QB Brock Purdy Thread

Originally posted by Ezekiel38:
If Brock doesn't turn into that dude, Kyle should be fired.

the only way Kyle's getting fired is if he has multiple losing seasons.

Kyle has four playoff wins in the past two years alone. dude wins games. that's all that matters. his seat is cold as f**k.

Originally posted by boast:

Originally posted by Ezekiel38:
If Brock doesn't turn into that dude, Kyle should be fired.

the only way Kyle's getting fired is if he has multiple losing seasons.

Kyle has four playoff wins in the past two years alone. dude wins games. that's all that matters. his seat is cold as f**k.

If Brock isn't that dude, we won't be winning anything meaningful and he will have officially destroyed the handling of the qb position. He needs to win THE game. that's all that matters.

I do think Brock can be that dude and have the "IT" that I hoped Jimmy had but didn't so I'm hopeful once again.

Originally posted by 49AllTheTime:

Originally posted by Bay2Bay9erAllday:

Originally posted by tankle104:

Originally posted by DonnieDarko:
Everyone clowning on kyle regarding lance debqcle and the jimmy shade

but aint no one realizing he found his dude in purdy

they will realize soon enough

Can't wait for Brock to have a 4 tuddie game!

Let's chill on this. lol

yeah, 3 TDs and 1 rush TD is more like it

I'm not a mathematician, but that still equals 4. LOL

Originally posted by SteveWallacesHelmet:

Originally posted by 49AllTheTime:

Originally posted by Bay2Bay9erAllday:

Originally posted by tankle104:

Originally posted by DonnieDarko:
Everyone clowning on kyle regarding lance debqcle and the jimmy shade

but aint no one realizing he found his dude in purdy

they will realize soon enough

Can't wait for Brock to have a 4 tuddie game!

Let's chill on this. lol

yeah, 3 TDs and 1 rush TD is more like it

I'm not a mathematician, but that still equals 4. LOL

oh man lol, i assumed they were all pass TDs

Originally posted by Ezekiel38:

Originally posted by boast:

Originally posted by Ezekiel38:
If Brock doesn't turn into that dude, Kyle should be fired.

the only way Kyle's getting fired is if he has multiple losing seasons.

Kyle has four playoff wins in the past two years alone. dude wins games. that's all that matters. his seat is cold as f**k.

If Brock isn't that dude, we won't be winning anything meaningful and he will have officially destroyed the handling of the qb position. He needs to win THE game. that's all that matters.

I do think Brock can be that dude and have the "IT" that I hoped Jimmy had but didn't so I'm hopeful once again.

it actually doesnt matter who "that dude" is if the team still wins

Originally posted by Ezekiel38:
If Brock isn't that dude, we won't be winning anything meaningful and he will have officially destroyed the handling of the qb position. He needs to win THE game. that's all that matters.

I do think Brock can be that dude and have the "IT" that I hoped Jimmy had but didn't so I'm hopeful once again.

If purdy falls flat on his face and darnold is darnold

kyle will have cousins on speed dial next offseason ;)

Originally posted by boast:

Originally posted by Ezekiel38:
If Brock doesn't turn into that dude, Kyle should be fired.

the only way Kyle's getting fired is if he has multiple losing seasons.

Kyle has four playoff wins in the past two years alone. dude wins games. that's all that matters. his seat is cold as f**k.

He just needs to make sure not to kick Jed out of any locker room meetings.

Originally posted by TheWooLick:

Originally posted by dayswwneskoqnazfma:
Take a look at the Dallas playoff game last year and how they shut down his short and intermediate throws. Purdy still needs to hit receivers outside the numbers, through tight windows and deep to keep NFL defenses honest. That is still a big question mark. Small QBs like Brees and Wilson can do it and he needs to do it too to succeed in this league.

I mean Dallas is a dominant defense. They are way better than their raw stats suggest. I'd call them the third best defense last year, and the top 3 are very close to each other. That Brock—a rookie—didn't make any game costing errors says a lot. Jimmy G single-handedly tried to steal defeat from the jaws of victory from them a couple years ago and they weren't as good on defense as they were last year. I was, if anything, encouraged by his performance against them.

Originally posted by 5_Golden_Rings:
I mean Dallas is a dominant defense. They are way better than their raw stats suggest. I'd call them the third best defense last year, and the top 3 are very close to each other. That Brock—a rookie—didn't make any game costing errors says a lot. Jimmy G single-handedly tried to steal defeat from the jaws of victory from them a couple years ago and they weren't as good on defense as they were last year. I was, if anything, encouraged by his performance against them.

Yep.

Originally posted by dayswwneskoqnazfma:

Originally posted by tankle104:
Max Duggan was just cut - another 7th rounder who played in the big 12 with 47 games, incase anyone wants to say that Brock looked how he did cause he started a lot in college. Lol it's amazing to me how quick some are to write off what Brock did and act like it wasn't historically amazing.

He was historically amazing by.....putting up the same numbers last year as Jimmy Garoppolo? The two basically had the same stats. The credit should go to Shannahan for building this plug and play offense.

