QB Brock Purdy Thread

Originally posted by NinerBuff:
It's not apples to apples because Allen costs literally 50x more.

You're totally right. Salaries aside though for the purposes of discussion...

Originally posted by SmokeyJoe:

Originally posted by NinerBuff:
It's not apples to apples because Allen costs literally 50x more.

You're totally right. Salaries aside though for the purposes of discussion...

If Allen somehow made Purdy money, then the choice is obvious. The dude had 42 TDs and like 12 picks one year.

Originally posted by NinerBuff:
If Allen somehow made Purdy money, then the choice is obvious. The dude had 42 TDs and like 12 picks one year.

Allen was arm punting his tail off tonight

Originally posted by NinerBuff:
If Allen somehow made Purdy money, then the choice is obvious. The dude had 42 TDs and like 12 picks one year.

I would take Allen at his current salary over Purdy at his as well... sacrificing players in the process.

I'm very happy with Purdy though and think he can be a great player.

Originally posted by SmokeyJoe:
I would take Allen at his current salary over Purdy at his as well... sacrificing players in the process.

I'm very happy with Purdy though and think he can be a great player.

You would? Absolutely ZERO chance I would. I'm actually hoping Purdy keeps it chill to not have to pay him that much, but looking at Brock's #s since he's been playing for us, not a f**king chance would I take Allen over him, unless they were paid the same.

Originally posted by GoreGoreGore:

Originally posted by SanDiego49er:
This is where the pundits are wrong. You can have a meathead who can throw 75 yards. 3 int's and 1 fumbled snap. 4 turnovers. Anybody watch MNF?

Or have elite processing ability before and after the snap, make excellent decisions, get the ball out quick, excellent mechanics, throw accurate catchable passes. Don't make the big mistakes.

So which would you rather have? Somebody tell Cohn and these other idiots.

Are you trying to argue that Purdy>Allen?

Lmao. Love Purdy, but holy homer take buddy.

I mean maybe if he continues this level of play through the year, but even people weren't crowning Pat as a top QB with only 7-8 games under his belt.

Purdy is better than Allen. Allen is looking overrated, he panics and throws the ball up for grabs. He has below average decision making and processing speed. It takes much more than arm strength and being 6'5" to be a great qb. Why would you want a guy who turns it over four times? Not even Jimmy had four in one game that I can recall.

Originally posted by SLCNiner:
You would? Absolutely ZERO chance I would. I'm actually hoping Purdy keeps it chill to not have to pay him that much, but looking at Brock's #s since he's been playing for us, not a f**king chance would I take Allen over him, unless they were paid the same.

I would. I think Purdy's been great and I don't like to argue against him, but as skilled as he has been the numbers and production are also the product of the team around him. He's got an elite running game, the best overall set of weapons in the game, and a top two offensive coach. He's a great fit system wise because of his accuracy, quick decision making, and ability to extend plays.

Josh is basically a one man wrecking crew. It's him and Diggs and no running game. It would be like putting a modern day version of John Elway in the Shanahan offense. He's an all time talent. He can hit any spot on the field with a variety of throw types, extend plays, and gouge defenses on the run.

As far as Purdy's salary goes... if he stays on this track I expect him to command a huge number. The fact that he's only making a million a year is not going to help us come negotiation time probably. Would love to have it become reality, and would love to be wrong about what he commands, lol.

Originally posted by Memphis9er:

Originally posted by GoreGoreGore:

Originally posted by SanDiego49er:
This is where the pundits are wrong. You can have a meathead who can throw 75 yards. 3 int's and 1 fumbled snap. 4 turnovers. Anybody watch MNF?

Or have elite processing ability before and after the snap, make excellent decisions, get the ball out quick, excellent mechanics, throw accurate catchable passes. Don't make the big mistakes.

So which would you rather have? Somebody tell Cohn and these other idiots.

Are you trying to argue that Purdy>Allen?

Lmao. Love Purdy, but holy homer take buddy.

I mean maybe if he continues this level of play through the year, but even people weren't crowning Pat as a top QB with only 7-8 games under his belt.

Purdy is better than Allen. Allen is looking overrated, he panics and throws the ball up for grabs. He has below average decision making and processing speed. It takes much more than arm strength and being 6'5" to be a great qb. Why would you want a guy who turns it over four times? Not even Jimmy had four in one game that I can recall.

You make great points there and you may be right too.

Originally posted by Memphis9er:

Originally posted by GoreGoreGore:

Originally posted by SanDiego49er:
This is where the pundits are wrong. You can have a meathead who can throw 75 yards. 3 int's and 1 fumbled snap. 4 turnovers. Anybody watch MNF?

Or have elite processing ability before and after the snap, make excellent decisions, get the ball out quick, excellent mechanics, throw accurate catchable passes. Don't make the big mistakes.

So which would you rather have? Somebody tell Cohn and these other idiots.

Are you trying to argue that Purdy>Allen?

Lmao. Love Purdy, but holy homer take buddy.

I mean maybe if he continues this level of play through the year, but even people weren't crowning Pat as a top QB with only 7-8 games under his belt.

Purdy is better than Allen. Allen is looking overrated, he panics and throws the ball up for grabs. He has below average decision making and processing speed. It takes much more than arm strength and being 6'5" to be a great qb. Why would you want a guy who turns it over four times? Not even Jimmy had four in one game that I can recall.

Outside of some niner fans, there is not one other person on this planet that would not take Allen. Be it fans, GMs, coaches, players, politicians, gardeners, people in retirement homes, etc...

Like jfc people

He already is a great QB too lol... he had a bad game, it happens. I guess we should've cut Joe as well when he threw 4 picks.

Josh Allen with these playmakers wouldnt be fair.

