QB Brock Purdy Thread

Originally posted by CharlieSheen:
Just have to laugh at these guys that try to knock the Cowboys game. I know he earned a lot of respect from Kyle and his teammates for that performance

I find it hilarious when they try to use things coaches/front office say - like you have to understand the position they're in. I only believe them when someone actually plays well and they dump praise on that player, any player.

for example: when Kyle and John/demeco/d players gush about how well Purdy has played, how awesome he is in practice and the locker room etc. you know they mean that stuff cause they choose to start listing things and expressing how they actually felt, not generic things.

but when Kyle/John says thing about a player that hasn't really performed or had a chance to, like "I think Lance would of had a hell of a season". I find this to be generic responses and what else are they suppose to say? Lol

not that I think they're lying but I don't think it's their honest complete answer. What is He supposed to say "I think Lance would of really continued to struggle but we woukd of expected him to start to figure it out"? You can't just publicly out down your guys. Lmao
he said similar stuff about jimmy but you could still tell he was frustrated with him.

or when Lance said "I don't want anything given to me. I want to compete". Of course he will say that. Lmao what is he supposed to say "I can't believe I have to compete for a starting job in the NFL"? Lmao not saying it isn't true but also doesn't mean he isn't annoyed/disappointed by the situation.

players/coaches/front office are told what they can and can't say publicly - or shouldn't. Just listen to what the ravens are saying about Lamar. Lol when obviously there is a ton of friction. Not a negative word about anything.
Players are especially coached up on this by their agent and coaches.

once again, I'm not saying anyone is lying, but those type of comments you have to take with a grain of salt. There's always something else they want to say or can't say.

Originally posted by tankle104:

Originally posted by CharlieSheen:

Just have to laugh at these guys that try to knock the Cowboys game. I know he earned a lot of respect from Kyle and his teammates for that performance

I find it hilarious when they try to use things coaches/front office say - like you have to understand the position they're in. I only believe them when someone actually plays well and they dump praise on that player, any player.

for example: when Kyle and John/demeco/d players gush about how well Purdy has played, how awesome he is in practice and the locker room etc. you know they mean that stuff cause they choose to start listing things and expressing how they actually felt, not generic things.

but when Kyle/John says thing about a player that hasn't really performed or had a chance to, like "I think Lance would of had a hell of a season". I find this to be generic responses and what else are they suppose to say? Lol

not that I think they're lying but I don't think it's their honest complete answer. What is He supposed to say "I think Lance would of really continued to struggle but we woukd of expected him to start to figure it out"? You can't just publicly out down your guys. Lmao
he said similar stuff about jimmy but you could still tell he was frustrated with him.

or when Lance said "I don't want anything given to me. I want to compete". Of course he will say that. Lmao what is he supposed to say "I can't believe I have to compete for a starting job in the NFL"? Lmao not saying it isn't true but also doesn't mean he isn't annoyed/disappointed by the situation.

players/coaches/front office are told what they can and can't say publicly - or shouldn't. Just listen to what the ravens are saying about Lamar. Lol when obviously there is a ton of friction. Not a negative word about anything.
Players are especially coached up on this by their agent and coaches.

once again, I'm not saying anyone is lying, but those type of comments you have to take with a grain of salt. There's always something else they want to say or can't say.

Yea I just look at their actions and if the words line up. Kyle can say he thinks Trey would play like Brock, but if he has him competing with Darnold we know that's not true lol

Originally posted by CharlieSheen:

Originally posted by tankle104:

Originally posted by CharlieSheen:
Just have to laugh at these guys that try to knock the Cowboys game. I know he earned a lot of respect from Kyle and his teammates for that performance

I find it hilarious when they try to use things coaches/front office say - like you have to understand the position they're in. I only believe them when someone actually plays well and they dump praise on that player, any player.

for example: when Kyle and John/demeco/d players gush about how well Purdy has played, how awesome he is in practice and the locker room etc. you know they mean that stuff cause they choose to start listing things and expressing how they actually felt, not generic things.

but when Kyle/John says thing about a player that hasn't really performed or had a chance to, like "I think Lance would of had a hell of a season". I find this to be generic responses and what else are they suppose to say? Lol

not that I think they're lying but I don't think it's their honest complete answer. What is He supposed to say "I think Lance would of really continued to struggle but we woukd of expected him to start to figure it out"? You can't just publicly out down your guys. Lmao
he said similar stuff about jimmy but you could still tell he was frustrated with him.

or when Lance said "I don't want anything given to me. I want to compete". Of course he will say that. Lmao what is he supposed to say "I can't believe I have to compete for a starting job in the NFL"? Lmao not saying it isn't true but also doesn't mean he isn't annoyed/disappointed by the situation.

players/coaches/front office are told what they can and can't say publicly - or shouldn't. Just listen to what the ravens are saying about Lamar. Lol when obviously there is a ton of friction. Not a negative word about anything.
Players are especially coached up on this by their agent and coaches.

once again, I'm not saying anyone is lying, but those type of comments you have to take with a grain of salt. There's always something else they want to say or can't say.

