There are 772 users in the forums

All-Time Favorite 49ers at Every Position: Who You Got?

Shop Find 49ers gear online
Originally posted by Dr_Bill_Walsh:
QB - Giovanni Carmazzi

RB - Lawrence Phillips
FB - Adam Waker
TE - Wesley Walls
WR - Kyle Williams
OT - Bubba Paris
OG - Tony Wragge
C - Brock Gutierrez

DE - Charles Haley
DT - Dana Stubblefield
ILB - Takeo Spikes
OLB - Aldon Smith
CB - Antonio Langham
FS - Mark Roman
SS - Taylor Mays

K - Jose Cortez
P - Barry Helton

U have Walker over Jed Bush at FB?? Langham over Rumph?? That Safety combo is on point though

P.S. I would throw Borland in at LB
Originally posted by NCommand:
Originally posted by Giedi:
Originally posted by CatchMaster80:
Originally posted by dj43:
In this 75th year, I must go pre-80s with favorites.

QB - John Brodie (Y. A. Tittle is in the HOF but mostly for his accomplishments after the trade to the NY Giants)
RB - Hugh McElhenny (Barry Sanders before Barry Sanders)
FB - Joe Perry - (was he better than Jim Brown? a victim of EC media bias)
TE - Ted Kwalick (h/t John David Crow - also power RB)
WR - R. C. Owens (Alley Oop)
OT - Bob St. Clair (just take that steak from the fridge and put it on my plate)
OG - Howard Mudd (became a great OL coach)
C - Forrest Blue (great poignant story of his life - https://www.sactownmag.com/the-hollow-man/ lengthy read but well worth it)

DE - Cedrick (Nasty) Hardman
DT - Leo Nomelini (HOF played both ways)
DT - Charlie Krueger (spit and mud) (sorry, OP, can't leave him off)
ILB - Dave Wilcox (no one hit harder, not even Nitschke)
LB - Skip Vanderbundt (gotta include Howard Cosell's favorite and my hometown guy)
OLB - Frank Nunley (fudge hammer)
DB - Jimmy Johnson (forget Neon rental year, this guy was the best of all 49er DBs)
DB - Abe Woodson (outstanding CB, also averaged over 28 yds/return as KR, still one of the highest ever averages)
S - Dave Baker (short 49er career but still holds the season record for INT, "when he hits you, you stayed hit!")

K - Tommy Davis - also the punter

I turn 75 next month and remember all those guys well. Hugh the King was my favorite player growing up. He was, as you say like Barry Sanders in a broken field. I think Cedrick Hardman was the best DE we ever had. His 108 sacks is still by far the best.

I could never name an all time favorite team because I've followed them so long and have seen them through 3 different eras. 50s through the 70s. 80s through the 90s and the current era. The game has changed in each era and the type of player has also changed. I have my favorites in each.

My favorite game all time was the 1982 Championship. That for me was better than winning the SB after watching so mant year sof frustration.

My worst game was that 15-13 loss to the Giants in championship game. 2 minutes and 36 seconds from victory and Craig fumbled. It's the closest any team has ever come to a three-peat.

Agree, I still remember that game as if it just happened yesterday.

Same. Brutal. Still heartbroken.

I don't know if you guys were at the game but the crowd mood went from celebratory anticipation to unbelief in a matter of 2 minutes. The hush that followed that fumble was deafening. The ride home seemed like 3 hours instead of the usual 1.
My list:

QB - Joe Montana
RB - Frank Gore
FB - Tom Rathman
TE - George Kittle
WR - Jerry Rice
OT - Trent Williams
OG - Larry Allen
C - Jesse Sapolu

DE - Justin Smith
DT - Bryant Young
ILB - Patrick Willis
OLB - Kevin Greene
CB - Deion Sanders
FS - Ronnie Lott
SS - Donte Whitner

K / P - N/A

Instead of kicker and punters I'd like to give some extra honorable mentions: FB Roger Craig, ILB Navorro Bowman, WR Terrell Owens, OT Joe Staley, OG Mike Iupati, OG Guy McIntyre, DE Nick Bosa, ILB Fred Warner, WR Deebo Samuel
Too much work to think of every position. I will say Jimmy Johnson at CB though. The best 49er to hardly ever get talked about. Dude even had 600+ yards receiving in his career. HOF entry in 94. Track star, multiple 1st team all pros, younger brother (or at least a relative) if Decathlon gold medalist Rafer Johnson. Has always been one of my favorite 49er players ever.
  • Deebo
  • Veteran
  • Posts: 1,460
Is Druckenmiller taken yet?
Originally posted by 49AllTheTime:
QB - Montana

