QB Brock Purdy Thread

Originally posted by Chance:

Originally posted by 49ersRing:
As long as we're not trailing in the 2nd half, he's great. Just need to make sure we're not playing in any close games, so that he doesn't feel the need to press.

lol, how miserable it must be to have to qualify every good moment with such petty b******t. Glad I don't live in your world.

Originally posted by Montana:
Purdy haters can suck my entire Brock

Originally posted by NoDeepBallSteveYoung:
HITL

Originally posted by 5_Golden_Rings:

Originally posted by BIGSTWONGAWM:
The problem with Bwock is that he doesn't have a stwong enough awm.

If Brock had a BIG, STRONG ARM like JaMarcus Russell or Ryan Leaf, he would have fired that throw to Mitchell right through the linebacker's arm for a laser 2 yard pass. But he doesn't have the arm to throw 2 yard passes like that. He also would not have thrown that second pick, because he would have fired it right through that linebacker's hands.

To be a successful QB in the NFL, you need to throw at least 10-12 deep outs per game. The only QBs who have any success these days are doing it Troy Aikman-to-Michael Irvin style. Just 5-7 step drops, set, fire 110 MPH bullets on deep comebacks and outs. That's what Goathomes is doing in Kansas City. Just threading needles into tight windows over and over again and never throwing any interceptions. Andy Reid isn't a genius who schemes guys wide open like Kyle Shanahan. It takes a special kind of QB to have any success with a play caller like Andy Reid, like an A.J. Feely or a Koy Detmer or an Alex Smith or a Michael Vick or a Donovan McNabb or a Matt Moore coming off coaching high school football.

You need a CANNON arm like Steve Young and Joe Montana had. The WCO was all about throwing a combination of 20 yard laser outs and 60 yard bombs on every play.

But Bwock's awm is weak. He is getting intercepted because of his weak awm.

He is holding back this amazeballs defense and supporting cast. Deebo should be running 20 yard deep outs and comebacks all the time, because he reminds me of Isaac Bruce.

Also, Bwock holds back the running game, because teams know he's not going to beat them deep, so they crowd the box and stuff the run. You can't run without a huge threat at QB.

Just ask Adrian Peterson. He had Christian Ponder and his big, stwong awm at QB the year he ran for 2,000 yards. Teams feared Ponder, who was way more talented than either Bwock or Brett Favre or Tom Brady, because he went 12th overall while they went Mr. Irrelevant and 2nd round and 6th round, beating them with the deep ball and his overall greatness throwing the football.

Teams also feared great QBs like Anthony Wright for the Ravens when Jamal Lewis ran for 2,000 yards, and Vince Young for the Titans when Chris Johnson did it. Bwock is nowhere near that class.

Defenses go, "AHHHH! We really want to stop this dominant running back, but if we do, Ponder/Wright/Vince will light up our defense through the air! AHHHH!"

We need Sam Darnold and his BIG, STWONG AWM in the game to prevent interceptions. Darnold was a high draft pick, which means he's way more talented than Purdy or Dan Marino, and he would NEVER throw a pick. He would make every throw and go to the HOF playing for the genius, Kyle Shanahan.

49er fans are so smart! NFL fans are so smart these days!

Actually it's because of late he's thrown astounding interceptions despite being in a scheme that has guys wide open most of the time. This was what Jimmy kept doing too, which is why the last three weeks are disturbing—and of course, it's precisely why Brock still has so many hardcore skeptics: they've seen how much worse Jimmy looked without Kyle calling plays, and are extrapolating that to Brock.

In any event, the fact that you think people are concerned about his arm shows exactly who "smart" 49ers fans are these days. The concern is his risky decisions and weird random drops in accuracy which make no sense. The only game of these three where his arm was a factor was the Browns, and that was only because the weather was trash. As soon as it cleared up, his arm was not the issue, and he threw a deep dime to Aiyuk (which was dropped). No. The issue is the red zone interceptions, and the late game interceptions when the team absolutely NEEDS its QB to step up. That's not related to arm strength.

Having an elite arm allows the QB to be right when he's wrong. But it's not necessary for winning. Ask the Bengals QB who turned out our defense a couple weeks ago.

s**tLOADS of fans are talking about Brock Purdy's supposed lack of arm strength, you disingenuous twit.

There's nothing "astounding" about Brock's interceptions. The red zone pick last week was off a stupid RPO call by Kyle trying to make Brock do something he NEVER does, and Brock missing a read to hand it off (because Kyle is a poor coach who didn't have him prepared for this play) and Brock trying to make something happen via ad-lib. That wasn't a misread on the actual throw. Mitchell was wide open and it was bad luck that the linebacker behind him was able to tip it.

