LISTEN: 49ers Midseason Mailbag →

There are 132 users in the forums

DE Nick Bosa "Smaller Bear" NO POLITICS

Shop Find 49ers gear online
Originally posted by JTB1974:
Originally posted by Stanley:
They would definitely still have a shot to win the Super Bowl without Bosa

No they don't. Purdy would have to turn into Mahomes.

They won't even make the playoffs without Bosa
Originally posted by the_dynasty:
Originally posted by dj43:
...and what happens if Bosa is injured and misses a good part of the season? Now you can say goodbye to at least three key players in your future.
What happens if Patrick Mahomes gets injured and misses a good part of the season?

Same answer.

The Niners don't win a SB this year with no Bosa. As of right now, there is no better option for the team chemistry and chances at a SB (which also probably goes through #1 seed) to have Nick Bosa playing for them this year. This is clear to me. An equal player trade is out of question this late in the preseason.

So, give me an all pro player now to win now.

I've given my answer a couple of times already but I'll state it differently here.

I believe the two other agents are waiting to see who blinks first. I would be willing to wager that within 24 hours of the first of those three players signing, the other two would sign.

It isn't about the money. That is just talk. The money is close enough to do a deal, but no one wants to be the one to settle for a deal and see the other guy get $2M/yr right after. This if for bragging rights, not money. Unless Lynch and Jed decide to blow the lid off the market, which I would be shocked to see, Ayrault isn't going to sign until at least one of the other two signs first.
Originally posted by Shemp:
Originally posted by Fanaticofnfl:
Wednesday morning I'll officially hit the panic button. That's the first "game week" practice (today was a bonus practice).

Until then, I will hang on to hope he plays Week 1.

He could easily come back and then get a significant soft tissue injury that puts him out for weeks because he hasn't been practicing or playing all off season .

He could get hit by a bus, struck by lightning or eaten by a shark.
Thank god we are scoring 50 a game this season
Originally posted by JTB1974:
The guaranteed money is only a bad thing if he gets a career threatening injury or he somehow is just not the same player which is very unlikely. If Bosa signs a 5 year extension are the Niners really going to get rid of him in the next 6 years? It's not like he is approaching 30 and could fall off at any moment.

I find it funny that fans are in an uproar about his asking price when the team has been getting away with highway robbery in 3 of the last 4 years when it comes to Bosa's production compared to what he was making. How much was his cap when he won DROY? How much was it when he had 15 1/2 sacks 2 years ago? How much last season when he had 18 1/2 sacks and won DPOY?

They got a huge bargain the last 4 years and now it's time to pay him. Actually last 5 years because this season they are getting him at a bargain also.

None of that stuff matters. Other players were getting paid so Bosa could play on a good team. Now it is Bosa's turn to get paid while Purdy and the rest of the draft picks are being paid low.
Originally posted by raywm3:
Disappointed in both Bosa and the Niners. They should've prioritized this sooner, imo. But, starting to lose some love/respect for Bosa. I mean, c'mon bro. They offer you the highest contract offer ever and you still hold out and still want more? When you're technically under contract? Does the final year of an NFL contract even matter anymore?

Reading the tea leaves now it seems as if the 49ers have done one of what I thought they needed to do which was to put up more in guarantees than TJ Watt is receiving BUT the other thing was to supersede AD in annual dollars amount at $31M per. I am guessing Bosa wants 32 or 33 and the 49ers are at 28 or 29 and that is likely where they are getting the reports that the 49ers are about $4M dollars away from where Bosa wants them. The 49ers are likely trying to set the market where TJ Watt is as a OLB/DE while AD is at DT. This is likely the holdup and to be honest you can't fault either side. The 49ers are saying "Bosa you play on the end so I am gonna make you the highest paid end". Bosa is likely saying "bump that. I am the DPOY regardless of whether I am an end or not so pay me more per year than AD". My gut feeling is Bosa is right here but I get the the 49ers don't want to set precedent that players come in wanting to jump to the top of other positions than their own

This is gonna take some time but the 49ers have the leverage of having Bosa under contract for 3 more years if they so choose and holding out will only cost Bosa both time and money the longer he sits ala Crabtree
Originally posted by TD49ers:
Originally posted by FredFlintstone:
We ain't winning no gah damn SB without Bosa especially with this current group of ends. The depth and DE was already questionable with Bosa

Why not? Lots of SB winners dont have a top DE.