RB - Craig
FB - Rathman
TE - Kittle
WR - Rice
OT - Williams
OG - Allen
C - Sapolu

DE - Bosa
DT - Young
ILB -Willis
OLB - Haley
CB - Wright
FS - Lott
SS - McDonald

K - Akers
P - Lee

Like this one. Taylor as kr/pr.
  • MarkD
  • Veteran
  • Posts: 2,601
Kevin Gogan
Originally posted by CatchMaster80:
Originally posted by NCommand:
Originally posted by Giedi:
Originally posted by CatchMaster80:
Originally posted by dj43:
In this 75th year, I must go pre-80s with favorites.

QB - John Brodie (Y. A. Tittle is in the HOF but mostly for his accomplishments after the trade to the NY Giants)
RB - Hugh McElhenny (Barry Sanders before Barry Sanders)
FB - Joe Perry - (was he better than Jim Brown? a victim of EC media bias)
TE - Ted Kwalick (h/t John David Crow - also power RB)
WR - R. C. Owens (Alley Oop)
OT - Bob St. Clair (just take that steak from the fridge and put it on my plate)
OG - Howard Mudd (became a great OL coach)
C - Forrest Blue (great poignant story of his life - https://www.sactownmag.com/the-hollow-man/ lengthy read but well worth it)

DE - Cedrick (Nasty) Hardman
DT - Leo Nomelini (HOF played both ways)
DT - Charlie Krueger (spit and mud) (sorry, OP, can't leave him off)
ILB - Dave Wilcox (no one hit harder, not even Nitschke)
LB - Skip Vanderbundt (gotta include Howard Cosell's favorite and my hometown guy)
OLB - Frank Nunley (fudge hammer)
DB - Jimmy Johnson (forget Neon rental year, this guy was the best of all 49er DBs)
DB - Abe Woodson (outstanding CB, also averaged over 28 yds/return as KR, still one of the highest ever averages)
S - Dave Baker (short 49er career but still holds the season record for INT, "when he hits you, you stayed hit!")

K - Tommy Davis - also the punter

I turn 75 next month and remember all those guys well. Hugh the King was my favorite player growing up. He was, as you say like Barry Sanders in a broken field. I think Cedrick Hardman was the best DE we ever had. His 108 sacks is still by far the best.

I could never name an all time favorite team because I've followed them so long and have seen them through 3 different eras. 50s through the 70s. 80s through the 90s and the current era. The game has changed in each era and the type of player has also changed. I have my favorites in each.

My favorite game all time was the 1982 Championship. That for me was better than winning the SB after watching so mant year sof frustration.

My worst game was that 15-13 loss to the Giants in championship game. 2 minutes and 36 seconds from victory and Craig fumbled. It's the closest any team has ever come to a three-peat.

Agree, I still remember that game as if it just happened yesterday.

Same. Brutal. Still heartbroken.

I don't know if you guys were at the game but the crowd mood went from celebratory anticipation to unbelief in a matter of 2 minutes. The hush that followed that fumble was deafening. The ride home seemed like 3 hours instead of the usual 1.

IWAS there. Worst sporting moment I've ever attended (followed by the '87 Vikings & the Kyle Williams OT turnover). That Giant/Bills Super Bowl is the only one I refused to watch since I started watching Super Bowls at 5yrs old, in '76.