Yea I just look at their actions and if the words line up. Kyle can say he thinks Trey would play like Brock, but if he has him competing with Darnold we know that's not true lol

Since they came out and said he is the starter proves 1 of 2 things.
either:
1. Kyle doesn't believe Lance has the ability to play at a higher level than Purdy (at least here)
2. Kyle doesn't believe Lance has the ability to play at the level Purdy did.

If Kyle thought Lance was going to eventually breakthrough and be a star, he would at least say "they'll duke it out". Not "Purdy is the starter when healthy but Lance has a chance to regain it" - a super generic answer.

Originally posted by tankle104:
The absolute ONLY way I want Brock sitting on the bench for any game is if he isn't healthy. Other than that, I don't want to see any other qb on the field.

and hoping someone's injury gets worse or heals way slower than it should so he can start, is odd and not cool.

if you want Lance to play then hope he has an amazing camp and forces kyle to make a tough decision. What is up with people wanting Lance to be given everything. Some guy in the Trey said earlier that Trey wasn't given QB2 his rookie year or QB1 his second year.. lol I didn't even respond.

im not saying it was the wrong by Kyle to do that, but don't deny it happen, you know?

I always suspected there would be some fans hoping for that. At least one fan had the balls to say just that. What a shame

why not just hope Lance balls out from the get which makes It impossible for Kyle to pull him for Purdy.

That post was wrong on so many levels.

Originally posted by Furlow:

Originally posted by krizay:
WTF did I just read? Don't want Brock back until week 8-10?

LMAO! And the Trey "haters" are the ones wanting to be right. The Trey "haters" putting being right above the team. DAFUQ?

Dude what games were these guys watching? Comparing Purdy to Keenum, Files, and Jimmy? What on earth...

That post was so bad all around. Worst part was wishing for Purdys recover to take longer so that Lance can be the unquestioned starter. If they isn't putting one player above the team, I don't know what is.

Originally posted by tankle104:
They just want Lance to work out so bad that they're willing to diminish anything and everything that could be an obstacle for him. lol it's very odd. I honestly don't know how anyone isn't drooling over what Purdy did for us last season. Absolutely incredible

I'm critical of Lance but it's all based on what he has and hasn't done yet, while being clear that he can improve, I just don't have faith in the guy to every become elite in this league. All while accepting I could be wrong. Lol

Exactly! Some of our fan base is

Originally posted by tankle104:
Lol I started to respond but it was too much. The only thing I can think of is that he sees it through a Perspective of not wanting Brock to do too well so Lance starts.

- Seahawks game: first rookie in a decade to win a playoff game. First rookie ever to score four touchdowns in a playoff game. One Aiyuk drop away from having a fifth.

- Dallas: it wasn't the sexiest game but it was damn good and extremely impressive, especially down the stretch. Dallas had an incredible pass rush (top 2 in the league).

- Philly: ????. He looked sharp on his first couple but then was quickly injured. Gutted it out though so we had a qb on the field.

literally historic and some say he didn't play well? So confusing.

Pretty much.

And he's not the only poster, so always have to keep that in mind.

Originally posted by CharlieSheen:
Just have to laugh at these guys that try to knock the Cowboys game. I know he earned a lot of respect from Kyle and his teammates for that performance

Expecting every game to be a shootout is foolish. Especially, in the playoffs. The main goal is to survive and move on. Kyle has said that that games are called differently. Tom Brady (arguably ) the best QB ever, won a super bowl scoring only 13 pts.

Tankle said It well, "They just want Lance to work out so bad that they're willing to diminish anything and everything that could be an obstacle for him. lol it's very odd. I honestly don't know how anyone isn't drooling over what Purdy did for us last season. Absolutely incredible"

Originally posted by krizay:

Originally posted by SLCNiner:

Originally posted by krizay:

Originally posted by WINiner:
What's the point in practicing then? If players are incapable of improving once they get into the league what's the point of practicing? If they are just going to do whatever their natural ability dictates "When the bullets start flying" then why practice at all? This kind of narrative comes from people who've been posting on this forum for well over a decade and claim to watch NFL football and sports, in general, is baffling. It's like yall have never watched a player progress through their career and unable to see when their game changes. We have soooooo many examples in 49ers history. Steve Young, Jerry Rice, Joe Montana, Byant Young, Derrick Deese the list goes on and on of guys who left the league a very different product than how they entered it and players' styles change completely over the course of their careers regularly in the NFL.

I am talking about QBs and accuracy you are talking about practice in general.

By the time a QB gets to the NFL throwing should be natural. You shouldn't have to think about throwing. You have waaaaaay more things to worry about.

