List of the Players I would dump after the season

Originally posted by lamontb:

dam you NC. this s**t was rough

Bless you for even doing it!

Fans wonder why we're the 2nd most injured team 8 years running yet still have Superbowl expectations annually.

The definition of insanity is... ^ this exact roster.

Imagine how much worse we would be replacing 22 players in one off-season.

so get rid of everyone except Trey & Bosa

Originally posted by Hysterikal:
Why is this a thread?

This thread deserves to be dumped.

Originally posted by billbird2111:

Originally posted by Hysterikal:
Why is this a thread?

This thread deserves to be dumped.

https://www.49erswebzone.com/forum/niners/195577-solutions-how-49ers-get-out-mess/page4/

same energy as that thread is my problem

Mostert is injury prone too, all of our RB's are. Just the way it is.

I like our team. Need better guard play. Would be nice if the rook corners took a big step forward into 2022. All this roster stuff means about 50% of the equation. The other 50% comes down to #5 Trey Lance. The difference between him becoming say a Josh Allen type versus becoming say a Blake Bortles type will define our future.

I doubt they get rid of Dontae Johnson.

Originally posted by Sickaa:
I doubt they get rid of Dontae Johnson.

LOL. We should do another of who we expect them to keep.

I know it's frustrating about Kinlaw but it would be dumb to get rid of him right now due to where he was drafted, his talent. And how cheap he is right now. You are not going to get anything for him in a trade right now. There is nothing to gain by trading him and everything to lose. Plus we are seing how bad our run defense is without him.

I would only trade Greenlaw if he is looking for a huge payday and if a team is offering a high pick.

- Jimmy frees up a lot of money

- Ford needs to be cut regardless of how minimal the savings might be

- Ebukam saves a lot of money if cut. He's been healthy, but he's not someone you want to be paying 8mil.

- Moseley would save about 5mil but with Tartt, Verrett, K Williams all off contract and questionable to return I'm not sure cutting him as well is the answer.

- Gould won't save us a cent. 5mil dead money and you still have to go out and replace him.

Not sure there's much more that we can do. I think we have a few guys who get re-signed, but hopefully more as depth than being relied on to start.

Originally posted by JR80Forever:
2 Categories: Injury Prone or Garbage (horrible players in my opinion)
Bolded Players are Starters

Daniel Brunskill - Garbage
Trenton Cannon - Garbage
Tom Compton - Garbage
Jimmy Garoppolo - Injury Prone
Robbie Gould - Injury Prone
Marcell Harris - Garbage
JaMycal Hasty - Injury Prone
Maurice Hurst - Injury Prone
Dontae Johnson - Garbage
Dre Kirkpatrick - Garbage
Alex Mack - Garbage
Josh Norman - Garbage
Mohamed Sanu Sr. - Garbage
Tavon Wilson - Garbage
Dee Ford - Injury Prone
Dre Greenlaw - Injury Prone
Jalen Hurd - Injury Prone
Richie James - Injury Prone
Javon Kinlaw - Injury Prone
Raheem Mostert - Injury Prone
Justin Skule - Injury Prone
Jaquiski Tartt - Injury Prone
Jason Verrett - Injury Prone

12 - Injury Prone & 10 - Garbage

Hold on, you'd dump Greenlaw? He had one injury, he played 2 seasons without any major injuries, he ended up with a bad break. Kinlaw isn't going anywhere whether people like it or not, you lose money cutting him, and we need every penny in 2022 because the cap won't be going up higher than $208.2M, I already have up as much as $11.206M over the cap once they fill out the top 51.

Again, same thing with Gould, his deal is fully GTD, he had an injury, idk how many times he's been injured, but missing 3 games isn't being injury prone.

Same with Hasty, high ankle sprains suck, they can happen at any time, you bring him back because he's young and inexpensive, if he sucks in camp, you cut him.

Sorry but Mack isn't garbage, he has crap on his right side in Brunskill who's best suited as a Swing Tackle, Mack isn't the problem, plus Laken, while I like him, is subpar at best in pass protection.

