There are 238 users in the forums

Brandon Aiyuk is a 49er! Pick #25, 2020 NFL Draft

Shop Find 49ers gear online
Originally posted by Hysterikal:
Originally posted by 49erKing:
From Chat (should be accurate) in no particular order

Adrian Peterson (Running Back)
  • Injury: Tore his ACL and MCL in his left knee in December 2011.
  • Recovery: Returned in 2012 to have an MVP season, rushing for 2,097 yards, just eight yards shy of breaking the NFL single-season record.
Carson Palmer (Quarterback)
  • Injury: Tore his ACL and MCL in his left knee during a 2006 playoff game.
  • Recovery: Made a strong return, playing several more years in the NFL and achieving a Second-Team All-Pro season in 2015 with the Arizona Cardinals.
Jordy Nelson (Wide Receiver)
  • Injury: Tore his ACL and MCL in his right knee during the 2015 preseason.
  • Recovery: Came back in 2016 with 97 receptions, 1,257 yards, and 14 touchdowns, earning Comeback Player of the Year honors.
Rob Gronkowski (Tight End)
  • Injury: Tore his ACL and MCL in his right knee in December 2013.
  • Recovery: Returned in 2014, dominating the league as a tight end and being named First-Team All-Pro.
Philip Rivers (Quarterback)
  • Injury: Tore his ACL and MCL in his right knee during the 2007 playoffs.
  • Recovery: Rivers famously played in the AFC Championship game just six days after the injury and went on to have a long, successful career without missing significant time due to knee issues afterward.
Wes Welker
  • Injury: Welker suffered a torn ACL and MCL in Week 17 of the 2009 season.
  • Recovery: He returned for the 2010 season, finishing with 86 receptions and over 800 yards, and later went on to post multiple 1,000-yard seasons with the Patriots.
Jerry Rice
  • Injury: Jerry Rice tore his ACL and MCL in 1997.
  • Recovery: Known for his legendary work ethic, Rice returned to the field in the same season but later fractured his kneecap, delaying a full comeback.
  • Post-Injury Performance: After fully recovering, he continued to play at a high level, posting several 1,000-yard seasons and cementing his legacy as the greatest receiver in NFL history.

Whats the point of this?

That all is not lost?
Originally posted by 49erKing:
Originally posted by Hysterikal:
Originally posted by 49erKing:
From Chat (should be accurate) in no particular order

Adrian Peterson (Running Back)
  • Injury: Tore his ACL and MCL in his left knee in December 2011.
  • Recovery: Returned in 2012 to have an MVP season, rushing for 2,097 yards, just eight yards shy of breaking the NFL single-season record.
Carson Palmer (Quarterback)
  • Injury: Tore his ACL and MCL in his left knee during a 2006 playoff game.
  • Recovery: Made a strong return, playing several more years in the NFL and achieving a Second-Team All-Pro season in 2015 with the Arizona Cardinals.
Jordy Nelson (Wide Receiver)
  • Injury: Tore his ACL and MCL in his right knee during the 2015 preseason.
  • Recovery: Came back in 2016 with 97 receptions, 1,257 yards, and 14 touchdowns, earning Comeback Player of the Year honors.
Rob Gronkowski (Tight End)
  • Injury: Tore his ACL and MCL in his right knee in December 2013.
  • Recovery: Returned in 2014, dominating the league as a tight end and being named First-Team All-Pro.
Philip Rivers (Quarterback)
  • Injury: Tore his ACL and MCL in his right knee during the 2007 playoffs.
  • Recovery: Rivers famously played in the AFC Championship game just six days after the injury and went on to have a long, successful career without missing significant time due to knee issues afterward.
Wes Welker
  • Injury: Welker suffered a torn ACL and MCL in Week 17 of the 2009 season.
  • Recovery: He returned for the 2010 season, finishing with 86 receptions and over 800 yards, and later went on to post multiple 1,000-yard seasons with the Patriots.
Jerry Rice
  • Injury: Jerry Rice tore his ACL and MCL in 1997.
  • Recovery: Known for his legendary work ethic, Rice returned to the field in the same season but later fractured his kneecap, delaying a full comeback.
  • Post-Injury Performance: After fully recovering, he continued to play at a high level, posting several 1,000-yard seasons and cementing his legacy as the greatest receiver in NFL history.

Whats the point of this?

That all is not lost?

