There are 164 users in the forums

Surprise Cut & Surprise Keep

Shop Find 49ers gear online
Originally posted by AB81Rules:
Originally posted by Jesusisreal:
Originally posted by AB81Rules:
Most of those surprise keeps are really surprises, AA is GTD $9.046M, Goodwin has most of his 2019 salary GTD. McKInnon has a lot of GTD money, we gain NOTHING by cutting him.

Jet will never agree to a settlement, he has a $2.6M Guarantee in 2020.

Ok new surprise cut: so it's not really a cut but a trade. Niners trade mullin to the colts for a 5th round pick in the 2020 draft. Shanahan goes all in for beatHard

That'd be a horrible trade IMO, no way I'd deal Mullens at all, I don't trust Beathard at QB.

What about a 4th pick?
Originally posted by DickNasty:
Originally posted by btthepunk:
Surprise (to some) keep: Joshua Garnett and Kaden Smith

Surprise cut: Julian Taylor

Stanford hater, Smith is a keeper

Lol I didn't even realize I put 2 Stanford guys on there.
Cut: Mckinnon
Keep: James jr
Originally posted by SamSung87:
Cut: Mckinnon
Keep: James jr

Again we aren't cutting McKinnon, we lose $2.6M as he has a $2.6M injury guarantee in 2020.
Originally posted by AB81Rules:
Originally posted by SamSung87:
Cut: Mckinnon
Keep: James jr

Again we aren't cutting McKinnon, we lose $2.6M as he has a $2.6M injury guarantee in 2020.

We shall see
Surprise cut- Colbert and Beathard

Surprise keep- Bourne, Garnett, and Skule.
[ Edited by LifelongNiner on Aug 29, 2019 at 8:00 PM ]
Originally posted by AB81Rules:
Originally posted by SamSung87:
Cut: Mckinnon
Keep: James jr

Again we aren't cutting McKinnon, we lose $2.6M as he has a $2.6M injury guarantee in 2020.

That's why it's called a "surprise"
Originally posted by SamSung87:
Originally posted by AB81Rules:
Originally posted by SamSung87:
Cut: Mckinnon
Keep: James jr

Again we aren't cutting McKinnon, we lose $2.6M as he has a $2.6M injury guarantee in 2020.

We shall see

You really think they'll waste $2.6M in cap space just to appease some fans?
Originally posted by AB81Rules:
Originally posted by SamSung87:
Originally posted by AB81Rules:
Originally posted by SamSung87:
Cut: Mckinnon
Keep: James jr

Again we aren't cutting McKinnon, we lose $2.6M as he has a $2.6M injury guarantee in 2020.

We shall see

You really think they'll waste $2.6M in cap space just to appease some fans?

No, but I do think that if the OP asks for a surprise cut/keep then I should include someone that I don't think that would be cut or kept... hence "surprise"
Originally posted by AB81Rules:
Originally posted by 9moon:
SURPRISE CUTS:
Julian Taylor
Jordan Matthews
Marcell Harris
Toilolo
D. Moore
Ashaair
Wilson

SURPRISE KEEPS:
Armstead
Ward
Williams
Bourne
Lee
Beathard
McKinnon
Goodwind
Celek

Most of those surprise keeps are really surprises, AA is GTD $9.046M, Goodwin has most of his 2019 salary GTD. McKInnon has a lot of GTD money, we gain NOTHING by cutting him.
Originally posted by Jesusisreal:
Surprise keep: Wilson RB
Cut injury settlement: Jet

Jet will never agree to a settlement, he has a $2.6M Guarantee in 2020.

actually, what I'm trying to say here is that i would very very SURPRISE if those guys on my KEEP list are KEPT !!!

THEY ALL NEED TO GO!!!
Originally posted by 9moon:
Originally posted by AB81Rules:
Originally posted by 9moon:
SURPRISE CUTS:
Julian Taylor
Jordan Matthews
Marcell Harris
Toilolo
D. Moore
Ashaair
Wilson

SURPRISE KEEPS:
Armstead
Ward
Williams
Bourne
Lee
Beathard
McKinnon
Goodwind
Celek

Most of those surprise keeps are really surprises, AA is GTD $9.046M, Goodwin has most of his 2019 salary GTD. McKInnon has a lot of GTD money, we gain NOTHING by cutting him.
Originally posted by Jesusisreal:
Surprise keep: Wilson RB
Cut injury settlement: Jet

Jet will never agree to a settlement, he has a $2.6M Guarantee in 2020.

actually, what I'm trying to say here is that i would very very SURPRISE if those guys on my KEEP list are KEPT !!!

THEY ALL NEED TO GO!!!

AA has been solid
Ward I agree
Williams is a solid Slot CB
Bourne agrees
Lee I like
Beathard agreed
McKinnon no, we lose $2.6M if we cut him, not worth it, take for instance Forrest Lamp has had knee injury issues for 2 years, and is finally playing for the Chargers, so I'm not given up on Jet, yet anyway.
Goodwin no, no other WR has his speed, and he's reliable
Celek agreed but won't happen unless he passes a physical, they don't save any cap room if he's injured.
I bet Dontae Johnson makes it, since he isn't playing tonight. I didn't like him before, but I must admit he had a good preseason
Originally posted by SamSung87:
Originally posted by AB81Rules:
Originally posted by SamSung87:
Originally posted by AB81Rules:
Originally posted by SamSung87:
Cut: Mckinnon
Keep: James jr

Again we aren't cutting McKinnon, we lose $2.6M as he has a $2.6M injury guarantee in 2020.

We shall see

You really think they'll waste $2.6M in cap space just to appease some fans?

No, but I do think that if the OP asks for a surprise cut/keep then I should include someone that I don't think that would be cut or kept... hence "surprise"

Its unrealistic. Might as well say Buckner.
Originally posted by thaakingd:
I bet Dontae Johnson makes it, since he isn't playing tonight. I didn't like him before, but I must admit he had a good preseason

He is playing, or did, he started at CB.
Originally posted by AB81Rules:
Originally posted by thaakingd:
I bet Dontae Johnson makes it, since he isn't playing tonight. I didn't like him before, but I must admit he had a good preseason

He is playing, or did, he started at CB.

Oh okay, I didn't even realize that. Good call. We'll see what happens.
Search Share 49ersWebzone