There are 224 users in the forums

QB Brock Purdy Thread

Shop Find 49ers gear online

QB Brock Purdy Thread

Originally posted by fropwns:
I just came in to say hi to my homies, and to say, "f**k Florio".

That is all.

Aye. That little s**tgobblin has been spewing sewage for years. The only solution is to not give him clicks.
The surrounding talent critique is a moot point, can only judge the kid by how he plays, unless we have loads of injuries he's going to have great weapons and great coaching, national media need to get over it.

If Brock was a top 5 draft pick everyone would be proclaiming him as the next coming.
Originally posted by fropwns:
I just came in to say hi to my homies, and to say, "f**k Florio".

That is all.

Right here with you. He is just an assclown with a platform at this point. Him and Grant Cohn can both go screw themselves.
Florio...lol what a 💩

Sorry but Purdy is a hot AF name

That is all lol
Originally posted by Koldo:
Originally posted by Bay2Bay9erAllday:
Here's one for the "weakest arm in the NFL" crowd


Ball placement was stellar.

Yep.

All arm on that dime. Going backwards, throwing against his momentum, into a tight window.

remember this bootleg throw Lance had vs the Texans, that everyone was gushing about?

[twitter

Posters saying very few QBs can make that throw. Apparently, Brock is one of those few QBs. Elite arm talent.

IMO, purdys throw is a lot more impressive due to degree of difficulty.
[ Edited by Bay2Bay9erAllday on Sep 23, 2023 at 2:12 PM ]
Originally posted by Jeepzilla:
Originally posted by Bay2Bay9erAllday:
Originally posted by qnnhan7:
Originally posted by SmokeyJoe:
Originally posted by _Goldblooded_:
I like his channel and agree with almost everything. I am not sure I buy that the Deebo TD was a happy accident on an underthrow.

Same. It's hard to tell. Baldy thought it was good, but JTO probably more credible.

I'm good with it working bottom line, lol.



They probably practiced the same route and pass all through camp

Almost had another one here.

Nicely Stepped up into the pocket & He's been avoiding that backwards bailout/spin to the left also..

You can teach an old dog new tricks I guess lol

I mean he was doing that last season. Just needed to do it more.
Originally posted by random49er:
Originally posted by YACBros85:
So do almost TD's weigh as heavy as almost INT's?

Which stat is associated stronger with losing and winning? Having +1 INT or having +1 TD?

TD because an Interception could happen on 3rd down and be a long throw that is basically a punt. A TD is points, so it is always going to be better, unless it is a pick 6.
Haven't read much of this thread lately, but has NY brought up his "almost INT's" yet? Just wondering lol

Originally posted by SlipAndSlideBosa:
Originally posted by random49er:
Originally posted by YACBros85:
So do almost TD's weigh as heavy as almost INT's?

Which stat is associated stronger with losing and winning? Having +1 INT or having +1 TD?

TD because an Interception could happen on 3rd down and be a long throw that is basically a punt. A TD is points, so it is always going to be better, unless it is a pick 6.

So, it comes down to context? Makes sense.
  • Giedi
  • Veteran
  • Posts: 33,368
Originally posted by OnTheClock:
Originally posted by Giedi:
Originally posted by OnTheClock:
There's so much bashing on Brock on social media it makes me sick, man.

Everyone's saying he's not good at all or solid at best because of his supporting cast.

Calling BS here 1000%.

They talk about his cast as if they forget Kurt Warner had a hall of fame RB two hall of fame caliber WR top 5-10 defense. He had that offensive cast in Arizona too when he went to the Super Bowl with them.

People bash Purdy for having talent around him as if it doesn't matter that he still has to make good throws to get them the ball in time, accurately and make good decisions under pressure..

You nailed it. Joe and Steve also had talent surrounding them. It's super bowl wins vs the highest competition that will get the narrative turned around. We can see the greatness in Brock, most others can't because of the Bias they have about 7th rounders and guys that aren't 6'4" and blessed with Aaron Rodger's rocket arms.

It's just nonsense. Warner looked awful much of his time in New York when he was stuck on a crap team.

Garcia is another when he went to Cleveland. Plenty of other examples that prove you need other talent on your team to win along with good coaching.
Agree 💯%, and like you said in another thread, it doesn't matter what talent a QB is surrounded by, if they can't get it to said talent, then that surrounding talent is worthless. Trey would not read or be able to hit on a lot of passes Brock is hitting now, but he gets a nod because he's physically talented. Nothing wrong with the bias, I just think its more evidence how biased and negative the mainstream and social media is in general to anything new or different.
  • Giedi
  • Veteran
  • Posts: 33,368
Originally posted by NCommand:
Originally posted by Giedi:
Originally posted by NCommand:
Originally posted by father49er:
Originally posted by brodiebluebanaszak:
Originally posted by okdkid:
He's knocking on that top 5 QB tier.

