There are 170 users in the forums

QB Brock Purdy Thread

Shop Find 49ers gear online
Originally posted by Furlow:
Originally posted by tankle104:

Okay but what about 40+ and 50+? Any QB can throw the ball 30 yards.

JT O'Sullivan and Chase Daniel pointed out that there was potentially a, what, 40 yard throw that would've been a Deebo(?) TD, but he opted for a (still very good) Aiyuk 20(?) yarder.

I'm curious if Purdy could've made that throw. I think he could've, because some of the coaches on the sideline got excited when they saw the opportunity. I assume that, in the split second window it happened, he already decided to throw to Aiyuk.
Originally posted by Wubbie:
JT O'Sullivan and Chase Daniel pointed out that there was potentially a, what, 40 yard throw that would've been a Deebo(?) TD, but he opted for a (still very good) Aiyuk 20(?) yarder.

I'm curious if Purdy could've made that throw. I think he could've, because some of the coaches on the sideline got excited when they saw the opportunity. I assume that, in the split second window it happened, he already decided to throw to Aiyuk.

That was an interesting breakdown, and I do think it's a good question whether that throw with that timing is something Brock is capable of. Obviously if the defense/defender commits earlier, he can make up for any lack of arm strength by throwing it earlier, but on that particular play he had to wait a tick first.
Originally posted by SmokeyJoe:
Originally posted by Wubbie:
JT O'Sullivan and Chase Daniel pointed out that there was potentially a, what, 40 yard throw that would've been a Deebo(?) TD, but he opted for a (still very good) Aiyuk 20(?) yarder.

I'm curious if Purdy could've made that throw. I think he could've, because some of the coaches on the sideline got excited when they saw the opportunity. I assume that, in the split second window it happened, he already decided to throw to Aiyuk.

That was an interesting breakdown, and I do think it's a good question whether that throw with that timing is something Brock is capable of. Obviously if the defense/defender commits earlier, he can make up for any lack of arm strength by throwing it earlier, but on that particular play he had to wait a tick first.

Agreed.

Says a lot (in a good way) about the play design and Purdy's execution that he had a big play to Aiyuk... and yet still could've had an even bigger play if he was able to hold off just a tick.
Originally posted by Wubbie:
Originally posted by SmokeyJoe:
Originally posted by Wubbie:
JT O'Sullivan and Chase Daniel pointed out that there was potentially a, what, 40 yard throw that would've been a Deebo(?) TD, but he opted for a (still very good) Aiyuk 20(?) yarder.

I'm curious if Purdy could've made that throw. I think he could've, because some of the coaches on the sideline got excited when they saw the opportunity. I assume that, in the split second window it happened, he already decided to throw to Aiyuk.

That was an interesting breakdown, and I do think it's a good question whether that throw with that timing is something Brock is capable of. Obviously if the defense/defender commits earlier, he can make up for any lack of arm strength by throwing it earlier, but on that particular play he had to wait a tick first.

Agreed.

Says a lot (in a good way) about the play design and Purdy's execution that he had a big play to Aiyuk... and yet still could've had an even bigger play if he was able to hold off just a tick.

We've seen Brock make 40-50+ yard throws. Now idk how comfortable he is doing it, but is more than capable. I think it just came down to his processing and decision making - he saw he had Aiyuk and took it. He throws with so much anticipation that I think he would have to hold it longer to see if that deebo throw develops. Instead, he saw a good chunk play and just took it.

i also think when he reviews the film on his own and with the coaches, he catches those things and puts it in his tool belt for later - just something to look for next time we run that play against a similar defensive call etc.

sometimes I forget how inexperienced he actually is, so I think the missing deebo is more of him just getting reps with these plays and more experience. Just my perspective
  • Furlow
  • Veteran
  • Posts: 21,994
Originally posted by Wubbie:
Originally posted by Furlow:
Originally posted by tankle104:

Okay but what about 40+ and 50+? Any QB can throw the ball 30 yards.

JT O'Sullivan and Chase Daniel pointed out that there was potentially a, what, 40 yard throw that would've been a Deebo(?) TD, but he opted for a (still very good) Aiyuk 20(?) yarder.

I'm curious if Purdy could've made that throw. I think he could've, because some of the coaches on the sideline got excited when they saw the opportunity. I assume that, in the split second window it happened, he already decided to throw to Aiyuk.