Originally posted by SanDiego49er:

Originally posted by Memphis9er:

Originally posted by GoreGoreGore:

Originally posted by SanDiego49er:
This is where the pundits are wrong. You can have a meathead who can throw 75 yards. 3 int's and 1 fumbled snap. 4 turnovers. Anybody watch MNF?

Or have elite processing ability before and after the snap, make excellent decisions, get the ball out quick, excellent mechanics, throw accurate catchable passes. Don't make the big mistakes.

So which would you rather have? Somebody tell Cohn and these other idiots.

Are you trying to argue that Purdy>Allen?

Lmao. Love Purdy, but holy homer take buddy.

I mean maybe if he continues this level of play through the year, but even people weren't crowning Pat as a top QB with only 7-8 games under his belt.

Purdy is better than Allen. Allen is looking overrated, he panics and throws the ball up for grabs. He has below average decision making and processing speed. It takes much more than arm strength and being 6'5" to be a great qb. Why would you want a guy who turns it over four times? Not even Jimmy had four in one game that I can recall.

You make great points there and you may be right too.

There was an offense philosophy change when daboll left and it's leaving it's mark. I doubt Allen would make the same mistakes here.

As for Purdy being better, i guess we would need to see how Purdy is doing after playing for 5 seasons

Originally posted by GoreGoreGore:

Originally posted by Memphis9er:

Originally posted by GoreGoreGore:

Originally posted by SanDiego49er:
This is where the pundits are wrong. You can have a meathead who can throw 75 yards. 3 int's and 1 fumbled snap. 4 turnovers. Anybody watch MNF?

Or have elite processing ability before and after the snap, make excellent decisions, get the ball out quick, excellent mechanics, throw accurate catchable passes. Don't make the big mistakes.

So which would you rather have? Somebody tell Cohn and these other idiots.

Are you trying to argue that Purdy>Allen?

Lmao. Love Purdy, but holy homer take buddy.

I mean maybe if he continues this level of play through the year, but even people weren't crowning Pat as a top QB with only 7-8 games under his belt.

Purdy is better than Allen. Allen is looking overrated, he panics and throws the ball up for grabs. He has below average decision making and processing speed. It takes much more than arm strength and being 6'5" to be a great qb. Why would you want a guy who turns it over four times? Not even Jimmy had four in one game that I can recall.

Outside of some niner fans, there is not one other person on this planet that would not take Allen. Be it fans, GMs, coaches, players, politicians, gardeners, people in a old home, etc...

Like jfc people

He's hugely mistake prone and chokes in the big games and playoffs routinely. You are slightly overrating him. Due to 6'5" 240 lbs. and a big arm. But the processing and decision making, risky throws, bad decisions are well below average in some cases. In big games and key moments. That's also part of him. Don't deny it isn't. That's simply not true.

Originally posted by mayo49:

Originally posted by SanDiego49er:
This is where the pundits are wrong. You can have a meathead who can throw 75 yards. 3 int's and 1 fumbled snap. 4 turnovers. Anybody watch MNF?

Or have elite processing ability before and after the snap, make excellent decisions, get the ball out quick, excellent mechanics, throw accurate catchable passes. Don't make the big mistakes.

So which would you rather have? Somebody tell Cohn and these other idiots.

He had a bad game, Allen is legit.

Nah, he's the most overrated QB in the NFL. The guy is an INT machine.

Originally posted by SanDiego49er:

Originally posted by GoreGoreGore:

Originally posted by Memphis9er:

Originally posted by GoreGoreGore:

Originally posted by SanDiego49er:
This is where the pundits are wrong. You can have a meathead who can throw 75 yards. 3 int's and 1 fumbled snap. 4 turnovers. Anybody watch MNF?

Or have elite processing ability before and after the snap, make excellent decisions, get the ball out quick, excellent mechanics, throw accurate catchable passes. Don't make the big mistakes.

So which would you rather have? Somebody tell Cohn and these other idiots.

Are you trying to argue that Purdy>Allen?

Lmao. Love Purdy, but holy homer take buddy.

I mean maybe if he continues this level of play through the year, but even people weren't crowning Pat as a top QB with only 7-8 games under his belt.

Purdy is better than Allen. Allen is looking overrated, he panics and throws the ball up for grabs. He has below average decision making and processing speed. It takes much more than arm strength and being 6'5" to be a great qb. Why would you want a guy who turns it over four times? Not even Jimmy had four in one game that I can recall.

Outside of some niner fans, there is not one other person on this planet that would not take Allen. Be it fans, GMs, coaches, players, politicians, gardeners, people in a old home, etc...

Like jfc people

He's hugely mistake prone and chokes in the big games and playoffs routinely. You are slightly overrating him. Due to 6'5" 240 lbs. and a big arm. But the processing and decision making, risky throws, bad decisions are well below average in some cases. In big games and key moments. That's also part of him. Don't deny it isn't. That's simply not true.

So their definitely not below average lol. It's not great that's for sure, but he's also still learning as well which makes it even scarier that he can be better. You would have to be really stupid to think that Allen isnt a really good QB. This a very dumb conversation.

Originally posted by Koldo:

Originally posted by mayo49:

Originally posted by SanDiego49er:
This is where the pundits are wrong. You can have a meathead who can throw 75 yards. 3 int's and 1 fumbled snap. 4 turnovers. Anybody watch MNF?

Or have elite processing ability before and after the snap, make excellent decisions, get the ball out quick, excellent mechanics, throw accurate catchable passes. Don't make the big mistakes.

So which would you rather have? Somebody tell Cohn and these other idiots.

He had a bad game, Allen is legit.

Nah, he's the most overrated QB in the NFL. The guy is an INT machine.

He's mistake prone in big games and certainly the playoffs. I wouldn't be surprised to see Purdy win the Super Bowl before Josh Allen. I'm serious.