QB Brock Purdy Thread

Steve Ruiz makes Grant Cohn look like a Steve Young take. What a dips**t.

Originally posted by Chance:

Originally posted by NCommand:
Actually Kyle is the man.

Not mutually exclusive

I just meant both Tua and Brock are playing in the same Kyle-system, albeit with different personnel and different focuses (e.g. run vs. pass-centric).

Originally posted by Montana:

Originally posted by NCommand:
Be efficient. B-E efficient!

I like that chart lol

For sure!

Originally posted by tankle104:

Originally posted by SanDiego49er:
The argument that it's just great athletes. Tua has the Olympic track team out there. As if he doesn't have great athletes. Mahomes has played with great athletes his whole career. Speedy WR's, RB's and an all time TE. Along with one of the best coaches. It's not like he has nothing out there. It's ridculous.

Never apologize for having great coaching and teammates. It's the dumbest argument. Anyone that knows football knows when a qb is just riding the coat tails of their talented teammates/scheme vs actually playing at a high level and elevating the team around them. Brock makes a lot of great plays. He hits a lot of tough throws, puts his guys in great position to make a play, he's accurate, on time, excellent anticipation. Reads the defense quickly and makes the right play - all of that stuff is hard. It isn't just hitting wide open guys. There is so much to playing qb and he makes it look easy, that's how you know he's playing great.

Everything felt so much harder when Jimmy or Lance was playing. Now it just feels like that if we don't have a good drive, it was excellent defense by the opposing team. Not some horrific misread or bad throw like we saw a lot with the other QBs. It's so much fun. I can't freakin wait for tomorrow night.

Yes that's correct. I agree completely.

Originally posted by NCommand:

Originally posted by Chance:

Originally posted by NCommand:
Actually Kyle is the man.

Not mutually exclusive

I just meant both Tua and Brock are playing in the same Kyle-system, albeit with different personnel and different focuses (e.g. run vs. pass-centric).

Also, Kyle focuses on physical weapons who can play multiple positions. Mike McDaniel focuses speed in the skill positions.

Originally posted by libertyforever:

Originally posted by NCommand:

Originally posted by Chance:

Originally posted by NCommand:
Actually Kyle is the man.

Not mutually exclusive

I just meant both Tua and Brock are playing in the same Kyle-system, albeit with different personnel and different focuses (e.g. run vs. pass-centric).

Also, Kyle focuses on physical weapons who can play multiple positions. Mike McDaniel focuses speed in the skill positions.

No doubt! Two sides of the same coin.

Originally posted by NCommand:

Originally posted by tankle104:

Holy s**t… Jeff Saturday BARKING about Brock Purdy 🫡 go ahead big fella #49ers pic.twitter.com/tZkgzxqt9T

— ryan (@RyanChillin) October 4, 2023

would be crazy if he won MVP. I don't expect it but would be so badass

Little chance of that. Not a QB-centric offense for those kinds of numbers.

he said nothing wrong. People are starting to catch on

Originally posted by NCommand:

Originally posted by Chance:

Originally posted by NCommand:
Actually Kyle is the man.

Not mutually exclusive

I just meant both Tua and Brock are playing in the same Kyle-system, albeit with different personnel and different focuses (e.g. run vs. pass-centric).

I don't disagree. Kyle is the man.

Brock is also the man. A perfect match.

Originally posted by ninerjok:
Steve Ruiz makes Grant Cohn look like a Steve Young take. What a dips**t.

As if we didn't have enough of a reason to root for six. This guy needs instant karma.

Originally posted by NCommand:

Originally posted by tankle104:

Holy s**t… Jeff Saturday BARKING about Brock Purdy 🫡 go ahead big fella #49ers pic.twitter.com/tZkgzxqt9T

— ryan (@RyanChillin) October 4, 2023

would be crazy if he won MVP. I don't expect it but would be so badass

Little chance of that. Not a QB-centric offense for those kinds of numbers.

I don't man, his numbers are elite right now, and he's had two great games and two good games. Tomorrow has to be another great game, while not turning it over, and winning in prime time. With that, he'll be on the short list, With another challenger for MVP on the team… if Purdy throws 3 TDs to McCaffery, who gets the kudos?

The one thing I am trying to understand about the Purdy narrative is why is the fact Purdy may or may not be a "system" quarterback matters. Who cares?

Bill Walsh. Joe Montana. West Coast Offense. All go hand in hand in nfl history. They are all connected and that's the reason for their success. Right coach. Right player. Right system. Isn't that exactly what you want to have?