Practicing can improve your QB play but not necessarily your accuracy. Yes your completion % can be improved but that's not the same thing as accuracy.

So yes practice can help a QB and other players. No one ever said that's not the case. IMO accuracy isn't one of them things that is usually drastically improves. Josh Allen IMO lone exception

What a load of bull s**t. Anything that can be practiced can be improved.

http://insidethepylon.com/nfl/2016-nfl-draft/2016/03/17/quarterback-traits-the-attainable-versus-the-inherent/

https://blogs.usafootball.com/blog/1430/4-drills-to-help-qbs-sharpen-accuracy

https://footballadvantage.com/quarterback-drills/

https://www.americanfootballinternational.com/qb-drills-improve-accuracy-arm-strength/

Yes lower level players. I think ive said it enough times. ONCE YOU GET TO THE PROS

Not only that! But it's MY OPINION! Not trying to pass it off as scientific fact

Yeah def not scientific fact but def proof of the same obtuse nonsensical arguments from that username that I was made familiar with well over a decade ago during our Vernon Davis/Michael Huff debates.

Originally posted by tankle104:

Originally posted by CharlieSheen:
Just have to laugh at these guys that try to knock the Cowboys game. I know he earned a lot of respect from Kyle and his teammates for that performance

I find it hilarious when they try to use things coaches/front office say - like you have to understand the position they're in. I only believe them when someone actually plays well and they dump praise on that player, any player.

for example: when Kyle and John/demeco/d players gush about how well Purdy has played, how awesome he is in practice and the locker room etc. you know they mean that stuff cause they choose to start listing things and expressing how they actually felt, not generic things.

but when Kyle/John says thing about a player that hasn't really performed or had a chance to, like "I think Lance would of had a hell of a season". I find this to be generic responses and what else are they suppose to say? Lol

not that I think they're lying but I don't think it's their honest complete answer. What is He supposed to say "I think Lance would of really continued to struggle but we woukd of expected him to start to figure it out"? You can't just publicly out down your guys. Lmao
he said similar stuff about jimmy but you could still tell he was frustrated with him.

or when Lance said "I don't want anything given to me. I want to compete". Of course he will say that. Lmao what is he supposed to say "I can't believe I have to compete for a starting job in the NFL"? Lmao not saying it isn't true but also doesn't mean he isn't annoyed/disappointed by the situation.

players/coaches/front office are told what they can and can't say publicly - or shouldn't. Just listen to what the ravens are saying about Lamar. Lol when obviously there is a ton of friction. Not a negative word about anything.
Players are especially coached up on this by their agent and coaches.

once again, I'm not saying anyone is lying, but those type of comments you have to take with a grain of salt. There's always something else they want to say or can't say.

Except that John and especially Kyle have not shied away from criticizing a player they don't feel is developing correctly. Kyle didn't have a problem calling out Aiyuk publicly. There's been others. Your narrative is false and proven so by the teams recent history.

Originally posted by WINiner:

Originally posted by tankle104:

Originally posted by CharlieSheen:
Just have to laugh at these guys that try to knock the Cowboys game. I know he earned a lot of respect from Kyle and his teammates for that performance

I find it hilarious when they try to use things coaches/front office say - like you have to understand the position they're in. I only believe them when someone actually plays well and they dump praise on that player, any player.

for example: when Kyle and John/demeco/d players gush about how well Purdy has played, how awesome he is in practice and the locker room etc. you know they mean that stuff cause they choose to start listing things and expressing how they actually felt, not generic things.

but when Kyle/John says thing about a player that hasn't really performed or had a chance to, like "I think Lance would of had a hell of a season". I find this to be generic responses and what else are they suppose to say? Lol

not that I think they're lying but I don't think it's their honest complete answer. What is He supposed to say "I think Lance would of really continued to struggle but we woukd of expected him to start to figure it out"? You can't just publicly out down your guys. Lmao
he said similar stuff about jimmy but you could still tell he was frustrated with him.

or when Lance said "I don't want anything given to me. I want to compete". Of course he will say that. Lmao what is he supposed to say "I can't believe I have to compete for a starting job in the NFL"? Lmao not saying it isn't true but also doesn't mean he isn't annoyed/disappointed by the situation.

players/coaches/front office are told what they can and can't say publicly - or shouldn't. Just listen to what the ravens are saying about Lamar. Lol when obviously there is a ton of friction. Not a negative word about anything.
Players are especially coached up on this by their agent and coaches.

once again, I'm not saying anyone is lying, but those type of comments you have to take with a grain of salt. There's always something else they want to say or can't say.

Except that John and especially Kyle have not shied away from criticizing a player they don't feel is developing correctly. Kyle didn't have a problem calling out Aiyuk publicly. There's been others. Your narrative is false and proven so by the teams recent history.