Huh? He's already there. #5 NFL fating, #3 QBR.

He's playing at Mahommes level. If he stays consistent, he's generational talent. He's the missing piece of any offense.

He's playing better than PM ATM. PM is running around for his life and playing hero ball averaging 18 points per game and KC is tied with the Raiders in their division.

Wow, I had to check. His offense scored 20 points vs Detroit, and 17 points vs the jaguars. He's also thrown two interceptions.

No more tier 1 OL.

It matters. Even for the greatest QB ever to walk the WZ earth.

Agree 💯%, and its a fact that most fantasy football doesn't draft offensive linemen because they don't directly score points for that kind of game. I don't play so I'm assuming a lot, and I'm probably wrong.

Even Mahomes needs time to read the defense and throw to the right guy. If he doesn't have the time, how can he do what he does, as gifted as he is physically.
Originally posted by Giedi:
Originally posted by Kolohe:
WTF is Florio talkin bout, Pur-dy is damn close to Bra-dy.


Agree, they *do* sound the same!

Yep! Florio..Latin/Italian meaning:
Blooming flower...just sayin
  • Giedi
  • Veteran
  • Posts: 33,368
Originally posted by tankle104:
Originally posted by Heroism:
EDIT I don't want to jinx him.

Purdy gonna get paid. /

Well in nearly an absolute worst case scenario (assuming he's starting), he will get $25-$30M a year. That's bottom tier for actually solid starting QBs. If he keeps up what he's doing - he will most likely fall in the $45-$55M - year salary. Which is still a relative bargain based on where the salaries for QBs are heading.

I don't think Brock's future salary closes any Superbowl windows. I think lack of talent is more of a factor. Yes once a QB is paid there is less money for everyone else, but the Patriots still won Superbowls despite Tom being paid. Russel, Brees and Rodgers winning only one Superbowl is more because they lost a lot of great coaching and had some average drafts after the Superbowl win than because of a lack of cap space. Ben won two Superbowl's despite being paid as another example that a QB being paid doesn't necessarily close the Superbowl window.
Originally posted by Giedi:
Originally posted by tankle104:
Originally posted by Heroism:
EDIT I don't want to jinx him.

Purdy gonna get paid. /

Well in nearly an absolute worst case scenario (assuming he's starting), he will get $25-$30M a year. That's bottom tier for actually solid starting QBs. If he keeps up what he's doing - he will most likely fall in the $45-$55M - year salary. Which is still a relative bargain based on where the salaries for QBs are heading.

I don't think Brock's future salary closes any Superbowl windows. I think lack of talent is more of a factor. Yes once a QB is paid there is less money for everyone else, but the Patriots still won Superbowls despite Tom being paid. Russel, Brees and Rodgers winning only one Superbowl is more because they lost a lot of great coaching and had some average drafts after the Superbowl win than because of a lack of cap space. Ben won two Superbowl's despite being paid as another example that a QB being paid doesn't necessarily close the Superbowl window.

I think the way our contracts are set up, the cap increases, and our talent evaluation/drafting gives us a lot of optimism. I'm not concerned about it.

i believe we will figure it out.

no qb wins a Super Bowl without talent around them, or it happens very seldom. It's not Brock's fault that he is surrounded by talent, great coaching, and scheme. It really is any young QBs dream. He's done a great job making the most of it - you can see him still learning and growing too. It's a great platform for any qb and he's doing his part as the qb. He will get better as time goes on, we just have to hope he's good enough now to capitalize on this roster this year - which I think he is.
It doesn't help that Herbstreet is constantly comparing him to Stetson Bennnett. I like Herbstreet generally. But come on.

Stetson Bennett = 5'11" 190 lbs.

Brock Purdy = 6'1" 215 lbs. Perhaps even listed at times at 220 lbs.

Yeah that's the same person Herbstreet. 2 inches taller and 25 pounds heavier. Just look at his legs. He's sturdy and strongly built. Purdy is way stronger and a stronger arm than that. There is no comparison. Plus all the "system quarterback" slights.

If you can't see that Purdy is way more Sturdy and has way more arm talent I don't know what to tell you. He's much stronger and a stronger thrower with better accuracy and better at reading the field too. A better athlete running around too. Just no comparison here at all. It's ridiculous.

Search Share 49ersWebzone