Originally posted by NYniner85:
Originally posted by 5thSFG:
Stopped reading after "saying he put the organization through hell is excessive". Take that one up with BA, who admittedly made it more difficult than it should have been. Perhaps you don't like my phrasing, but you're disagreeing with BA, not me.
let me know which wording you'd like for me to use when describing player conduct like holding out, holding in, demanding a trade, rejecting a trade, social media politicking, wearing wrong uniform to practice, and admittedly making the negations process more difficult than it needed to be. I'll use whatever wording you prefer, the end results are the same. We overpaid a guy that showed every indicator of someone only in it for themselves, and will not live up in the contract.
Horrible emotional posts? 🤣🤣. You were the biggest "resign BA" advocate on these boards and are having a hard time coming to terms with how badly that decision has cost us. Assume my emotional status all you want…. The only clearly wrong opinion on the topic was the one that advocated so strongly to get him resigned.
want to spend more time on how wrong you were? Or want to keep taking shots in the dark as to how I reached my conclusions that have, coincidentally enough, turned out to be correct?
im pretty versed in this type of debate… its how my wife argues.
I don't care how he goes about getting his cash. Maybe SF shouldn't have sat on their asses for months and instead did what needed to be done to get him in camp.
it's not like this is an isolated incident. This happens all the damn time with SF. So instead of blaming just the player take a look at the organization and how they do business.
If you look back at the draft with BA, I had my doubts about him. I wanted Lamb and or Ruggs. I got mock drafts showing this.
Hell yes I wanted to resign BA, why the f**k would you not? Dude was elite across the board and had improved every single year. This team needed to invest cash in young talent and guys like Deebo and Kittle were past their prime. The breakdown of how his cap hit woks fit perfectly for when Deebo left. Made all the sense in the world to pay him and continue the growth of a good young WR.
I don't have to assume your emotional status, you wrote it all down for everyone to read.
Dude 70% of the posts in here are whiny in the moment emotional responses with little to no actually thought. Those folks are NOT capable of having a conversation that involves nuances and the idea that they might not be right. I never said that was you….like I said I got no problem calling that s**t out, we all get emotional but damn man, let's stop making this place worse by the day.
I don't even know what you think you're right about? I mean is that what this is about? Instead of being upset we lost a good player and feel for a fellow 49er…it's a big f**k you for wanting to get paid? Not sure how you can say you're right because he got hurt? The ROI for damn near all these contracts isn't gonna be good. That's just professional sports as a whole.
lol now who's emotional. Relax pal, just a game.
youre pro ba, I'm not. Simple as that. As the overseer of board conduct, I figured you'd be able to figure that out. No need to drag it out.
we'd be in a better position had we pursued any other option than resigning him at the 13th hour. I'd hope most could agree on that.
I'll run my future posts through ChatGPT to remove all the human fingerprints for you… perhaps then you'll be able to respond to a post instead of all the ad hominems
i wasn't able to run this one through though…. Incoming attacks on the poster I'm sure. Fire away
[ Edited by 5thSFG on Oct 21, 2024 at 10:40 AM ]