Some of these guys I agree who shouldn't be back, like Skule, & James, aren't injury prone when this is the first season to my knowledge that they were hurt.

Dee Ford I'm 50/50 on, I like him, but he can't stay healthy.

I agree with pretty much the rest, except Hurst, I want to see what he can do.

You have these players still currently putting their health on the line for your entertainment, but you want to use the word "dump".

Straight objects for yall. But u beg for autographs or photos if you come across them.

Originally posted by NCommand:
Let's just call them "unreliable" whether it's poor play or injury history or injury future.

Last year we had 45 players hit I.R. (just I.R.); not including all the others that didn't go on I.R. but missed games. We're actually on track to have MORE than that with 9 games to go (26-28).

For those objective fans, try this exercise. Simply bold the players below you feel you can rely on for health + quality play. WARNING: Please consult a therapist immediately after this exercise.

Offensive Personnel:
Jimmy Garoppolo
Trey Lance
Nate Sudfeld
Elijah Mitchell
Raheem Mostert
Trey Sermon
Jeff Wilson Jr.
Jamycal Hasty
Trenton Cannon
Kyle Juszczyk
George Kittle
Ross Dwelley
Charlie Woerner
Brandon Aiyuk
Trent Sherfield
Travis Benjamin
Mohamed Sanu
Richie James
Deebo Samuel
Jauan Jennings
Austin Watkins
Jalen Hurd
Trent Williams
Jaylon Moore
Justin Skule
Laken Tomlinson
Tom Compton
Alex Mack
Jake Brendel
Daniel Brunskill
Aaron Banks
Mike McGlinchey
Shon Coleman

Defensive Personnel:
Dee Ford
Charles Omenihu
Samson Ebukam
D.J. Jones
Maurice Hurst
Arik Armstead
Javon Kinlaw
Kentavius Street
Kevin Givens
Nick Bosa
Arden Key
Jordan Willis
Marcell Harris
Terrell Adams
Fred Warner
Mychal Kendricks
Azeez Al-Shaair
Dre Greenlaw
Demetrius Flannigan-Fowles
Emmanuel Moseley
Jason Verrett
K'Waun Williams
Deommodore Lenoir
Dontae Johnson
Josh Norman
Dre Kirkpatrick
Davontae Harris
Tim Harris Jr.
Ambrey Thomas
Tavon Wilson
Jimmie Ward
Kai Nacua
Tarvarius Moore
Talanoa Hufanga
Jaquiski Tartt
Tony Jefferson

Special Teams:
Taybor Pepper
Robbie Gould
Mitch Wishnowsky

Shon Coleman isn't on the roster, he was waived off IR earlier this season with an injury settlement, same with Tim Harris. Also Kendricks was cut.

Of the guys you list, I'd keep Trey, Mitchell, Hasty, Sermon, Juice, Deebo, Aiyuk, Jennings, Kittle, Woerner, Mack, Brunskill, Laken, Trent, McGlinchey, Moore, Banks, Armstead, Bosa, Ebukam, Key, Willis, Omenihu, Kinlaw, Street, Givens, Hurst, Jones, Greenlaw, Warner, Al-Shaair, Moseley, Ambry, Lenoir, K'Waun, Ward, Hufanga, Moore, Gould, Wish, & Pepper, so that's 41 players I'd keep around for 2022 and possibly beyond as core players.

I'd jettison the following, Jimmy, Sudfeld, Mostert, Cannon, Hurd, Compton, Harris, D.Johnson, Norman, Kirkpatrick, Tartt, & Wilson.

Unsure of the following, J.Wilson, Sanu, Sherfield, Brendel, Skule, Dee, Flannigan-Fowles.

Originally posted by Afrikan:
You have these players still currently putting their health on the line for your entertainment, but you want to use the word "dump".

Straight objects for yall. But u beg for autographs or photos if you come across them.

Exactly, they put their life/health on the line for a game, yes many make millions, but some only make the league minimum, plus the fact that they don't bring home every bit of that money, they pay taxes for where they live, play, plus 401K, and other stuff.