Yeah saying all is lost is just sky is falling thinking. But to post a bunch of Hall of Famers, a dude catching passes from some of the GOATs and a immobile QB having good season after knee injuries isn't the same situation as Aiyuk. I think with modern medicine he will be back to being a productive receiver but the list of players who took a year or 2 to fully recover if at all is probably a lot longer than the guys who had huge years after a knee injury.
[ Edited by Hysterikal on Dec 29, 2024 at 9:45 AM ]
Originally posted by Hysterikal:
Yeah saying all is lost is just sky is falling thinking. But to post a bunch of Hall of Famers, a dude catching passes from some of the GOATs and a immobile QB having good season after knee injuries isn't the same situation as Aiyuk. I think with modern medicine he will be back to being a productive receiver but the list of players who took a year or 2 to fully recover if at all is probably a lot longer than the guys who had huge years after a knee injury.

Yep, I was just trying to alleviate some of the worry being displayed here, lol. Oh I'm sure the list is longer but I did specifically prompt Chat to list 'all-pros' that recovered from MCL & ACL tears. I don't even think this list is comprehensive looking at all-pros.
  • mayo49
  • Veteran
  • Posts: 64,601
This current conversation is lost in space.
What a mess to have all this money in this guy. He was never as good as Jamar Chase and Justin Jefferson. Or Ceedee Lamb for that matter. He was below that but a good player. Now this terrible injury and the huge cap hit. He might not be the same. But I hope for the best. I think they over paid him. Now we are on the hook for the guaranteed years which I believe is 3.
History of other players recovery isn't an indicator of how well Aiyuk will be able to play when he returns. I saw one estimate tht he may not be back until November. That would mean he missed camp and probably won't be in game shape. We saw that this season before he got hurt. The team can hope for the best but they need to plan for the worst.
Originally posted by eric_anthony:
Originally posted by RedGoldSquatch:
Not sure how people don't see he wasn't worth the money and was hot garbage BEFORE the injury. We should have absolutely traded him when he pulled the diva BS during negotiations. He is not now, never was, and never will be a $30M WR

Still better than Deebo

Sad but true. Deebo should be an outright cut.
Originally posted by Kolohe:
Originally posted by Hoovtrain:
Fingers crossed he comes back healthy. Between the skill set he brings to the table and the money they invested in him, gotta have him back.

I now appreciate him even more after this season.

I appreciate the 2023 BA. The 2024 BA is everything that was wrong with this football team this year. Overpaid, entitled, unprepared to play, and hurt.
  • Deebo
  • Veteran
  • Posts: 1,485
Hope he chokes on Popeyes
Originally posted by 49erKing:
From Chat (should be accurate) in no particular order

Adrian Peterson (Running Back)
  • Injury: Tore his ACL and MCL in his left knee in December 2011.
  • Recovery: Returned in 2012 to have an MVP season, rushing for 2,097 yards, just eight yards shy of breaking the NFL single-season record.
Carson Palmer (Quarterback)
  • Injury: Tore his ACL and MCL in his left knee during a 2006 playoff game.
  • Recovery: Made a strong return, playing several more years in the NFL and achieving a Second-Team All-Pro season in 2015 with the Arizona Cardinals.
Jordy Nelson (Wide Receiver)
  • Injury: Tore his ACL and MCL in his right knee during the 2015 preseason.
  • Recovery: Came back in 2016 with 97 receptions, 1,257 yards, and 14 touchdowns, earning Comeback Player of the Year honors.
Rob Gronkowski (Tight End)
  • Injury: Tore his ACL and MCL in his right knee in December 2013.
  • Recovery: Returned in 2014, dominating the league as a tight end and being named First-Team All-Pro.
Philip Rivers (Quarterback)
  • Injury: Tore his ACL and MCL in his right knee during the 2007 playoffs.
  • Recovery: Rivers famously played in the AFC Championship game just six days after the injury and went on to have a long, successful career without missing significant time due to knee issues afterward.
Wes Welker
  • Injury: Welker suffered a torn ACL and MCL in Week 17 of the 2009 season.
  • Recovery: He returned for the 2010 season, finishing with 86 receptions and over 800 yards, and later went on to post multiple 1,000-yard seasons with the Patriots.
Jerry Rice
  • Injury: Jerry Rice tore his ACL and MCL in 1997.
  • Recovery: Known for his legendary work ethic, Rice returned to the field in the same season but later fractured his kneecap, delaying a full comeback.
  • Post-Injury Performance: After fully recovering, he continued to play at a high level, posting several 1,000-yard seasons and cementing his legacy as the greatest receiver in NFL history.

