QB Brock Purdy Thread

Originally posted by SmokeyJoe:

Originally posted by krizay:
Are you serious right now? Your joking right?

Well you see, if George Kittle is out there that makes the QB read defenses better, process faster, play with more poise in the face of a rush, throw more accurately… etc.

Yeah, you don't have to have everyone out there in order to play good. If Brock needs all pros at every position just to have a good game, then he himself is trash.

having good talent around you makes it easier, but he can still play well if dwelley is in there, or anyone.

What some fail to realize that even if a play doesn't work, doesn't mean the QB didn't play well.

That's why I never understood that argument for Trey. Trey struggled to do the little things right, that makes a qb play well.

Originally posted by tankle104:
Yeah, you don't have to have everyone out there in order to play good. If Brock needs all pros at every position just to have a good game, then he himself is trash.

having good talent around you makes it easier, but he can still play well if dwelley is in there, or anyone.

What some fail to realize that even if a play doesn't work, doesn't mean the QB didn't play well.

That's why I never understood that argument for Trey. Trey struggled to do the little things right, that makes a qb play well.

Not worth understanding. It's just a bad argument by peeps who tend to judge QBs with a high priority on team production. If Kittle isn't playing, I'd expect the offense and the QB's production to suffer some. I still would expect the QB to play his position well from an individual standpoint.

40% chance of rain for Sunday afternoon

Originally posted by SmokeyJoe:

Originally posted by tankle104:
Yeah, you don't have to have everyone out there in order to play good. If Brock needs all pros at every position just to have a good game, then he himself is trash.

having good talent around you makes it easier, but he can still play well if dwelley is in there, or anyone.

What some fail to realize that even if a play doesn't work, doesn't mean the QB didn't play well.

That's why I never understood that argument for Trey. Trey struggled to do the little things right, that makes a qb play well.

Not worth understanding. It's just a bad argument by peeps who tend to judge QBs with a high priority on team production. If Kittle isn't playing, I'd expect the offense and the QB's production to suffer some. I still would expect the QB to play his position well from an individual standpoint.

exactly, I hope Kittle plays cause he is awesome and a difference maker - super fun to watch. Like you said, I expect Brock to do his individual job at a high level regardless.

It's just odd that some can't differentiate between a QB executing the responsibilities of the position well vs the offense as a whole not playing as well because the quality of players in the game.

Originally posted by riverrunzthruit:
40% chance of rain for Sunday afternoon

I think rain imoproves the 49ers chances of winning. Though I have said from the start I think (on a sunny day) the 49ers win by 10.

Originally posted by riverrunzthruit:
40% chance of rain for Sunday afternoon

lmao noooooo really?! i hope it doesn't rain. if it does, I hope it's light. I don't like rainy games in general.

hopefully Pennsylvania is like Cali where it says it'll rain and never does. lmao

Originally posted by tankle104:

Originally posted by riverrunzthruit:
40% chance of rain for Sunday afternoon

lmao noooooo really?! i hope it doesn't rain. if it does, I hope it's light. I don't like rainy games in general.

hopefully Pennsylvania is like Cali where it says it'll rain and never does. lmao

last year was odd for home games, it rained every game except for like two games

Originally posted by riverrunzthruit:
40% chance of rain for Sunday afternoon

I hope it's a f**king monsoon on Sunday and sets records for the city of Pittsburgh.

And I hope Deebo fumbles at the 7 yard line on the first drive when we're heading in to score. And that the Oline plays like complete trash all day long. And that Kittle and McCaffery take the week off.

Ok now let's get this win!

Originally posted by Ezekiel38:
I hope it's a f**king monsoon on Sunday and sets records for the city of Pittsburgh.

Lolol

*add a couple more for the extra crying in your edit.

Originally posted by riverrunzthruit:
40% chance of rain for Sunday afternoon

Maybe purdy needs to pull a kenny two gloves on sunday

Originally posted by Ezekiel38:

Originally posted by riverrunzthruit:
40% chance of rain for Sunday afternoon

I hope it's a f**king monsoon on Sunday and sets records for the city of Pittsburgh.

And I hope Deebo fumbles at the 7 yard line on the first drive when we're heading in to score. And that the Oline plays like complete trash all day long. And that Kittle and McCaffery take the week off.

Ok now let's get this win!

Butthurt is real with this one.

Originally posted by SmokeyJoe:

Originally posted by krizay:
Are you serious right now? Your joking right?

Well you see, if George Kittle is out there that makes the QB read defenses better, process faster, play with more poise in the face of a rush, throw more accurately… etc.

Classic strawman

Originally posted by Waterbear:
Classic strawman

Is it? I'm pretty certain I repeatedly saw Trey's performances defended because of missing players, along with weather conditions… etc.

Wasn't that the exact reason you mentioned it? Seems pretty clear in your post.

Originally posted by SmokeyJoe:

Originally posted by Waterbear:
Classic strawman

Is it? I'm pretty certain I repeatedly saw Trey's performances defended because of missing players, along with weather conditions… etc.

Wasn't that the exact reason you mentioned it? Seems pretty clear in your post.

Correlation =/= causation

So yes, a lot of fans used Kittle's absence to defend Trey, but I didn't see any fans actually claim it caused Trey to not read defenses, process slower, or throw with less accuracy. That's what I'm saying is a strawman. I saw more people gaslight those ideas, or claim that people were saying Kittle's absence or the rain was the only reason Trey played poorly, when in reality the number of people who said those things verbatim was slim to none.

My OP was just agreeing with the idea that not having Kittle did not CAUSE Trey to play poorly and I'm simply applying that rule to all 49ers QBs, equally. Which is something I feel like I've been very consistent in doing.
Considering I've always said Trey hadn't reached the standard we needed him to play at, while Purdy exceeded that standard.

Originally posted by Koldo:

Originally posted by Ezekiel38:

Originally posted by riverrunzthruit:
40% chance of rain for Sunday afternoon

I hope it's a f**king monsoon on Sunday and sets records for the city of Pittsburgh.

And I hope Deebo fumbles at the 7 yard line on the first drive when we're heading in to score. And that the Oline plays like complete trash all day long. And that Kittle and McCaffery take the week off.

Ok now let's get this win!

Butthurt is real with this one.

Boy i can only imagine how hard he'll take the wins