QB Brock Purdy Thread

Originally posted by BOI49er:
Trey will start the season and if his decision making is better than Brock's he sticks, and if not in comes Brock.

That's not how it works lol. If we are winning regardless he will stay in. The kid needs to play as long as we're winning. s**t we let jimmy play when he doesn't make good decisions lol

Thank the Lord it was the lesser of the two procedures.

Jim Miller on SXM apparently has a good track record when it comes to injuries and time frames regarding return to play....given the news today, he believes Purdy is probably sometime around November.

Originally posted by fan49:
Look, I love Brock Purdy. I think he's great. I think he is already ready to go. I don't know what his limit is. We might've already seen it. He might only be able to get a little bit better, but I already like that boi more than Jimmy. But if he's not getting reps in the off-season consistently while Trey is, I think there's a question in a discussion to be had unless trey looks miserable. Did that discussion is not important but if he's looking pretty good, I think you go into the season with Trey.

Talk of Trey's ceiling is so over-hyped. He doesn't run well, for starters. That leaves his passing, which is strong-armed, but inaccurate and not cycling through his options half as fast as Purdy. Come on, man, what were you watching last year? A QB with no first team reps rips off 7 straight wins, two playoff wins, a 3 to 1 TD ratio, a 100+ QB rating, and looks to be as cool of a customer in the pocket as we've seen since Joe Montana, and you're saying we may have already seen Brock Purdy's ceiling? Give me some more of that ceiling, bro. As opposed to the mythical and infinite ceiling of Lance who, by the way, got injured three times in like 8 games. Lance was a workout warrior the Niners talked themselves into when they foolishly gave up all that draft capital without a plan. Brock Purdy is what will save Lynch and Shanahan's jobs.

Originally posted by RickyRoma:

Jim Miller on SXM apparently has a good track record when it comes to injuries and time frames regarding return to play....given the news today, he believes Purdy is probably sometime around November.

He is way off if Purdy recovers like Mullens did

Good luck Brock on your post surgery recovery…..

Thank God! hopfully we dont have to wait too long into the season for him to come back. We need him

Originally posted by ninerjok:
Thank the Lord it was the lesser of the two procedures.

I just hope it was best for him in the long run.

Originally posted by CharlieSheen:
He is way off if Purdy recovers like Mullens did

I've read Mullens was throwing again in 3 months....but was he fully recovered for the rigors of the NFL? It looks like he had his surgery in December or January - a good 2 months ahead of Purdy. We'll see I guess.

Originally posted by ninerjok:
Thank the Lord it was the lesser of the two procedures.

I know right? Thankful and also excited! Go Brock Go! Get better soon brother!

Originally posted by BSofSF:
Talk of Trey's ceiling is so over-hyped. He doesn't run well, for starters. That leaves his passing, which is strong-armed, but inaccurate and not cycling through his options half as fast as Purdy. Come on, man, what were you watching last year? A QB with no first team reps rips off 7 straight wins, two playoff wins, a 3 to 1 TD ratio, a 100+ QB rating, and looks to be as cool of a customer in the pocket as we've seen since Joe Montana, and you're saying we may have already seen Brock Purdy's ceiling? Give me some more of that ceiling, bro. As opposed to the mythical and infinite ceiling of Lance who, by the way, got injured three times in like 8 games. Lance was a workout warrior the Niners talked themselves into when they foolishly gave up all that draft capital without a plan. Brock Purdy is what will save Lynch and Shanahan's jobs.

To judge, a man based off for games is ridiculous. I guess Justin field should never play snap again in his life because of the way he played his rookie year I guess the same thing goes for Josh Allen.

Originally posted by fan49:

Originally posted by BSofSF:
Talk of Trey's ceiling is so over-hyped. He doesn't run well, for starters. That leaves his passing, which is strong-armed, but inaccurate and not cycling through his options half as fast as Purdy. Come on, man, what were you watching last year? A QB with no first team reps rips off 7 straight wins, two playoff wins, a 3 to 1 TD ratio, a 100+ QB rating, and looks to be as cool of a customer in the pocket as we've seen since Joe Montana, and you're saying we may have already seen Brock Purdy's ceiling? Give me some more of that ceiling, bro. As opposed to the mythical and infinite ceiling of Lance who, by the way, got injured three times in like 8 games. Lance was a workout warrior the Niners talked themselves into when they foolishly gave up all that draft capital without a plan. Brock Purdy is what will save Lynch and Shanahan's jobs.

To judge, a man based off for games is ridiculous. I guess Justin field should never play snap again in his life because of the way he played his rookie year I guess the same thing goes for Josh Allen.

Should we judge BP off his 5 games

Originally posted by fan49:
To judge, a man based off for games is ridiculous. I guess Justin field should never play snap again in his life because of the way he played his rookie year I guess the same thing goes for Josh Allen.

I agree the book on Trey isn't closed, but these situations you're comparing to ours aren't remotely comparable.

The Bills and Bears were/are not teams developing QBs in the middle of a Super Bowl window. The Bills developed Josh Allen as part of a rebuild, and the Bears are doing the same currently. Suffering through their growing pains was not costing their team any meaningful chance to compete in those seasons.

In addition to that, neither of those teams had an alternative option at the position that was playing extremely well and had the team on the doorstep of winning the Super Bowl until he was injured. The offense was scoring 30 plus points a game and Brock was playing extremely well. This is exactly the kind of result we were looking for moving off Jimmy in the first place.

Finally a good news, goddammit!
I m so happy for Brock and the team.
Now sign a vet min and draft a QB (Haener, Bennett, DTR, Tune, Hall...) in the later rounds.

My expectations