Lmao alright

Originally posted by tankle104:

Originally posted by WINiner:

Originally posted by tankle104:

Originally posted by CharlieSheen:
Just have to laugh at these guys that try to knock the Cowboys game. I know he earned a lot of respect from Kyle and his teammates for that performance

I find it hilarious when they try to use things coaches/front office say - like you have to understand the position they're in. I only believe them when someone actually plays well and they dump praise on that player, any player.

for example: when Kyle and John/demeco/d players gush about how well Purdy has played, how awesome he is in practice and the locker room etc. you know they mean that stuff cause they choose to start listing things and expressing how they actually felt, not generic things.

but when Kyle/John says thing about a player that hasn't really performed or had a chance to, like "I think Lance would of had a hell of a season". I find this to be generic responses and what else are they suppose to say? Lol

not that I think they're lying but I don't think it's their honest complete answer. What is He supposed to say "I think Lance would of really continued to struggle but we woukd of expected him to start to figure it out"? You can't just publicly out down your guys. Lmao
he said similar stuff about jimmy but you could still tell he was frustrated with him.

or when Lance said "I don't want anything given to me. I want to compete". Of course he will say that. Lmao what is he supposed to say "I can't believe I have to compete for a starting job in the NFL"? Lmao not saying it isn't true but also doesn't mean he isn't annoyed/disappointed by the situation.

players/coaches/front office are told what they can and can't say publicly - or shouldn't. Just listen to what the ravens are saying about Lamar. Lol when obviously there is a ton of friction. Not a negative word about anything.
Players are especially coached up on this by their agent and coaches.

once again, I'm not saying anyone is lying, but those type of comments you have to take with a grain of salt. There's always something else they want to say or can't say.

Except that John and especially Kyle have not shied away from criticizing a player they don't feel is developing correctly. Kyle didn't have a problem calling out Aiyuk publicly. There's been others. Your narrative is false and proven so by the teams recent history.

Lmao alright

Am I wrong?

Originally posted by tankle104:
https://youtu.be/NW4CAViPeZU

oh snap! Kyle on the qb school channel with JT! Dropped 8 hours ago! Lmao this is great.

That isn't Kyle. Lol

Originally posted by WINiner:
Yeah def not scientific fact but def proof of the same obtuse nonsensical arguments from that username that I was made familiar with well over a decade ago during our Vernon Davis/Michael Huff debates.

Lol yea I remember the claims VD was going to revolutionize the TE position because of his physical traits. Here we are over a decade later

Originally posted by WINiner:

Originally posted by tankle104:

Originally posted by WINiner:

Originally posted by tankle104:

Originally posted by CharlieSheen:
Just have to laugh at these guys that try to knock the Cowboys game. I know he earned a lot of respect from Kyle and his teammates for that performance

I find it hilarious when they try to use things coaches/front office say - like you have to understand the position they're in. I only believe them when someone actually plays well and they dump praise on that player, any player.

for example: when Kyle and John/demeco/d players gush about how well Purdy has played, how awesome he is in practice and the locker room etc. you know they mean that stuff cause they choose to start listing things and expressing how they actually felt, not generic things.

but when Kyle/John says thing about a player that hasn't really performed or had a chance to, like "I think Lance would of had a hell of a season". I find this to be generic responses and what else are they suppose to say? Lol

not that I think they're lying but I don't think it's their honest complete answer. What is He supposed to say "I think Lance would of really continued to struggle but we woukd of expected him to start to figure it out"? You can't just publicly out down your guys. Lmao
he said similar stuff about jimmy but you could still tell he was frustrated with him.

or when Lance said "I don't want anything given to me. I want to compete". Of course he will say that. Lmao what is he supposed to say "I can't believe I have to compete for a starting job in the NFL"? Lmao not saying it isn't true but also doesn't mean he isn't annoyed/disappointed by the situation.

players/coaches/front office are told what they can and can't say publicly - or shouldn't. Just listen to what the ravens are saying about Lamar. Lol when obviously there is a ton of friction. Not a negative word about anything.
Players are especially coached up on this by their agent and coaches.

once again, I'm not saying anyone is lying, but those type of comments you have to take with a grain of salt. There's always something else they want to say or can't say.

Except that John and especially Kyle have not shied away from criticizing a player they don't feel is developing correctly. Kyle didn't have a problem calling out Aiyuk publicly. There's been others. Your narrative is false and proven so by the teams recent history.

Lmao alright

Am I wrong?

In general, yes. Pointing out one time where someone was clearly in the dog house, doesn't make you unanimously right. If you believe that you can take what these guys say literally all the time, then good luck. You've obviously never watched podcast from ex-players and current players that talk about it all the time.

your point is like me being like "the ravens have said nothing but glowing things about Lamar in the press, so there are no issues, right?" Lmao come on, man.