Don't think we'll generate enough pressure with this current group and against the elite qbs that's a death sentence
Originally posted by dj43:
I've given my answer a couple of times already but I'll state it differently here.

I believe the two other agents are waiting to see who blinks first. I would be willing to wager that within 24 hours of the first of those three players signing, the other two would sign.

It isn't about the money. That is just talk. The money is close enough to do a deal, but no one wants to be the one to settle for a deal and see the other guy get $2M/yr right after. This if for bragging rights, not money. Unless Lynch and Jed decide to blow the lid off the market, which I would be shocked to see, Ayrault isn't going to sign until at least one of the other two signs first.

who are the other 2? Jones and ?
Originally posted by FredFlintstone:
Don't think we'll generate enough pressure with this current group and against the elite qbs that's a death sentence

We will just have to score more plus we have a DC that knows how to blitz when needed
Originally posted by Pillbusta:
who are the other 2? Jones and ?

Brian Burns down in Carolina.
Originally posted by linkboy:
Originally posted by Pillbusta:
who are the other 2? Jones and ?

Brian Burns down in Carolina.

Gotcha. Thanks!
Originally posted by FredFlintstone:
Originally posted by TD49ers:
Originally posted by FredFlintstone:
We ain't winning no gah damn SB without Bosa especially with this current group of ends. The depth and DE was already questionable with Bosa

Why not? Lots of SB winners dont have a top DE.

Don't think we'll generate enough pressure with this current group and against the elite qbs that's a death sentence

Isnt Wilks a blitz guy?
Originally posted by Pillbusta:
Originally posted by dj43:
I've given my answer a couple of times already but I'll state it differently here.

I believe the two other agents are waiting to see who blinks first. I would be willing to wager that within 24 hours of the first of those three players signing, the other two would sign.

It isn't about the money. That is just talk. The money is close enough to do a deal, but no one wants to be the one to settle for a deal and see the other guy get $2M/yr right after. This if for bragging rights, not money. Unless Lynch and Jed decide to blow the lid off the market, which I would be shocked to see, Ayrault isn't going to sign until at least one of the other two signs first.

who are the other 2? Jones and ?

Bragging rights in relation to 'who blinks first' sounds like the agent holding back and in that case Bosa should tell his agent to get the deal done asap out of respect to his teammates who need him on the field.
Originally posted by Pillbusta:
Originally posted by raywm3:
Disappointed in both Bosa and the Niners. They should've prioritized this sooner, imo. But, starting to lose some love/respect for Bosa. I mean, c'mon bro. They offer you the highest contract offer ever and you still hold out and still want more? When you're technically under contract? Does the final year of an NFL contract even matter anymore?

Reading the tea leaves now it seems as if the 49ers have done one of what I thought they needed to do which was to put up more in guarantees than TJ Watt is receiving BUT the other thing was to supersede AD in annual dollars amount at $31M per. I am guessing Bosa wants 32 or 33 and the 49ers are at 28 or 29 and that is likely where they are getting the reports that the 49ers are about $4M dollars away from where Bosa wants them. The 49ers are likely trying to set the market where TJ Watt is as a OLB/DE while AD is at DT. This is likely the holdup and to be honest you can't fault either side. The 49ers are saying "Bosa you play on the end so I am gonna make you the highest paid end". Bosa is likely saying "bump that. I am the DPOY regardless of whether I am an end or not so pay me more per year than AD". My gut feeling is Bosa is right here but I get the the 49ers don't want to set precedent that players come in wanting to jump to the top of other positions than their own

This is gonna take some time but the 49ers have the leverage of having Bosa under contract for 3 more years if they so choose and holding out will only cost Bosa both time and money the longer he sits ala Crabtree

Well said and without knowing any of this for sure, I actually believe this could be true. Good points.
Originally posted by Pillbusta:
Originally posted by dj43:
I've given my answer a couple of times already but I'll state it differently here.

I believe the two other agents are waiting to see who blinks first. I would be willing to wager that within 24 hours of the first of those three players signing, the other two would sign.

It isn't about the money. That is just talk. The money is close enough to do a deal, but no one wants to be the one to settle for a deal and see the other guy get $2M/yr right after. This if for bragging rights, not money. Unless Lynch and Jed decide to blow the lid off the market, which I would be shocked to see, Ayrault isn't going to sign until at least one of the other two signs first.

who are the other 2? Jones and ?

Brian Burns of the Panthers.
Share 49ersWebzone