Originally posted by genus49:
Mina is a very smart lady. I think she said a stupid take but that's what media tends to do...they blow up a take that is based in logic and go with hyperbole spin on it which can incite the reaction that she got.
Garcia also had a point because he's reacting to Mina's comment. Saying Jimmy didn't do anything is a trash take. There is a lot that goes into playing QB in the NFL and it's not always about passing numbers or big plays down the field.
It's one thing if you want to say Jimmy is a game manager who is asked to not make a lot of mistakes and run the offense but he still has to run the offense.
How many big throws do we have to see him make late in games to help us get the win or on 3rd down to keep drives going before we admit that he plays a part in helping this team win?
Let's be real, most people in here that think it's a stupid take are saying that and poo pooing on her (not saying you are) because we're all 49er fans. If she gave Jimmy all the credit in the world, it would be posted in multiple threads. People would love it and not question her merits to be able to speak about football...IMO it's weird that Garcia chose to go after her....like she was the only person that has talked about Jimmy like this lol? Where's the Chris Simm, Florio, Chris Carter and the handful of other "analysts" posts questioning them?
and what did she say that was so crazy? That SF is winning with Jimmy and not because of Jimmy? I mean that debatable IMO, but not some horrific thing where she should then be called out because she's not a former player and a women...just weird. But whatever fans are weird
[ Edited by NYniner85 on Jan 27, 2022 at 11:32 AM ]