second half sounds like whining from a Shanafan. It's a garbage take, quite frankly.

Shhhh no one said you could talk. Sit your ass down.

Careful, these guys are very soft in here and go cry to the mods

Some of us have jobs. Got bigger things to worry about than internet bullies

Riiiiigt. You log on at 5am and spend your day doing nothing but ragging on Kyle shanahan 🤣

Live look at Gore owning " s" on the webzone

I've been using that pic for SanDiego for many years now, don't steal my jokes

I always picture Love on the Spectrum with him

Originally posted by Cisco0623:

Originally posted by captveg:

Originally posted by Andra:
Here is also some food for thought. Andy Reid, god's gift to coaching has only been this great since Patrick Mahomes. I don't know if he ever went to the Super Bowl as a head coach before Mahomes let alone win one.

Reid went to five NFC Championship Games with the Eagles: 2001, 2002, 2003, 2004, 2008. Only won the 2004 game, then lost the SB to the Patriots. McNabb was the QB for all five.

Reid is an great coach. I don't get why anyone tries to argue that.

Correct. And Shanahan's resume with the 49ers is already better than Reid's resume with the Eagles. So what does that make Shanahan?

Originally posted by PatandBow:
I don't know what you have posted in other threads.

Why was this season doomed before training camp started?

You said "Kyle's scheme is heavily decisive on the QB ability". Are you a Brock supporter or do you not like him?

Thanks in advance for elaborating and explaining your opinion.

Started before camp and just snowballed

Greenlaw not healthy
CMC Madden cover
CMC holding out
Aiyuk holding out
Trent Holding
Feliciano our future Center injured
Drake Jackson
Eli Mitchell injury
CMC injury
Persall shot
Gross-matos knee
Etc
etc

I like Brock, but i can't say he's playing his best ball right now

Originally posted by Fanaticofnfl:

Originally posted by Cisco0623:

Originally posted by captveg:

Originally posted by Andra:
Here is also some food for thought. Andy Reid, god's gift to coaching has only been this great since Patrick Mahomes. I don't know if he ever went to the Super Bowl as a head coach before Mahomes let alone win one.

Reid went to five NFC Championship Games with the Eagles: 2001, 2002, 2003, 2004, 2008. Only won the 2004 game, then lost the SB to the Patriots. McNabb was the QB for all five.

Reid is an great coach. I don't get why anyone tries to argue that.

Correct. And Shanahan's resume with the 49ers is already better than Reid's resume with the Eagles. So what does that make Shanahan?

0-2 against Reid