No, this scheme does not get guys "wide open most of the time." That's PFF nonsense from idiots who think that receivers having the illusion of separation against zone coverage (because most of Kyle's route combinations focus on the middle of the field) is "big separation."

Additionally, there was NOBODY OPEN on ANY of Brock's interceptions this year, other than Mitchell in the flat on the redzone pick last week, who is exactly who Brock was trying to go to.

"Random drops in accuracy." If he were as accurate and threw as few picks as the fans on here are suggesting, he'd be the greatest QB of all-time.

The guy is averaging f**king 9.1 yards per pass attempt, which is among the highest figures in NFL history. He's thrown only 5 picks.

You idiots seriously expect Brock to hit 80+% of his throws and throw ZERO interceptions. You think every interception ever is "unacceptable."

Also, since when does Burrow not have a strong arm?

Burrow's arm is so much stronger than Steve Young's was it's a joke.

Originally posted by SlipAndSlideBosa:
Ok he finally got his Mojo back. Hopefully he doesn't lose it again.

Originally posted by 5_Golden_Rings:

Originally posted by NoDeepBallSteveYoung:
HITL

Originally posted by 5_Golden_Rings:

Originally posted by BIGSTWONGAWM:
The problem with Bwock is that he doesn't have a stwong enough awm.

If Brock had a BIG, STRONG ARM like JaMarcus Russell or Ryan Leaf, he would have fired that throw to Mitchell right through the linebacker's arm for a laser 2 yard pass. But he doesn't have the arm to throw 2 yard passes like that. He also would not have thrown that second pick, because he would have fired it right through that linebacker's hands.

To be a successful QB in the NFL, you need to throw at least 10-12 deep outs per game. The only QBs who have any success these days are doing it Troy Aikman-to-Michael Irvin style. Just 5-7 step drops, set, fire 110 MPH bullets on deep comebacks and outs. That's what Goathomes is doing in Kansas City. Just threading needles into tight windows over and over again and never throwing any interceptions. Andy Reid isn't a genius who schemes guys wide open like Kyle Shanahan. It takes a special kind of QB to have any success with a play caller like Andy Reid, like an A.J. Feely or a Koy Detmer or an Alex Smith or a Michael Vick or a Donovan McNabb or a Matt Moore coming off coaching high school football.

You need a CANNON arm like Steve Young and Joe Montana had. The WCO was all about throwing a combination of 20 yard laser outs and 60 yard bombs on every play.

But Bwock's awm is weak. He is getting intercepted because of his weak awm.

He is holding back this amazeballs defense and supporting cast. Deebo should be running 20 yard deep outs and comebacks all the time, because he reminds me of Isaac Bruce.

Also, Bwock holds back the running game, because teams know he's not going to beat them deep, so they crowd the box and stuff the run. You can't run without a huge threat at QB.

Just ask Adrian Peterson. He had Christian Ponder and his big, stwong awm at QB the year he ran for 2,000 yards. Teams feared Ponder, who was way more talented than either Bwock or Brett Favre or Tom Brady, because he went 12th overall while they went Mr. Irrelevant and 2nd round and 6th round, beating them with the deep ball and his overall greatness throwing the football.

Teams also feared great QBs like Anthony Wright for the Ravens when Jamal Lewis ran for 2,000 yards, and Vince Young for the Titans when Chris Johnson did it. Bwock is nowhere near that class.

Defenses go, "AHHHH! We really want to stop this dominant running back, but if we do, Ponder/Wright/Vince will light up our defense through the air! AHHHH!"

We need Sam Darnold and his BIG, STWONG AWM in the game to prevent interceptions. Darnold was a high draft pick, which means he's way more talented than Purdy or Dan Marino, and he would NEVER throw a pick. He would make every throw and go to the HOF playing for the genius, Kyle Shanahan.

49er fans are so smart! NFL fans are so smart these days!

Actually it's because of late he's thrown astounding interceptions despite being in a scheme that has guys wide open most of the time. This was what Jimmy kept doing too, which is why the last three weeks are disturbing—and of course, it's precisely why Brock still has so many hardcore skeptics: they've seen how much worse Jimmy looked without Kyle calling plays, and are extrapolating that to Brock.

