***The Forever Official 53-MAN ROSTER/DEPTH CHART/PS Thread***

Every f***king talented UDFA we had got claimed. Absolutely asinine that we let CLEARLY inferior guys make it over actual talent.

Oliver, Zakelj, and Brandon Allen had no business being on the final roster IMO.

Originally posted by frenchmov:

Originally posted by NYniner85:

It's also important to keep in mind that the 49ers were adamant about Ilm Manning playing guard long term. They relished his success at tackle in the preseason but were also quick to point out that it mainly came against third-string competition.

They viewed him as a project at…

— David Lombardi (@LombardiHimself) August 30, 2023

Ok??? All of our other backups who made it were trash playing against those same third stringers. So dumb

Lombardi is a 49ers apologist who masks his takes as "common sense".

Originally posted by OnTheClock:
Every f***king talented UDFA we had got claimed. Absolutely asinine that we let CLEARLY inferior guys make it over actual talent.

Oliver, Zakelj, and Brandon Allen had no business being on the final roster IMO.

I like those 3 guys OTC

Great final 53 roster as always. Let real football begin at last.

Originally posted by 9ersLiferInChicago:
I'm really pissed that we lost D'Shawn Jamison due solely to Isaiah Oliver's roster politics. Isaiah Oliver has no business on this roster. He's been nothing but hot a$$ garbage.

Considering what Wilks wants in his slot corner, the 6' 202lb Oliver is a much better fit than 5'9" 185lb Jamison.

Oliver has some work to do to clean up his play. However, his tape shows a much better player than the few plays we saw in pre-season.

Maybe we can get Manning and/or Jamison when t Cardinals and Panthers waive them in a few weeks.

Originally posted by OnTheClock:
Every f***king talented UDFA we had got claimed. Absolutely asinine that we let CLEARLY inferior guys make it over actual talent.

Oliver, Zakelj, and Brandon Allen had no business being on the final roster IMO.

Did you have a bad grade on Oliver coming out of college?

Originally posted by dj43:

Originally posted by 9ersLiferInChicago:
I'm really pissed that we lost D'Shawn Jamison due solely to Isaiah Oliver's roster politics. Isaiah Oliver has no business on this roster. He's been nothing but hot a$$ garbage.

Considering what Wilks wants in his slot corner, the 6' 202lb Oliver is a much better fit than 5'9" 185lb Jamison.

Oliver has some work to do to clean up his play. However, his tape shows a much better player than the few plays we saw in pre-season.

What difference does is 6'2, 202 frame makes if he can't cover anybody. And it wasn't just a few plays. from what I've heard from those who were at the practices Oliver didn't look any better than he did in games. Give what Jamison has shown us in the return game alone says top me that Oliver, not Jamison, should have been cut. If Jamison looks as good as he did for us, and Oliver looks no better, then Wilks should be fired, especially if this defense regresses, and slot corner play is central to that regression.

I feel we let a better player go for pure roster politics.

Hurry up. Signed to La'Mical Perine for running back from Chiefs. He looks a great preseason games well. Must cut to TDP right now.. check it out about Perine on YouTube video. La'Mical Perine Highlights vs Browns Preseason=3Tft2Txt6QttAqtz

Originally posted by 9ersLiferInChicago:
What difference does is 6'2, 202 frame makes if he can't cover anybody. And it wasn't just a few plays. from what I've heard from those who were at the practices Oliver didn't look any better than he did in games. Give what Jamison has shown us in the return game alone says top me that Oliver, not Jamison, should have been cut. If Jamison looks as good as he did for us, and Oliver looks no better, then Wilks should be fired, especially if this defense regresses, and slot corner play is central to that regression.

I feel we let a better player go for pure roster politics.

lol. no.

"We're very pleased with where Oliver is," Wilks said. "We brought him in for a reason. This league's all about matchups.

you have no idea how the coaches felt about his camp and preseason. youre going off tweets and watching a defense play a preseason game without a real game plan for their opponent. and he's learning a new defense.

they obviously have a plan for Oliver. he played really well in ATL. it's not like he's some scrub theyre taking a chance on.

ooooh former 5th round pick….this could be good.

Originally posted by AB81Rules:

Former #Packers 5th-round CB Shemar Jean-Charles is signing with the #49ers practice squad, per source. pic.twitter.com/GD39op50db

— Ari Meirov (@MySportsUpdate) August 30, 2023

Now we're interested in the CBs the Packers like

Originally posted by OnTheClock:
Every f***king talented UDFA we had got claimed. Absolutely asinine that we let CLEARLY inferior guys make it over actual talent.

Oliver, Zakelj, and Brandon Allen had no business being on the final roster IMO.

Allen was QB2 for a playoff team last season. To say he has no business being in the final roster is ridiculous IMO

Originally posted by Hysterikal:
Now we're interested in the CBs the Packers like