That fumble has kept Catfish, and a few linemen, and a coach out of the HOF, imo. Because had we 3peated…
QB Montana
RB Gore
FB Rathman
WR Rice
TE Kittle
OL Staley

DE Bosa
DT BY
OLB Woodall
MLB Willis
OLB Bowman
CB Deion Sanders
CB Rod Woodson
FS Lott
SS Parrish

KR Ginn
K Gould
P Lee
My list:

QB - Steve Young
RB - Frank Gore
FB - Kyle Juszczyk
TE - George Kittle
WR - Terrell Owens
OT - Joe Staley
OG - Mike Iupati
C - Alex Mack

DE - Justin Smith
DT - Bryant Young
ILB - Patrick Willis
OLB - Aldon Smith
CB - all of them sucked bigtime
FS - Dashon Goldson
SS - Donte Whitner

K - Joe Nedney
P - Andy Lee
If you wanted an all busts team:

QB Jim Druckenmiller
RB Dexter Carter
WR AJ Jenkins
WR Rashaun Woods
OL Chilo Rachal
DL Kentwan Balmer
LB Ruben Foster
DB Mike Rumph
K Jeff Chandler
KR/PR Kyle Williams

Coach Erickson
QB- Joe
RB- Hearst
FB- Rathman
WR- Rice
TE- Kittle
C- Newberry
G- Ray Brown
T- Williams

DE- Bosa
DT- BY
ILB- Willis
OLB- Peterson
CB- Deion
FS- Lott
SS- McDonald

P- Lee
K- Nedney
Originally posted by Giedi:
Originally posted by CatchMaster80:
Originally posted by dj43:
In this 75th year, I must go pre-80s with favorites.

QB - John Brodie (Y. A. Tittle is in the HOF but mostly for his accomplishments after the trade to the NY Giants)
RB - Hugh McElhenny (Barry Sanders before Barry Sanders)
FB - Joe Perry - (was he better than Jim Brown? a victim of EC media bias)
TE - Ted Kwalick (h/t John David Crow - also power RB)
WR - R. C. Owens (Alley Oop)
OT - Bob St. Clair (just take that steak from the fridge and put it on my plate)
OG - Howard Mudd (became a great OL coach)
C - Forrest Blue (great poignant story of his life - https://www.sactownmag.com/the-hollow-man/ lengthy read but well worth it)

DE - Cedrick (Nasty) Hardman
DT - Leo Nomelini (HOF played both ways)
DT - Charlie Krueger (spit and mud) (sorry, OP, can't leave him off)
ILB - Dave Wilcox (no one hit harder, not even Nitschke)
LB - Skip Vanderbundt (gotta include Howard Cosell's favorite and my hometown guy)
OLB - Frank Nunley (fudge hammer)
DB - Jimmy Johnson (forget Neon rental year, this guy was the best of all 49er DBs)
DB - Abe Woodson (outstanding CB, also averaged over 28 yds/return as KR, still one of the highest ever averages)
S - Dave Baker (short 49er career but still holds the season record for INT, "when he hits you, you stayed hit!")

K - Tommy Davis - also the punter

I turn 75 next month and remember all those guys well. Hugh the King was my favorite player growing up. He was, as you say like Barry Sanders in a broken field. I think Cedrick Hardman was the best DE we ever had. His 108 sacks is still by far the best.

I could never name an all time favorite team because I've followed them so long and have seen them through 3 different eras. 50s through the 70s. 80s through the 90s and the current era. The game has changed in each era and the type of player has also changed. I have my favorites in each.

My favorite game all time was the 1982 Championship. That for me was better than winning the SB after watching so mant year sof frustration.

My worst game was that 15-13 loss to the Giants in championship game. 2 minutes and 36 seconds from victory and Craig fumbled. It's the closest any team has ever come to a three-peat.

Agree, I still remember that game as if it just happened yesterday.

Ya...definitely worst game. Marshall runs over Montana and knocks him out. Brutal hit. Back when QBs didnt wear flags. Just had to run the clock out... .....

1994 NFC championship has to be up there as one of the best wins outside a SB. Could arguably be the best team ever. The 84 team was really good too.
[ Edited by TD49ers on Dec 26, 2021 at 6:11 AM ]
QB - Steve Young/kap

RB - Frank Gore/Craig
FB - Juice/ Fred Beasley
TE - George Kittle Vernon Davis
WR - T.O./rice
OT - Trent Williams/Staley
OG - mike lupati/Adam Snyder
C - Jeremy newberry

DE - Justin Smith/aldon
DT - Bryant Young/Buckner
ILB - Patrick Willis/bowman
OLB - Julian Peterson/Lawson
CB - Deion Sanders/Carlos rogers
FS - Ronnie Lott
SS - Merton Hanks

Madden ultimate team let's gooo
Share 49ersWebzone