In any event, the fact that you think people are concerned about his arm shows exactly who "smart" 49ers fans are these days. The concern is his risky decisions and weird random drops in accuracy which make no sense. The only game of these three where his arm was a factor was the Browns, and that was only because the weather was trash. As soon as it cleared up, his arm was not the issue, and he threw a deep dime to Aiyuk (which was dropped). No. The issue is the red zone interceptions, and the late game interceptions when the team absolutely NEEDS its QB to step up. That's not related to arm strength.

Having an elite arm allows the QB to be right when he's wrong. But it's not necessary for winning. Ask the Bengals QB who turned out our defense a couple weeks ago.

s**tLOADS of fans are talking about Brock Purdy's supposed lack of arm strength, you disingenuous twit.

There's nothing "astounding" about Brock's interceptions. The red zone pick last week was off a stupid RPO call by Kyle trying to make Brock do something he NEVER does, and Brock missing a read to hand it off (because Kyle is a poor coach who didn't have him prepared for this play) and Brock trying to make something happen via ad-lib. That wasn't a misread on the actual throw. Mitchell was wide open and it was bad luck that the linebacker behind him was able to tip it.

No, this scheme does not get guys "wide open most of the time." That's PFF nonsense from idiots who think that receivers having the illusion of separation against zone coverage (because most of Kyle's route combinations focus on the middle of the field) is "big separation."

Additionally, there was NOBODY OPEN on ANY of Brock's interceptions this year, other than Mitchell in the flat on the redzone pick last week, who is exactly who Brock was trying to go to.

"Random drops in accuracy." If he were as accurate and threw as few picks as the fans on here are suggesting, he'd be the greatest QB of all-time.

The guy is averaging f**king 9.1 yards per pass attempt, which is among the highest figures in NFL history. He's thrown only 5 picks.

You idiots seriously expect Brock to hit 80+% of his throws and throw ZERO interceptions. You think every interception ever is "unacceptable."

Also, since when does Burrow not have a strong arm?

Burrow's arm is so much stronger than Steve Young's was it's a joke.

Your post is of no value. Brock played excellent today and restored faith. But that doesn't mean his three games of weirdly timed interceptions weren't COMPLETELY OUT OF CHARACTER for him, and thus "astounding."

EDIT: Burrow's arm isn't any stronger than Brock's, or if it is, it's not by much. Neither one has a rocket, but both can make every throw.

And Brock did plenty of RPO's in college and they are a staple of our scheme ffs.

Originally posted by 49ersRing:

Originally posted by 5_Golden_Rings:

Originally posted by NoDeepBallSteveYoung:
HITL

Originally posted by 5_Golden_Rings:

Originally posted by BIGSTWONGAWM:
The problem with Bwock is that he doesn't have a stwong enough awm.

If Brock had a BIG, STRONG ARM like JaMarcus Russell or Ryan Leaf, he would have fired that throw to Mitchell right through the linebacker's arm for a laser 2 yard pass. But he doesn't have the arm to throw 2 yard passes like that. He also would not have thrown that second pick, because he would have fired it right through that linebacker's hands.

To be a successful QB in the NFL, you need to throw at least 10-12 deep outs per game. The only QBs who have any success these days are doing it Troy Aikman-to-Michael Irvin style. Just 5-7 step drops, set, fire 110 MPH bullets on deep comebacks and outs. That's what Goathomes is doing in Kansas City. Just threading needles into tight windows over and over again and never throwing any interceptions. Andy Reid isn't a genius who schemes guys wide open like Kyle Shanahan. It takes a special kind of QB to have any success with a play caller like Andy Reid, like an A.J. Feely or a Koy Detmer or an Alex Smith or a Michael Vick or a Donovan McNabb or a Matt Moore coming off coaching high school football.

You need a CANNON arm like Steve Young and Joe Montana had. The WCO was all about throwing a combination of 20 yard laser outs and 60 yard bombs on every play.

But Bwock's awm is weak. He is getting intercepted because of his weak awm.

He is holding back this amazeballs defense and supporting cast. Deebo should be running 20 yard deep outs and comebacks all the time, because he reminds me of Isaac Bruce.

Also, Bwock holds back the running game, because teams know he's not going to beat them deep, so they crowd the box and stuff the run. You can't run without a huge threat at QB.

Just ask Adrian Peterson. He had Christian Ponder and his big, stwong awm at QB the year he ran for 2,000 yards. Teams feared Ponder, who was way more talented than either Bwock or Brett Favre or Tom Brady, because he went 12th overall while they went Mr. Irrelevant and 2nd round and 6th round, beating them with the deep ball and his overall greatness throwing the football.