So why is it bad if Brock might suck in another teams offense? Who cares? He's killing it here in the offense that was designed for him by a great football mind. If Brock Purdy. Kyle Shanahan. Whatever you want to call this offense. Are all clicking like this. Why does it matter? Who cares what Lamar would look like in this offense or what Purdy would look like on another team.

The results are all that matters. Purdy is destroying it in Kyle's offense. Somehow that means his stats and performances are less meaningful?

It's a lame narrative.

Also lame. Purdy needs to have a bad game and get behind and "prove" he can lead a come back when it counts. How about just keep killing it and never get behind. I will take that instead.

Originally posted by Hammer:
The one thing I am trying to understand about the Purdy narrative is why is the fact Purdy may or may not be a "system" quarterback matters. Who cares?

Bill Walsh. Joe Montana. West Coast Offense. All go hand in hand in nfl history. They are all connected and that's the reason for their success. Right coach. Right player. Right system. Isn't that exactly what you want to have?

So why is it bad if Brock might suck in another teams offense? Who cares? He's killing it here in the offense that was designed for him by a great football mind. If Brock Purdy. Kyle Shanahan. Whatever you want to call this offense. Are all clicking like this. Why does it matter? Who cares what Lamar would like in this offense or what Purdy would look like on another team.

The results are all that matters. Purdy is destroying it in Kyle's offense. Somehow that means his stats and performances are some how less meaningful?

It's a lame narrative.

Also lame. Purdy needs to have a bad game and get behind and "prove" he can lead a come back when it counts. How about just keep killing it and never get behind. I will take that instead.

Why would you want to play from behind? That's so completely dumb it's unbelievable.

Originally posted by Hammer:
The one thing I am trying to understand about the Purdy narrative is why is the fact Purdy may or may not be a "system" quarterback matters. Who cares?

Bill Walsh. Joe Montana. West Coast Offense. All go hand in hand in nfl history. They are all connected and that's the reason for their success. Right coach. Right player. Right system. Isn't that exactly what you want to have?

So why is it bad if Brock might suck in another teams offense? Who cares? He's killing it here in the offense that was designed for him by a great football mind. If Brock Purdy. Kyle Shanahan. Whatever you want to call this offense. Are all clicking like this. Why does it matter? Who cares what Lamar would like in this offense or what Purdy would look like on another team.

The results are all that matters. Purdy is destroying it in Kyle's offense. Somehow that means his stats and performances are less meaningful?

It's a lame narrative.

Also lame. Purdy needs to have a bad game and get behind and "prove" he can lead a come back when it counts. How about just keep killing it and never get behind. I will take that instead.

Originally posted by Hammer:
The one thing I am trying to understand about the Purdy narrative is why is the fact Purdy may or may not be a "system" quarterback matters. Who cares?

Bill Walsh. Joe Montana. West Coast Offense. All go hand in hand in nfl history. They are all connected and that's the reason for their success. Right coach. Right player. Right system. Isn't that exactly what you want to have?

So why is it bad if Brock might suck in another teams offense? Who cares? He's killing it here in the offense that was designed for him by a great football mind. If Brock Purdy. Kyle Shanahan. Whatever you want to call this offense. Are all clicking like this. Why does it matter? Who cares what Lamar would look like in this offense or what Purdy would look like on another team.

The results are all that matters. Purdy is destroying it in Kyle's offense. Somehow that means his stats and performances are less meaningful?

It's a lame narrative.

Also lame. Purdy needs to have a bad game and get behind and "prove" he can lead a come back when it counts. How about just keep killing it and never get behind. I will take that instead.

Originally posted by SanDiego49er:

Originally posted by tankle104:

Originally posted by SanDiego49er:
The argument that it's just great athletes. Tua has the Olympic track team out there. As if he doesn't have great athletes. Mahomes has played with great athletes his whole career. Speedy WR's, RB's and an all time TE. Along with one of the best coaches. It's not like he has nothing out there. It's ridculous.

Never apologize for having great coaching and teammates. It's the dumbest argument. Anyone that knows football knows when a qb is just riding the coat tails of their talented teammates/scheme vs actually playing at a high level and elevating the team around them. Brock makes a lot of great plays. He hits a lot of tough throws, puts his guys in great position to make a play, he's accurate, on time, excellent anticipation. Reads the defense quickly and makes the right play - all of that stuff is hard. It isn't just hitting wide open guys. There is so much to playing qb and he makes it look easy, that's how you know he's playing great.

Everything felt so much harder when Jimmy or Lance was playing. Now it just feels like that if we don't have a good drive, it was excellent defense by the opposing team. Not some horrific misread or bad throw like we saw a lot with the other QBs. It's so much fun. I can't freakin wait for tomorrow night.

Yes that's correct. I agree completely.

You mean it's not like Madden?