QB Brock Purdy Thread

Originally posted by Furlow:


Here's something we can all unite behind. This can't be real lol.

Originally posted by YACBros85:
The Baby Face Assassin.

Originally posted by YACBros85:
The Baby Face Assassin.

Originally posted by Bay2Bay9erAllday:
Let's not forget Brock's no look pass vs the Raiders last year.

So far, Brock's tape has surpassed all other Niners QBs not named Young and Montana, that it's a disservice to keep comparing to Jimmy, Alex, Kap, Garcia, Lance

Originally posted by Furlow:

Originally posted by 49AllTheTime:

Originally posted by SteveWallacesHelmet:

Originally posted by Furlow:

Originally posted by SteveWallacesHelmet:

Originally posted by Furlow:

Originally posted by 9ers4eva:

Originally posted by Furlow:
McDaniels is as good of a coach as Kyle now.

You tell us. You were predicting far more Jimmy success in Vegas all offseason.

I thought that Jimmy being able to play with more freedom would help him. Didn't realize how broken he actually was/is. Busted up body plus freedom to do whatever you want = a lot of turnovers.

Jimmy aside, McDaniels isn't in the same universe as Kyle.

Even though you and I dont agree on Jimmy, at least you try to answer questions like others dont. So I will ask you this. What part of Jimmy's skillset has diminished from last season to this season? Is his mobility less? Is he slower running? Can he not throw the ball as far? Can he not throw the ball with as much velocity?

When someone is considered broken down or washed up, you can clearly see the difference in athleticism and skillset. So what did you see out of him that was markedly different than last season, where he had arguably played at the highest level he had as a 49er?

I watched a couple of Raider games this year, and I'd say all of the above looked worse. But arm strength in particular. I mean he threw one fade to Adams that was about 10 yards short lol. Something is wrong with him. Maybe he spent the whole off season eating crackers and drinking wine, I don't know. But even Jimmy's worst critics cannot honestly say that he is the same QB that we had here. Kyle is good and gets the most out of his QB's, but he's not a damn wizard lol.

In the handful of Raider games I watched, Jimmy was doing the same things that he was doing with us that drove me crazy, just at a higher frequency. There was not a noticeable difference in arm strength to me, and I never once saw any analyst say or hear any broadcaster say there was a deterioration in it.

I agree with you that he wasnt performing like the same QB. He had much more freedom as a Raider, and the same mistakes he made as a 49er just happened substantially more often.

plenty of over throws also.. if that proof his arm is stronger lol

Yeah lots of air yards, which means he's being aggressive. You guys should love that.

Originally posted by Giedi:

Originally posted by NinerBuff:

Originally posted by wysiwyg:
Trey Lance

Someone had to say it

I was not in favor of the move, but I can at least understand Shanahan's confidence in trading him away because he knew what he had..

Trey will be a good QB, just needs more reps!

Originally posted by Eddie_D:

Originally posted by Bay2Bay9erAllday:
Let's not forget Brock's no look pass vs the Raiders last year.

So far, Brock's tape has surpassed all other Niners QBs not named Young and Montana, that it's a disservice to keep comparing to Jimmy, Alex, Kap, Garcia, Lance

We're comparing him to Joe and Steve but our very own fans like to bring up those former QB's. He is a lot closer to Steve and Joe then the rest.

Originally posted by Eddie_D:

Originally posted by Furlow:


Here's something we can all unite behind. This can't be real lol.

He was actually sucking Brock off big time then he changed his narrative. Since he changed his narrative his content gets a lot more views and more engagement from 49er fans. So he keeps on doing it.

I listen to him everyday at the office because he comes on after Dan Patrick. He doesn't believe in what he says and he isn't a hot take guy but this time he is.

Originally posted by Bay2Bay9erAllday:
That's true.

I understand some fans just miss the old, tired arguments and use any excuse to bring them up again, even if there are other threads for it. But, at some point we need to move on. You'd think Purdys elite play would make it easier for some to do so, but nope lol

Originally posted by SteveWallacesHelmet:
Cowherd is the king of flip flopping.

Originally posted by 9ers4eva:

Originally posted by Bay2Bay9erAllday:
That's true.

I understand some fans just miss the old, tired arguments and use any excuse to bring them up again, even if there are other threads for it. But, at some point we need to move on. You'd think Purdys elite play would make it easier for some to do so, but nope lol

People should move on past the idea that this offense limits any QB. Sadly it keeps being brought up. It is absolutely a tired argument being shown to be BS in real time.

Originally posted by 9ers4eva:

Originally posted by Bay2Bay9erAllday:
That's true.

I understand some fans just miss the old, tired arguments and use any excuse to bring them up again, even if there are other threads for it. But, at some point we need to move on. You'd think Purdys elite play would make it easier for some to do so, but nope lol

People should move on past the idea that this offense limits any QB. Sadly it keeps being brought up. It is absolutely a tired argument being shown to be BS in real time.

Originally posted by Bay2Bay9erAllday:
It's probably best to just laugh it off at this point. Kyle is an elite coach/OC. Is he or his offense perfect? Of course not. It still needs competent QB play to make it work. But, it has proven that it can lift QBs play. Its also not a miracle worker that can make any s**tty QB good. If that were the case, then Lance would still be here, especially after all the capital wasted on him.