Originally posted by YACBros85:Originally posted by CharlieSheen:Originally posted by YACBros85:+ Show all quotes
I know I will catch a lot of flack for this but honestly, I believe CMC has made Deebo obsolete.
I love the Deebo CMC combo. They are unique players and it is good to have two to take the load or if the other is banged up for some games. Guys that can take it to the house from anywhere on the field are more rare than route runners. I feel like we can replace a route runner
Solid route runners are not a dime a dozen and aren't easy to replace as you say. Deebo can't even stay healthy and relies heavily on Kyle's play calling to get him the ball. Deebo the RB was terrible last season outside of a carry or two. In fact without the 51 and 39 yard runs that he had in the 1st half of the 2022 season, he averaged 3.3 YPC. As a receiver, QB's had a 87.1 passer rating when targeting him last season. Deebo also has a 10.5% drop rate. So even when Kyle schemes him open, it is no guarantee he will even catch the ball. Does Deebo have some eye candy highlight reel plays? Yes. But can you rely it on it when you need it most? No. The consistency just hasn't been there.
Idk I see Jerry Judy as a route runner but I would never want him over Deebo. I think Aiyuk is better than jeudy but he's a little overrated here, understandably so.
He doesn't bring the versatility Deebo does. He doesn't make defenses panic when he goes in motion like Deebo does. He can't share the load with CMC. I just think he's more replaceable