Originally posted by pasodoc9er:
Originally posted by NYniner85:
Originally posted by NinerGM:
I'm not saying you do NY - come one man, I've never said we need Pro Bowl guards to have success. You can make your point with hyperbole. We do need better guards than we've had - that's just a fact and the reason why Kyle and John invested where they did. Kyle sees it. McD sees it. Impacts both run and pass (McD's states what he saw on tape from Banks). Sure better QB play lessens the need for better guard play but at some point if you want to win championships, you're OL talent will need to win consistently. There's no way you can convince me that Mike Person was good enough for that. And given what Tampa's LOS (O and D) looks like with a good QB, I'll go on the record to say we will struggle to beat Tampa simply because their LOS talent >> 49ers right now.
We needed a better RG and I think everyone agrees there...saying we need a better LG is not a fact, just a preference from you.
Kyle and Co. made a bit of a reach with Banks IMO but they upgraded form whoever they had setup to play RG. IMO they didn't improve from Tomlinson during the off season...Moore is not better than Tomlinson at this point. We have a bunch of day 3 guys that will hopefully develop into something, but they didn't upgrade there. LT is a starting LG in the NFL. He doesn't get hurt and does his job. He's not elite, but he's not as bad as some of ya'll keep saying.
Mack was the most important move in the off season (outside of resigning TW) at OL.... center calls out the protection for the most part (the QB does play a part in that as well).
Tampa's OL was not good prior to Brady coming in (ranked 22nd in PP according to FOs, SF was 15th) They moved to 3rd overall (a pass pro) when Brady showed up...yes adding Wirfs helps, but that was one spot. QB and play calling help PP a ton end of the day.
Agree with you that we needed…desperately needed…a RG. Also agree that the Mack acquisition was THE most important move of the offseason, also along with resigning big Trent.
Also agree Moore is not better than Laken at present but that was a contextual choice, big man, good feet, and Laken is going to command $5.5-6 mil per next yr. So there were double reasons to take him. One for talent in the future (AND back up in case of LG injury), Plus monetary reason. We'll see, but are the 9ers committed to $6 mil for Laken at LG in 2022? IDK. But still that was part and parcel of the pick. Downside is he came from a smaller school, but that can be coached up. If you have seen any of his Utube film, it is excellent. I am looking for him to contend for LG next yr, and hopefully not because of a LG injury this yr. Until we see Moore playing against BIGGER, FASTER, SMARTER, MEANER, STRONGER, we won't really KNOW what we have. Give him a yr tho, and i believe we will like what we see…and it won't be for $6mil per. If he can't beat out Laken, then re-sign Laken. But a yr working against Nick, Javon, AA, and for a change of pace, Ebuk, and we'll have a lot better idea . But as for now, i love the pick…and we instantly have a backup at LG in case of injury….except this yr, NO injuries.(once we get out of OTAs, that is)
I'm interested in seeing how Moore & McKivitz play at the Guard spot, Aaron Banks is penciled in, IMO, at RG, I think the 49ers wouldn't mind Laken back, at the right price of course, but they'd also be happy if Moore or McKivitz can unseat him for 2022, kind of like Hufanga taking over the SS spot.
I look back on this offseason, and I think this was the Shanahan/Lynch era's best offseason, they, IMO, may have drafted 7 long term starters, not to mention retaining Juice & Trent long term, adding vet Mack, and a young EDGE Ebukam. So If you look at what they've done since 2017, whether people agree or not, I see it like this.
They drafted the following current starters or long term starters
QB- Trey Lance
RB- Trey Sermon
WR- Brandon Aiyuk
WR- Deebo Samuel
Slot WR- Jalen Hurd or Jauan Jennings
TE- George Kittle
LG- Jaylon Moore or Colton McKivitz
Utility OL- Jaylon Moore or Colton McKivitz
RG- Aaron Banks
RT- Mike McGlinchey
DE- Nick Bosa
DT- Javon Kinlaw
NT- D.J. Jones
WLB- Dre Greenlaw
MLB- Fred Warner
CB- Ambry Thomas
Slot CB- Deommodore Lenoir
SS- Talanoa Hufanga
P- Mitch Wishnowsky
That leaves the FB, C, LT, 2nd DE, 2nd outside CB, FS, & PK, but Juice & Trent IMO fill the FB & LT spots for the long term.
Of course Mack is a great C to have, but they need to draft & develop/groom a C to learn under Mack, maybe Brunskill can be the guy.
I think it's possible Ebukam could be that long term EDGE opposite Bosa, with Armstead playing DE/DT as he is/should be apart of the teams long term plans.
I think the 49ers were hoping for Tarvarius Moore to step up in 2021, but with the Achilles injury, this now, IMO, means Ward is the FS next year.
As for the other CB, I think they hope either Verrett or Moseley get that spot.
Not to look to far into the future, but I do see Moore back in 2022, on a 1yr deal like K'Waun signed, gets like $2.5M, but only $1.2M counts against the cap.