QB Brock Purdy Thread

Originally posted by NCommand:

Originally posted by tankle104:

Holy s**t… Jeff Saturday BARKING about Brock Purdy 🫡 go ahead big fella #49ers pic.twitter.com/tZkgzxqt9T

— ryan (@RyanChillin) October 4, 2023

would be crazy if he won MVP. I don't expect it but would be so badass

Little chance of that. Not a QB-centric offense for those kinds of numbers.

Originally posted by Hammer:
The one thing I am trying to understand about the Purdy narrative is why is the fact Purdy may or may not be a "system" quarterback matters. Who cares?

Bill Walsh. Joe Montana. West Coast Offense. All go hand in hand in nfl history. They are all connected and that's the reason for their success. Right coach. Right player. Right system. Isn't that exactly what you want to have?

So why is it bad if Brock might suck in another teams offense? Who cares? He's killing it here in the offense that was designed for him by a great football mind. If Brock Purdy. Kyle Shanahan. Whatever you want to call this offense. Are all clicking like this. Why does it matter? Who cares what Lamar would look like in this offense or what Purdy would look like on another team.

The results are all that matters. Purdy is destroying it in Kyle's offense. Somehow that means his stats and performances are less meaningful?

It's a lame narrative.

Also lame. Purdy needs to have a bad game and get behind and "prove" he can lead a come back when it counts. How about just keep killing it and never get behind. I will take that instead.

Originally posted by Chance:
I actually don't see a system that Purdy wouldn't flourish in, provided it isn't a flawed system barren of surrounding talent. Throwing accurately with anticipation, reading defenses pre- and post-snap, making off-schedule plays, great agility and pocket awareness. I mean these are core to every successful QB. So why wouldn't Purdy do well elsewhere?

Originally posted by Montana:

Originally posted by tankle104:


lol I don't think Brock needs to ditch his roommate but I just thought I'd share this.

Sharpe annoys me a bit lol. It's called being smart. And who cares if he has a roommate? . Prices in the Bay Area are insane lol. I am guessing he isn't living with his girl until married cause he is a Christian who seems to take his faith srsly and it's not uncommon, in that case, to have a roommate with another dude. What's the big deal lol. Shannon is a bit drama lol. I think it's commendable and that it's great that he appears to go by what he says he believes in, while at the same time, saving money. He doesn't have a big contract right now, it's smart. He might be saving up for a wedding too but honestly, who the heck cares, it is his money. Please don't give Shannon my wallet ever lol. And btw..if Sharpe wants to pay his rent..by all means haha.

Originally posted by Chance:
I actually don't see a system that Purdy wouldn't flourish in, provided it isn't a flawed system barren of surrounding talent. Throwing accurately with anticipation, reading defenses pre- and post-snap, making off-schedule plays, great agility and pocket awareness. I mean these are core to every successful QB. So why wouldn't Purdy do well elsewhere?

Originally posted by SanDiego49er:

Originally posted by Chance:
I actually don't see a system that Purdy wouldn't flourish in, provided it isn't a flawed system barren of surrounding talent. Throwing accurately with anticipation, reading defenses pre- and post-snap, making off-schedule plays, great agility and pocket awareness. I mean these are core to every successful QB. So why wouldn't Purdy do well elsewhere?

He would be great anywhere. It's a lot of him.

Originally posted by riverrunzthruit:

Originally posted by Montana:

Originally posted by tankle104:


lol I don't think Brock needs to ditch his roommate but I just thought I'd share this.

Sharpe annoys me a bit lol. It's called being smart. And who cares if he has a roommate? . Prices in the Bay Area are insane lol. I am guessing he isn't living with his girl until married cause he is a Christian who seems to take his faith srsly and it's not uncommon, in that case, to have a roommate with another dude. What's the big deal lol. Shannon is a bit drama lol. I think it's commendable and that it's great that he appears to go by what he says he believes in, while at the same time, saving money. He doesn't have a big contract right now, it's smart. He might be saving up for a wedding too but honestly, who the heck cares, it is his money. Please don't give Shannon my wallet ever lol. And btw..if Sharpe wants to pay his rent..by all means haha.

horse face shannon sharpe is an idiot, very good player but worthless as an analyst

Originally posted by 5_Golden_Rings:

Originally posted by SanDiego49er:

Originally posted by Chance:
I actually don't see a system that Purdy wouldn't flourish in, provided it isn't a flawed system barren of surrounding talent. Throwing accurately with anticipation, reading defenses pre- and post-snap, making off-schedule plays, great agility and pocket awareness. I mean these are core to every successful QB. So why wouldn't Purdy do well elsewhere?

