LISTEN: Are The 49ers Done? →

There are 237 users in the forums

QB Brock Purdy Thread

Shop Find 49ers gear online
Originally posted by NYniner85:
Originally posted by Chance:
Yeah, no s**t.

I never said Brock and Tom Brady in the same sentence.

You said Brock & Montana in the same sentence…the guy who brady and I both call the GOAT.

It was a joke, calm down.

By the way, you just said Brock, Brady, and Montana in the same sentence.
[ Edited by Chance on Dec 1, 2023 at 11:03 AM ]
Originally posted by TheWooLick:
Originally posted by NYniner85:
His arm is not fantastic. It's passable and can get the job done.

A lot of those INTs this yr was some of the same s**t that he did in college and the stuff that was dropped last yr. He's gotta play better when we're behind and on those early downs. I love the gunslinger stuff, but INTs on 1st/2nd down and in the RZ are killer.

he's young and improving, but it sounds like you don't think he has any flaws and nothing he can improve upon. I'll disagree.

Passable? The statistics tell the truth. You think Lance has a better arm and you are dug into your bad take about him being the starter.

LOL at calling leading the league in passing and being the best deep ball thrower in the league as "getting the job done."

He has a better TD/INT ratio than Mahomes.

Brock has made similar throws to Lance that had posters panties wet. Yet, brock is considered "bottom 3 arm strength" and "passable"lol

Brock's good arm strength, different arm angles, plus beautiful touch and arc, can be considered fantastic.

some just need to move on from the whole noodle arm argument already. Brock has proven that to be false.
Originally posted by Heroism:
Originally posted by CatchMaster80:
You're right. And yours is a frat boy take. I don't have to like every fad that comes along. I never cared for the backwards hat, the sideways hat or the pants falling off look. I wear hats all the time but never backwards. It defeats the purpose of keeping the sun out of the eyes.

Anyway it's not a huge deal but it just doesn't look very professional. Remember, he's dealing with a lot of older people in the press. If Kittle wants to look goofy then that's fine because he's not the leader and the face of the franchise. I would just like to see him look as professional as he plays.


Originally posted by Bay2Bay9erAllday:
Originally posted by Heroism:
Originally posted by CatchMaster80:
You're right. And yours is a frat boy take. I don't have to like every fad that comes along. I never cared for the backwards hat, the sideways hat or the pants falling off look. I wear hats all the time but never backwards. It defeats the purpose of keeping the sun out of the eyes.

Anyway it's not a huge deal but it just doesn't look very professional. Remember, he's dealing with a lot of older people in the press. If Kittle wants to look goofy then that's fine because he's not the leader and the face of the franchise. I would just like to see him look as professional as he plays.



hahahaha
Originally posted by Chance:
Originally posted by NYniner85:
Originally posted by Chance:
Yeah, no s**t.

I never said Brock and Tom Brady in the same sentence.

You said Brock & Montana in the same sentence…the guy who brady and I both call the GOAT.

It was a joke, calm down.

By the way, you just said Brock, Brady, and Montana in the same sentence.

Hey they all had processing power as elite. However your right Brock has not earned GOAT status lol.
Originally posted by Bay2Bay9erAllday:
Brock has made similar throws to Lance that had posters panties wet. Yet, brock is considered "bottom 3 arm strength" and "passable"lol

Brock's good arm strength, different arm angles, plus beautiful touch and arc, can be considered fantastic.

some just need to move on from the whole noodle arm argument already. Brock has proven that to be false.

Who said noodle arm? His arm strength isn't at the level of Lance and Kap which is what the discussion was about. Stop pretending it is. Simple as that
Originally posted by Chance:
It was a joke, calm down.

By the way, you just said Brock, Brady, and Montana in the same sentence.