Yeah I saw both of their takes on it, but to me the CB was still facing up field when Purdy made his decision and was even with Deebo. Not saying he couldn't have gone for it, but it looked like the CB was going to stay deep. Now the CB did sit down as Purdy began to separate, but I don't know if it's possible for a QB to change their mind mid throw like that.
After this seahawk game - Aiyuk will have broken 1k yards two consecutive years 😍.

kittle still can too. Just needs to finish the season strong
Originally posted by Furlow:
Yeah I saw both of their takes on it, but to me the CB was still facing up field when Purdy made his decision and was even with Deebo. Not saying he couldn't have gone for it, but it looked like the CB was going to stay deep. Now the CB did sit down as Purdy began to separate, but I don't know if it's possible for a QB to change their mind mid throw like that.

Thought it wasn't the simplest read as you're sort of implying here… at least in terms of timing. There is something to be said about being able to wait that extra beat because you have plus arm strength though. Elite anticipation is going to make up for a lack of plus arm strength in nearly every scenario, but maybe this was an example in the other direction.

Either way it was still a good gain and perfectly acceptable. Just maybe not the ideal result on the play. Welcome to QB'ing from the film room, lol.
20 years from now when Brock Purdy has won 10 Superbowls, recognized as the greatest draft pick ever made and re-established the San Francisco 49ers as the greatest organization in football, ESPN will start Brock Purdy's version of the Man in the Arena with this clip:


LOL sorry if this has been posted, but just saw this quote on ATH:

Hurts is admired and beloved here, but Brock Purdy would be a God in Philadelphia. A God."

- Mike Sielski, Philadelphia Inquirer

Originally posted by SLCNiner:
LOL sorry if this has been posted, but just saw this quote on ATH:

Hurts is admired and beloved here, but Brock Purdy would be a God in Philadelphia. A God."

- Mike Sielski, Philadelphia Inquirer


That article was a huge hit among Philly fans, lol. Absolutely losing their s**t.
***Lord Purdy***

  • Furlow
  • Veteran
  • Posts: 21,994
Originally posted by SmokeyJoe:
Originally posted by Furlow:
Yeah I saw both of their takes on it, but to me the CB was still facing up field when Purdy made his decision and was even with Deebo. Not saying he couldn't have gone for it, but it looked like the CB was going to stay deep. Now the CB did sit down as Purdy began to separate, but I don't know if it's possible for a QB to change their mind mid throw like that.

Thought it wasn't the simplest read as you're sort of implying here… at least in terms of timing. There is something to be said about being able to wait that extra beat because you have plus arm strength though. Elite anticipation is going to make up for a lack of plus arm strength in nearly every scenario, but maybe this was an example in the other direction.

Either way it was still a good gain and perfectly acceptable. Just maybe not the ideal result on the play. Welcome to QB'ing from the film room, lol.

I hear you. My opinion though is if Purdy waited a bit longer, the CB would have kept going up field with Deebo, and made that throw a lot tougher. And then Aiyuk would be much closer to the sideline, making that throw even harder. So Purdy made his decision at the right time. And I'm not saying it would have been a bad decision to throw to Deebo, I just don't think he would have been as open as JT was making it sound.
  • Furlow
  • Veteran
  • Posts: 21,994
Originally posted by SmokeyJoe:
Originally posted by SLCNiner:
LOL sorry if this has been posted, but just saw this quote on ATH:

Hurts is admired and beloved here, but Brock Purdy would be a God in Philadelphia. A God."

- Mike Sielski, Philadelphia Inquirer


That article was a huge hit among Philly fans, lol. Absolutely losing their s**t.

Reminds me of a Bill Burr stand up where he ROASTED the people in Philadelphia who were giving him s**t. One of his jokes was how stupidly racist they are - so much so that despite having their own heavyweight champion of the world in Joe Frazier, instead decided to make a statue of a movie character (Rocky) because he's white and not black. Lol
Originally posted by Furlow:
I hear you. My opinion though is if Purdy waited a bit longer, the CB would have kept going up field with Deebo, and made that throw a lot tougher. And then Aiyuk would be much closer to the sideline, making that throw even harder. So Purdy made his decision at the right time. And I'm not saying it would have been a bad decision to throw to Deebo, I just don't think he would have been as open as JT was making it sound.

Right but even that potential 'issue' would be lessened with great arm strength. Brock simply has to throw with great anticipation to be a great QB. Had that corner followed Deebo, that's a busted coverage on Aiyuk and a laser eliminates or at least significantly reduces the sideline/space issue.

We can still dominate as we did without hitting every potential downfield opportunity.
Originally posted by Heroism:
20 years from now when Brock Purdy has won 10 Superbowls, recognized as the greatest draft pick ever made and re-established the San Francisco 49ers as the greatest organization in football, ESPN will start Brock Purdy's version of the Man in the Arena with this clip:



That is cool, I hadn't heard the phone call before. He seems calm and already in go mode haha
Share 49ersWebzone