He would be great anywhere. It's a lot of him.

These dudes are quick to forgot how Jimmy G was doing in the same system with the same guys. Again, WITH CMC, Jimmy was scoring like 8 points less per game than Brock is (I can't remember the number but it's a big jump). That clearly means the QB is doing something. And what that something is, it seems, is finding the open guy consistently and executing the system better.

Originally posted by ninerjok:
Steve Ruiz makes Grant Cohn look like a Steve Young take. What a dips**t.

Originally posted by 5_Golden_Rings:
These dudes are quick to forgot how Jimmy G was doing in the same system with the same guys. Again, WITH CMC, Jimmy was scoring like 8 points less per game than Brock is (I can't remember the number but it's a big jump). That clearly means the QB is doing something. And what that something is, it seems, is finding the open guy consistently and executing the system better.

Originally posted by tankle104:

Originally posted by 5_Golden_Rings:
These dudes are quick to forgot how Jimmy G was doing in the same system with the same guys. Again, WITH CMC, Jimmy was scoring like 8 points less per game than Brock is (I can't remember the number but it's a big jump). That clearly means the QB is doing something. And what that something is, it seems, is finding the open guy consistently and executing the system better.

Reading the defensive coverages, accuracy, anticipation, pocket awareness, downfield confidence, ball placement etc. Brock does all those well and that's been the huge difference between this offense with Brock and with Jimmy.

Brock hasn't shown any "limitations" and Jimmy did - which opens our offense up, stretches/stresses a defense, gives our skill guys better chances to make plays, and turns the ball over less.

Originally posted by YACBros85:

Originally posted by 5_Golden_Rings:

Originally posted by SanDiego49er:

Originally posted by Chance:
I actually don't see a system that Purdy wouldn't flourish in, provided it isn't a flawed system barren of surrounding talent. Throwing accurately with anticipation, reading defenses pre- and post-snap, making off-schedule plays, great agility and pocket awareness. I mean these are core to every successful QB. So why wouldn't Purdy do well elsewhere?

He would be great anywhere. It's a lot of him.

These dudes are quick to forgot how Jimmy G was doing in the same system with the same guys. Again, WITH CMC, Jimmy was scoring like 8 points less per game than Brock is (I can't remember the number but it's a big jump). That clearly means the QB is doing something. And what that something is, it seems, is finding the open guy consistently and executing the system better.

With Jimmy+CMC the offense was averaging 25 ppg. Its somewhere around 31-32 ppg with Brock+CMC. And 3.5 of those games was without Deebo.

Originally posted by 5_Golden_Rings:

Originally posted by SanDiego49er:

Originally posted by Chance:
I actually don't see a system that Purdy wouldn't flourish in, provided it isn't a flawed system barren of surrounding talent. Throwing accurately with anticipation, reading defenses pre- and post-snap, making off-schedule plays, great agility and pocket awareness. I mean these are core to every successful QB. So why wouldn't Purdy do well elsewhere?

He would be great anywhere. It's a lot of him.

These dudes are quick to forgot how Jimmy G was doing in the same system with the same guys. Again, WITH CMC, Jimmy was scoring like 8 points less per game than Brock is (I can't remember the number but it's a big jump). That clearly means the QB is doing something. And what that something is, it seems, is finding the open guy consistently and executing the system better.

Originally posted by Jcool:

Originally posted by 5_Golden_Rings:

Originally posted by SanDiego49er:

Originally posted by Chance:
I actually don't see a system that Purdy wouldn't flourish in, provided it isn't a flawed system barren of surrounding talent. Throwing accurately with anticipation, reading defenses pre- and post-snap, making off-schedule plays, great agility and pocket awareness. I mean these are core to every successful QB. So why wouldn't Purdy do well elsewhere?

He would be great anywhere. It's a lot of him.

These dudes are quick to forgot how Jimmy G was doing in the same system with the same guys. Again, WITH CMC, Jimmy was scoring like 8 points less per game than Brock is (I can't remember the number but it's a big jump). That clearly means the QB is doing something. And what that something is, it seems, is finding the open guy consistently and executing the system better.

Jimmy was completing 71% of his passes with 9 TDs and 1 INT for a 110 QB rating after CMC joined the team.