QB Brock Purdy Thread

Originally posted by qnnhan7:
Gonna pray Brock doesn't lose any arm strength and accuracy after he comes back. Would be awesome if both Lance and Brock having bright promising futures.

I'm confident they both will

Originally posted by SmokeyJoe:
I agree the book on Trey isn't closed, but these situations you're comparing to ours aren't remotely comparable.

The Bills and Bears were/are not teams developing QBs in the middle of a Super Bowl window. The Bills developed Josh Allen as part of a rebuild, and the Bears are doing the same currently. Suffering through their growing pains was not costing their team any meaningful chance to compete in those seasons.

In addition to that, neither of those teams had an alternative option at the position that was playing extremely well and had the team on the doorstep of winning the Super Bowl until he was injured. The offense was scoring 30 plus points a game and Brock was playing extremely well. This is exactly the kind of result we were looking for moving off Jimmy in the first place.

I agree which is why I said basically he doesn't need to tear it up. We just have to be winning with him. And watching him progress. BP should have been ready. We know trey needs time. So same plan as last year let him play due to situation and if he's winning he stays in. Simple

Originally posted by SmokeyJoe:
I agree the book on Trey isn't closed, but these situations you're comparing to ours aren't remotely comparable.

The Bills and Bears were/are not teams developing QBs in the middle of a Super Bowl window. The Bills developed Josh Allen as part of a rebuild, and the Bears are doing the same currently. Suffering through their growing pains was not costing their team any meaningful chance to compete in those seasons.

In addition to that, neither of those teams had an alternative option at the position that was playing extremely well and had the team on the doorstep of winning the Super Bowl until he was injured. The offense was scoring 30 plus points a game and Brock was playing extremely well. This is exactly the kind of result we were looking for moving off Jimmy in the first place.

The 49ers knew that and yet they still drafted Trey and wanted to start him last year as a project! Were you aware that we had a Super Bowl roster to start 2022 also? That argument is LAME!!

Originally posted by fan49:
I agree which is why I said basically he doesn't need to tear it up. We just have to be winning with him. And watching him progress. BP should have been ready. We know trey needs time. So same plan as last year let him play due to situation and if he's winning he stays in. Simple

My point is in disagreement with this. If he and the offense are not playing at a level at least very close to what was happening last year with Brock, then we should be playing Brock.

I need to make the mystery box video my signature, lol.

In other news panthers moving to #1

Originally posted by SmokeyJoe:
My point is in disagreement with this. If he and the offense are not playing at a level at least very close to what was happening last year with Brock, then we should be playing Brock.

I need to make the mystery box video my signature, lol.

If we are winning at the Bye week guess what we will do? We'll CONTINUE TO WIN WHILE DEVELOPING TREY JUST AS WE WERE WILLING TO DO LAST YEAR!

Now if we're losing you'll get your dream case scenario of Trey holding the clipboard keeping the bench warmed for Brock

Originally posted by Pillbusta:
The 49ers knew that and yet they still drafted Trey and wanted to start him last year as a project! Were you aware that we had a Super Bowl roster to start 2022 also? That argument is LAME!!

It's not the 2022 offseason anymore. It's 2023. Much has happened since their decision to roll with Trey as the starting QB, competition free, last offseason. To think nothing has changed and they're just going to roll with that same plan is beyond naive.

Originally posted by SmokeyJoe:
My point is in disagreement with this. If he and the offense are not playing at a level at least very close to what was happening last year with Brock, then we should be playing Brock.

I need to make the mystery box video my signature, lol.

Why is it different when jimmy is playing? Jimmy kept playing because we were winning, not because of his skills

Originally posted by SmokeyJoe:
It's not the 2022 offseason anymore. It's 2023. Much has happened since their decision to roll with Trey as the starting QB, competition free, last offseason. To think nothing has changed and they're just going to roll with that same plan is beyond naive.

What competition does he have? Brock will be ready to start fully practice basically week 1?

Originally posted by Pillbusta:
If we are winning at the Bye week guess what we will do? We'll CONTINUE TO WIN WHILE DEVELOPING TREY JUST AS WE WERE WILLING TO DO LAST YEAR!

Now if we're losing you'll get your dream case scenario of Trey holding the clipboard keeping the bench warmed for Brock

My dream scenario is Trey dominating in camp and playing the position like the player we all hope he could be. My dream scenario is winning the Super Bowl next season, not mortgaging the chance and foregoing Brock's development to prioritize Trey's development.

Originally posted by NYniner85:
In other news panthers moving to #1

daaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaang

Originally posted by fan49:

Originally posted by BOI49er:
Trey will start the season and if his decision making is better than Brock's he sticks, and if not in comes Brock.

That's not how it works lol. If we are winning regardless he will stay in. The kid needs to play as long as we're winning. s**t we let jimmy play when he doesn't make good decisions lol

It should be clear to you by the play calling that Kyle Never trusted Garoppolo. He just never had anyone he did trust that had the ability too.

Kyle does trust Purdy. He calls passing plays in dangerous situations that he would Never do with James. (He's gone. I forgot his name).

Trey is going to have the entire off season to shore up that part of his game. He's smart, with a good attitude and work ethic. We'll see how far he comes.

Originally posted by RickyRoma:

Originally posted by CharlieSheen:

He is way off if Purdy recovers like Mullens did

I've read Mullens was throwing again in 3 months....but was he fully recovered for the rigors of the NFL? It looks like he had his surgery in December or January - a good 2 months ahead of Purdy. We'll see I guess.

It's a rare injury so probably a little harder to gauge for him. Jimmy didn't have to be 100% to start in 2021 so maybe Brock doesn't need to be 100%. I have a feeling Brock starts week 1

Why do people like Cam Inman and other such media personnel, etc. continue to think full TJ surgery was an option. It was ruled out completely about 2 weeks ago. For the 4 millionth time it was either one of two procedures. So annoying.

Originally posted by SmokeyJoe:
It's not the 2022 offseason anymore. It's 2023. Much has happened since their decision to roll with Trey as the starting QB, competition free, last offseason. To think nothing has changed and they're just going to roll with that same plan is beyond naive.

As to who is naive I believe every single thing I've said thus far has come to pass and your wishful thinking and postulations have been quite amusing to say the least. I have my calendar in front of me and I have our current roster in front of me. What I see is Trey will start the season on a roster that HOPEFULLY is as talented as last year with the same Super Bowl aspirations and just like last year this team will be willing to take their lumps with Trey under center so long as he's winning. IF Trey is losing then we should see Brock come in to take the reins. I have said all along that Trey likely has until the bye week to prove he is QB1. Now let's see how naive I am as this thing plays out