QB Brock Purdy Thread

Originally posted by NinerBuff:
Mahomes
Burrow
Lawrence
Herbert

are the only for sure

Hurts
Allen
Tua

maybe

Originally posted by DonnieDarko:

Originally posted by NinerBuff:
Mahomes
Burrow
Lawrence
Herbert

are the only for sure

Hurts
Allen
Tua

maybe

USC's Caleb Williams lol

Originally posted by tankle104:

Originally posted by CornellU49er:

Originally posted by NinerBuff:

Originally posted by SLCNiner:

#Cowboys Micah Parsons calls #49ers Brock Purdy a top 15 QB and says he shouldn't be slept on anymore 👀

(via @BleacherReport) pic.twitter.com/Z6ew4tAvrd

— 𝙏𝙝𝙚𝙎𝙁𝙉𝙞𝙣𝙚𝙧𝙨 (@TheSFNiners) September 12, 2023

Everything he said seemed pretty accurate. Brock somewhere between 10-15th, but I can accept a small sample size for skepticism. And maybe bump one number up with Rodgers going down.

How many QBs would you trade straight up for Purdy right now and who are they?

* Understand there will be some homerism here, myself included
* Assume you can get each QB on Purdy's current contract to take salary cap implications out of it - purely a performance assessment, now and projecting into the future.

I am struggling to come up with more than 8. This might be the whole list (not in order):

Mahomes
Burrow
Hurts
Lawrence
Allen
Jackson
Herbert

and even a couple of those I kind of have to think about based on scheme fit…..

Dak? Stafford? Rodgers? Cousins? Tua? Hard pass

It's wild that parsons has a better take than most 49ers fans Lmao

Originally posted by SanDiego49er:
This is where the pundits are wrong. You can have a meathead who can throw 75 yards. 3 int's and 1 fumbled snap. 4 turnovers. Anybody watch MNF?

Or have elite processing ability before and after the snap, make excellent decisions, get the ball out quick, excellent mechanics, throw accurate catchable passes. Don't make the big mistakes.

So which would you rather have? Somebody tell Cohn and these other idiots.

Originally posted by SanDiego49er:
This is where the pundits are wrong. You can have a meathead who can throw 75 yards. 3 int's and 1 fumbled snap. 4 turnovers. Anybody watch MNF?

Or have elite processing ability before and after the snap, make excellent decisions, get the ball out quick, excellent mechanics, throw accurate catchable passes. Don't make the big mistakes.

So which would you rather have? Somebody tell Cohn and these other idiots.

Originally posted by GoreGoreGore:

Originally posted by SanDiego49er:
This is where the pundits are wrong. You can have a meathead who can throw 75 yards. 3 int's and 1 fumbled snap. 4 turnovers. Anybody watch MNF?

Or have elite processing ability before and after the snap, make excellent decisions, get the ball out quick, excellent mechanics, throw accurate catchable passes. Don't make the big mistakes.

So which would you rather have? Somebody tell Cohn and these other idiots.

Are you trying to argue that Purdy>Allen?

Lmao. Love Purdy, but holy homer take buddy.

Originally posted by GoreGoreGore:

Originally posted by SanDiego49er:
This is where the pundits are wrong. You can have a meathead who can throw 75 yards. 3 int's and 1 fumbled snap. 4 turnovers. Anybody watch MNF?

Or have elite processing ability before and after the snap, make excellent decisions, get the ball out quick, excellent mechanics, throw accurate catchable passes. Don't make the big mistakes.

So which would you rather have? Somebody tell Cohn and these other idiots.

Are you trying to argue that Purdy>Allen?

Lmao. Love Purdy, but holy homer take buddy.

I mean maybe if he continues this level of play through the year, but even people weren't crowning Pat as a top QB with only 7-8 games under his belt.

Originally posted by mayo49:

Originally posted by GoreGoreGore:

Originally posted by SanDiego49er:
This is where the pundits are wrong. You can have a meathead who can throw 75 yards. 3 int's and 1 fumbled snap. 4 turnovers. Anybody watch MNF?

Or have elite processing ability before and after the snap, make excellent decisions, get the ball out quick, excellent mechanics, throw accurate catchable passes. Don't make the big mistakes.

So which would you rather have? Somebody tell Cohn and these other idiots.

Are you trying to argue that Purdy>Allen?

Lmao. Love Purdy, but holy homer take buddy.

He might not have the talent of an Allen, but I bet Purdy wins a Super Bowl before Allen.

Originally posted by mayo49:

Originally posted by GoreGoreGore:

Originally posted by SanDiego49er:
This is where the pundits are wrong. You can have a meathead who can throw 75 yards. 3 int's and 1 fumbled snap. 4 turnovers. Anybody watch MNF?

Or have elite processing ability before and after the snap, make excellent decisions, get the ball out quick, excellent mechanics, throw accurate catchable passes. Don't make the big mistakes.

So which would you rather have? Somebody tell Cohn and these other idiots.

Are you trying to argue that Purdy>Allen?

Lmao. Love Purdy, but holy homer take buddy.

He might not have the talent of an Allen, but I bet Purdy wins a Super Bowl before Allen.

Originally posted by mayo49:

Originally posted by GoreGoreGore:

Originally posted by SanDiego49er:
This is where the pundits are wrong. You can have a meathead who can throw 75 yards. 3 int's and 1 fumbled snap. 4 turnovers. Anybody watch MNF?

Or have elite processing ability before and after the snap, make excellent decisions, get the ball out quick, excellent mechanics, throw accurate catchable passes. Don't make the big mistakes.

So which would you rather have? Somebody tell Cohn and these other idiots.

Are you trying to argue that Purdy>Allen?

Lmao. Love Purdy, but holy homer take buddy.

He might not have the talent of an Allen, but I bet Purdy wins a Super Bowl before Allen.

Originally posted by GoreGoreGore:
Possibly. But do you think if Allen was our QB we wouldn't be hands down the SB favorite?

Originally posted by SmokeyJoe:

Originally posted by GoreGoreGore:
Possibly. But do you think if Allen was our QB we wouldn't be hands down the SB favorite?

Could probably push for 20-0.

That guy carries his offense. We would reduce his burden so much with our scheme and talent.

Originally posted by NinerBuff:

Originally posted by SmokeyJoe:

Originally posted by GoreGoreGore:
Possibly. But do you think if Allen was our QB we wouldn't be hands down the SB favorite?

Could probably push for 20-0.

That guy carries his offense. We would reduce his burden so much with our scheme and talent.

It's not apples to apples because Allen costs literally 50x more.