Teams also feared great QBs like Anthony Wright for the Ravens when Jamal Lewis ran for 2,000 yards, and Vince Young for the Titans when Chris Johnson did it. Bwock is nowhere near that class.

Defenses go, "AHHHH! We really want to stop this dominant running back, but if we do, Ponder/Wright/Vince will light up our defense through the air! AHHHH!"

We need Sam Darnold and his BIG, STWONG AWM in the game to prevent interceptions. Darnold was a high draft pick, which means he's way more talented than Purdy or Dan Marino, and he would NEVER throw a pick. He would make every throw and go to the HOF playing for the genius, Kyle Shanahan.

49er fans are so smart! NFL fans are so smart these days!

Actually it's because of late he's thrown astounding interceptions despite being in a scheme that has guys wide open most of the time. This was what Jimmy kept doing too, which is why the last three weeks are disturbing—and of course, it's precisely why Brock still has so many hardcore skeptics: they've seen how much worse Jimmy looked without Kyle calling plays, and are extrapolating that to Brock.

In any event, the fact that you think people are concerned about his arm shows exactly who "smart" 49ers fans are these days. The concern is his risky decisions and weird random drops in accuracy which make no sense. The only game of these three where his arm was a factor was the Browns, and that was only because the weather was trash. As soon as it cleared up, his arm was not the issue, and he threw a deep dime to Aiyuk (which was dropped). No. The issue is the red zone interceptions, and the late game interceptions when the team absolutely NEEDS its QB to step up. That's not related to arm strength.

Having an elite arm allows the QB to be right when he's wrong. But it's not necessary for winning. Ask the Bengals QB who turned out our defense a couple weeks ago.

s**tLOADS of fans are talking about Brock Purdy's supposed lack of arm strength, you disingenuous twit.

There's nothing "astounding" about Brock's interceptions. The red zone pick last week was off a stupid RPO call by Kyle trying to make Brock do something he NEVER does, and Brock missing a read to hand it off (because Kyle is a poor coach who didn't have him prepared for this play) and Brock trying to make something happen via ad-lib. That wasn't a misread on the actual throw. Mitchell was wide open and it was bad luck that the linebacker behind him was able to tip it.

No, this scheme does not get guys "wide open most of the time." That's PFF nonsense from idiots who think that receivers having the illusion of separation against zone coverage (because most of Kyle's route combinations focus on the middle of the field) is "big separation."

Additionally, there was NOBODY OPEN on ANY of Brock's interceptions this year, other than Mitchell in the flat on the redzone pick last week, who is exactly who Brock was trying to go to.

"Random drops in accuracy." If he were as accurate and threw as few picks as the fans on here are suggesting, he'd be the greatest QB of all-time.

The guy is averaging f**king 9.1 yards per pass attempt, which is among the highest figures in NFL history. He's thrown only 5 picks.

You idiots seriously expect Brock to hit 80+% of his throws and throw ZERO interceptions. You think every interception ever is "unacceptable."

Also, since when does Burrow not have a strong arm?

Burrow's arm is so much stronger than Steve Young's was it's a joke.

Your post is of no value. Brock played excellent today and restored faith. But that doesn't mean his three games of weirdly timed interceptions weren't COMPLETELY OUT OF CHARACTER for him, and thus "astounding."

EDIT: Burrow's arm isn't any stronger than Brock's, or if it is, it's not by much. Neither one has a rocket, but both can make every throw.

And Brock did plenty of RPO's in college and they are a staple of our scheme ffs.

They weren't out of character, they were just situational.

Originally posted by DonnieDarko:
espn hasnt released his qbr yet

but a 148.9 passer rating

Originally posted by random49er:

Originally posted by DonnieDarko:
espn hasnt released his qbr yet

but a 148.9 passer rating

I think it's going to go up.

Originally posted by 49ersRing:

Originally posted by Chance:

Originally posted by 49ersRing:
As long as we're not trailing in the 2nd half, he's great. Just need to make sure we're not playing in any close games, so that he doesn't feel the need to press.

lol, how miserable it must be to have to qualify every good moment with such petty b******t. Glad I don't live in your world.

It's not being miserable. He played great today. It's just that the questions about him that came out of the 3 straight losses (5 turnovers when we were trailing by 7 points or less) haven't been answered by 1 dominant win where we were never really challenged.

Originally posted by DrEll:
Still the best QB this roster has had since Jeff Garcia. I know it doesn't say much given the daunting eras of Alex Smith and Jimmy Garoppolo, who inspired fear in opposing defenses. But still, glad to have this guy on our roster.