I'm calm buzzy. I never even said your name…you're the one that came out of nowhere getting defensive about it. Moving on
Originally posted by NYniner85:
Originally posted by Bay2Bay9erAllday:
Brock has made similar throws to Lance that had posters panties wet. Yet, brock is considered "bottom 3 arm strength" and "passable"lol

Brock's good arm strength, different arm angles, plus beautiful touch and arc, can be considered fantastic.

some just need to move on from the whole noodle arm argument already. Brock has proven that to be false.

Who said noodle arm? His arm strength isn't at the level of Lance and Kap which is what the discussion was about. Stop pretending it is. Simple as that

I never said they are the same lol

he has made similar throws to Lance though, that had folks creaming their pants. But now Brock's are considered "passable" lol

I'm calling out the bottom 3 arm strength that you pushed for months. simple as that.
  • pdc20
  • Veteran
  • Posts: 1,936
https://www.philadelphiaeagles.com/news/duffy-49ers-offense-is-operating-at-high-level-christian-mccaffrey-brock-purdy

Really good article about the offense and Purdy by a journalist covering the Eagles.
Originally posted by NYniner85:
Originally posted by Bay2Bay9erAllday:
Brock has made similar throws to Lance that had posters panties wet. Yet, brock is considered "bottom 3 arm strength" and "passable"lol

Brock's good arm strength, different arm angles, plus beautiful touch and arc, can be considered fantastic.

some just need to move on from the whole noodle arm argument already. Brock has proven that to be false.

Who said noodle arm? His arm strength isn't at the level of Lance and Kap which is what the discussion was about. Stop pretending it is. Simple as that

You did.. are we flip flopping?
Originally posted by 49erFaithful6:
You did.. are we flip flopping?

He was just speaking more Brock arm strength into existence
Originally posted by Bay2Bay9erAllday:
Originally posted by Heroism:
Originally posted by CatchMaster80:
You're right. And yours is a frat boy take. I don't have to like every fad that comes along. I never cared for the backwards hat, the sideways hat or the pants falling off look. I wear hats all the time but never backwards. It defeats the purpose of keeping the sun out of the eyes.

Anyway it's not a huge deal but it just doesn't look very professional. Remember, he's dealing with a lot of older people in the press. If Kittle wants to look goofy then that's fine because he's not the leader and the face of the franchise. I would just like to see him look as professional as he plays.



He should come out with the full Tux next time.

Originally posted by Bay2Bay9erAllday:
I never said they are the same lol

he has made similar throws to Lance though, that had folks creaming their pants. But now Brock's are considered "passable" lol

I'm calling out the bottom 3 arm strength that you pushed for months. simple as that.

That's what the discussion was about. Someone literally said that which is absurd.

There isn't anyone that's objective or not a homer 49er fan saying his arm strength is a positive or a plus…so what exactly is it compared to the rest of the league? Functional? Passable? Whose arm strength is worse as a starter currently? Who is it comparable too then? Andy Dalton? Mac Jones? Is it top 10? Or bottom 3rd?

he's got plently of other attributes that are good/great. He's been damn good for us this yr. It's okay that he's not + in that category because overall he's not.
Originally posted by 49erFaithful6:
You did.. are we flip flopping?

Nope…I said Mac has a noodle arm.

you don't get to talk about flip flopping Mr. Lance will be MVP and have 50TDs
[ Edited by NYniner85 on Dec 1, 2023 at 11:31 AM ]
Originally posted by 49erFaithful6:
Originally posted by NYniner85:
Originally posted by Bay2Bay9erAllday:
Brock has made similar throws to Lance that had posters panties wet. Yet, brock is considered "bottom 3 arm strength" and "passable"lol

Brock's good arm strength, different arm angles, plus beautiful touch and arc, can be considered fantastic.

some just need to move on from the whole noodle arm argument already. Brock has proven that to be false.

Who said noodle arm? His arm strength isn't at the level of Lance and Kap which is what the discussion was about. Stop pretending it is. Simple as that

You did.. are we flip flopping?

Feels so different being on the outside looking in.

Share 49ersWebzone