Anyone who says Brock put up the same numbers as Jimmy hasn't looked at the numbers. First of all, he was much better in the red zone. Second, his completed air yards per attempt (3.9) were higher than Patrick Mahomes (3.7), let alone Jimmy (3.2). Third, his touchdown percentage was ridiculous (7.6%), and more than 2 percentage points higher than Jimmy (5.2%). And lastly, his running contributions were crucial. All told, Jimmy's Total QBR was 54.3, about what he's been the last three years, while Brock's Total QBR was 65.6, which would have been 5th in the NFL had he had enough attempts.

And most importantly, unlike Jimmy, Brock didn't wilt in the playoffs. His Total QBR actually increased, going from 65.6 to 70.8. For comparison, Jimmy in 2021-22 went from 59.2 to 57.8, and in the 2019-20 season Jimmy went from 60.8 to 45.8.

Not only did Brock play a bit better in the regular season, he improved when the competition got better and the stakes got higher. He's the better QB. Or at least was last year, and no reasonable person would doubt that.

Originally posted by NCommand:

Originally posted by YACBros85:

Originally posted by dayswwneskoqnazfma:

Originally posted by TheWooLick:

Did you make my point? Purdy couldn't make throws over 20 yards in that game. Most of his completions were under 10 yards.

He couldn't make them? More like he didn't really attempt them. Was that because Brock or because of the gameplan? According to the chart he was 50% on them which is actually a good % for deep ball passing.

95%, the game plan. Kyle runs this b***h:

Garoppolo said. "While I was there, Kyle was gonna call the plays for you. You've just got to go up there and execute them to the best of your ability.

Kyle doesn't tell his QBs to go with the ball, and he DOESN'T prefer the QB to throw short when a deeper pass is open. I'm very confident that the reason Purdy threw a lot of deep stuff versus Seattle and not Dallas is because Dallas had the best pass rusher in football and maybe the second best pass rushing defense in the league. It's true Kyle's game plan would have accounted for that, but Purdy wasn't deciding not to throw deep when it was open. He was mostly forced to get rid of the ball due to good defense.

Originally posted by 9ers4eva:

Originally posted by YACBros85:
Now you are moving the goal posts and I can make an educated guess on why. You are a Trey fan and are mad that Kyle found his guy and it isn't the one you emotionally invested in.

Incorrect Yac. A Darnold fan who clearly wants him to be the starter.

Gonna be the new debate with guys like him and Faithful pretending Darnold is on Purdys level. Only gonna take one bad game.

"Best #2 QB in league"

Hey I'm fairly sold on Brock but I'm not gonna sell Sam short. Maybe he finally figures it out here. He's certainly talented. But if so he'll have to wait for his opportunity. And besides, even in the preseason Brocked looked better at processing.

Originally posted by TheWooLick:

Originally posted by NYniner85:

Originally posted by TheWooLick:
Why not be content with winning?

Guess we should have never moved off Jimmy then.

No, Brock was a better option so they moved on from Jimmy and Trey.

Duh

Trey wanted out. Not sure he gets traded if he doesn't ask to be traded.

Originally posted by SlipAndSlideBosa:

Originally posted by Giedi:

Originally posted by eastie:

Originally posted by dayswwneskoqnazfma:

Originally posted by YACBros85:
Still missing from the chart whether they were incompletions or not. So how reliable is that chart if its missing information?

On another note. Have you ever heard the term "take what the defense gives you"?

The Cowboys played a 4-3 defense and left the edges open. Purdy didn't hit any deep or intermediate pass outside the numbers.

Originally posted by TheWooLick:

Originally posted by dayswwneskoqnazfma:

Originally posted by YACBros85:
He couldn't make them? More like he didn't really attempt them. Was that because Brock or because of the gameplan? According to the chart he was 50% on them which is actually a good % for deep ball passing.

LOL. 20 yards are deep passes now? We have the best skill players by far in the NFL and we're somehow content with 5 yard dink and dunks. I have hope that Purdy can extend his game but if he can't, this is worrisome for our Super Bowl odds.

Why not be content with winning?

Agree 100%. This whole debate/argument is reminding me of the 80's when Joe was QB. There were 'fans' that complained when the team won that they "should have scored more points" LOL The HC/OC are going to employ what they need to win, nothing more. Why expose your whole toolbox so that the next opponent gets a heads up on what you might do? The most solid strategy is to only show what is necessary to achieve the goal, winning. Same reason poker players don't show what they are holding unless called, don't want to give anything away. Go Niners!

I still remember the '94 team just getting a lead by halftime and pretty much calling 80% run plays (in certain games) the rest of the game and coasting to a bunch of wins. Thats another way to not show your entire tool box to the next team.

I think us losing Ricky Watters the following year really hurt us. Even more so that Deion Sanders.

100%. Letting him walk was the beginning of the end.

Originally posted by 5_Golden_Rings:
Trey wanted out. Not sure he gets traded if he doesn't ask to be traded.

Lol. I just cannot believe people buy this.

Oh well, meaningless in the grand scheme of things.