I appreciate this post. Thank you. At the very least it's possible for him to overcome the injury and return to form.
Originally posted by Hysterikal:
Originally posted by 49erKing:
Originally posted by Hysterikal:
Originally posted by 49erKing:
From Chat (should be accurate) in no particular order

Adrian Peterson (Running Back)
  • Injury: Tore his ACL and MCL in his left knee in December 2011.
  • Recovery: Returned in 2012 to have an MVP season, rushing for 2,097 yards, just eight yards shy of breaking the NFL single-season record.
Carson Palmer (Quarterback)
  • Injury: Tore his ACL and MCL in his left knee during a 2006 playoff game.
  • Recovery: Made a strong return, playing several more years in the NFL and achieving a Second-Team All-Pro season in 2015 with the Arizona Cardinals.
Jordy Nelson (Wide Receiver)
  • Injury: Tore his ACL and MCL in his right knee during the 2015 preseason.
  • Recovery: Came back in 2016 with 97 receptions, 1,257 yards, and 14 touchdowns, earning Comeback Player of the Year honors.
Rob Gronkowski (Tight End)
  • Injury: Tore his ACL and MCL in his right knee in December 2013.
  • Recovery: Returned in 2014, dominating the league as a tight end and being named First-Team All-Pro.
Philip Rivers (Quarterback)
  • Injury: Tore his ACL and MCL in his right knee during the 2007 playoffs.
  • Recovery: Rivers famously played in the AFC Championship game just six days after the injury and went on to have a long, successful career without missing significant time due to knee issues afterward.
Wes Welker
  • Injury: Welker suffered a torn ACL and MCL in Week 17 of the 2009 season.
  • Recovery: He returned for the 2010 season, finishing with 86 receptions and over 800 yards, and later went on to post multiple 1,000-yard seasons with the Patriots.
Jerry Rice
  • Injury: Jerry Rice tore his ACL and MCL in 1997.
  • Recovery: Known for his legendary work ethic, Rice returned to the field in the same season but later fractured his kneecap, delaying a full comeback.
  • Post-Injury Performance: After fully recovering, he continued to play at a high level, posting several 1,000-yard seasons and cementing his legacy as the greatest receiver in NFL history.

Whats the point of this?

That all is not lost?

Yeah saying all is lost is just sky is falling thinking. But to post a bunch of Hall of Famers, a dude catching passes from some of the GOATs and a immobile QB having good season after knee injuries isn't the same situation as Aiyuk. I think with modern medicine he will be back to being a productive receiver but the list of players who took a year or 2 to fully recover if at all is probably a lot longer than the guys who had huge years after a knee injury.

The point is that it didn't affect their level of play after. We know Aiyuk isn't a hall of fame guy, at least not at this point. But he was an All Pro last year. So he could still come back and be the quality player we knew.
  • Kolohe
  • Hall of Fame
  • Posts: 62,728
Originally posted by Schulzy:
Originally posted by Kolohe:
Originally posted by Hoovtrain:
Fingers crossed he comes back healthy. Between the skill set he brings to the table and the money they invested in him, gotta have him back.

I now appreciate him even more after this season.

I appreciate the 2023 BA. The 2024 BA is everything that was wrong with this football team this year. Overpaid, entitled, unprepared to play, and hurt.

Yah I'm over that already, no reason to dwell on that stuff. I hope he comes back with a vengeance next season.
Originally posted by Deebo:
Hope he chokes on Popeyes

aren't you the guy who wanted Kyle dead after the Arizona game? Dude, I think you have issues...
Originally posted by Kolohe:
Originally posted by Schulzy:
Originally posted by Kolohe:
Originally posted by Hoovtrain:
Fingers crossed he comes back healthy. Between the skill set he brings to the table and the money they invested in him, gotta have him back.

I now appreciate him even more after this season.

I appreciate the 2023 BA. The 2024 BA is everything that was wrong with this football team this year. Overpaid, entitled, unprepared to play, and hurt.

Yah I'm over that already, no reason to dwell on that stuff. I hope he comes back with a vengeance next season.

I'll be over it if the 2023 BA returns.
Originally posted by BP13:
Originally posted by Deebo:
Hope he chokes on Popeyes

aren't you the guy who wanted Kyle dead after the Arizona game? Dude, I think you have issues...

He's wished death on more than 1 player/coach. Well adjusted guy
Search Share 49ersWebzone