There are 324 users in the forums
Originally posted by footballxpaul:
Mvp is a race between dak and brock (brock to me has the tie breaker because he dominated in the head to head). You would have to be like AP when he won to win it as a non qb, he willed the Vikings to the playoffs with little to no qb help. Tyreek benefits from tua being solid, without that he turns into garret wilson (stretch but not far off what can happen).
Originally posted by tankle104:
Originally posted by libertyforever:
Originally posted by tankle104:
Originally posted by libertyforever:
Originally posted by tankle104:There is already OPOY.
Originally posted by qnnhan7:
I think CMC is a clear-cut MVP over all the QB this year. I haven't watched T.Hill enough to have an opinion on him, although I've heard people include him in the conversation. If Brock continues to put up numbers and playing out of his mind like he is so far, would be tough to not have him as MVP even over CMC.
I'm honestly surprised that CMC isn't getting more national attention for the award. I'm not saying he should be leading it but he's an all around elite player performing at a super high level, he's what enables this offense to be so explosive - in my opinion.
i kinda wish they would break out the position group awards.
"Most Valuable QB of the year"
"Most Valuable RB/WR/TE of the year". Etc etc
instead of essentially the NFL MVP being a qb award and DPOY being a pass rusher award
i guess that's kinda what the ESPYs are but I'm surprised the nfl doesn't have its own annual award show. Everytbing purely voted on by players and coaches - get great insight into what the folks within the NFL world think is great. It would be cool insight into that fraternity.
CMC and Tyreek Are seriously competing for OPOY. Why isn't that good enough?
If you're really talking about which one is more important to an offense and performs the best, I don't think it would be close.
CMC: Amazing at rushing, receiving, blocking, scoring touchdowns in various ways.
Tyreke hill: amazing at receiving and receiving touchdowns.
i think comparing players at different positions and trying to say which one is better, is dumb. It's like saying who is better, Michael Jordan or lebron James? Well they don't even play the same position and/or have the same responsibilities.
why not compare them to their positional peers?
Does it make more sense to say Who's better, Fred Warner or tj watt? They do two completely different things and have two completely different responsibilities. Warner should be compared to other linebackers and watt should be compared to other defensive lineman.
We already have the first team all pro. Yes it wasn't one player in each position, but that is a good enough recognition to me.
I'm not throwing a tantrum and I don't lose any sleep over this. Lol I'm just saying that the current recognition system doesn't make sense to me - it's piss poor and that's why the same awards typically go to the same position over and over again. Players get snubbed on the all pro team/pro bowl team every year - like when CMC didn't make either last year or when bosa didn't even make second team all pro 2 years ago.
eff it, only award I really want this year is the super bowl. Anything less will just be depressing.
Originally posted by YACBros85:
Originally posted by footballxpaul:
Mvp is a race between dak and brock (brock to me has the tie breaker because he dominated in the head to head). You would have to be like AP when he won to win it as a non qb, he willed the Vikings to the playoffs with little to no qb help. Tyreek benefits from tua being solid, without that he turns into garret wilson (stretch but not far off what can happen).
All that matters in this race is to convince the people that do the voting.
Originally posted by CatchMaster80:
I'm sure Brock is way more concerned with winning the SB than the MVP award. If they win the SB he probably will win the SB MVP.
Originally posted by SlipAndSlideBosa:
Originally posted by CatchMaster80:
I'm sure Brock is way more concerned with winning the SB than the MVP award. If they win the SB he probably will win the SB MVP.
Brock is probably way too concerned about beating the Cards than anything else.
Originally posted by CatchMaster80:
He's on the air talking about his rehab. He feels his arm is stronger because of all the rehab exercises he did. He said he will continue those same exercises from now on to keep his arm strong. He said he never really threw the deep ball much in college and the deep pass is a new part of his game. That helps explain why the scouting reports downgraded him.
Originally posted by CatchMaster80:
Originally posted by SlipAndSlideBosa:
Originally posted by CatchMaster80:
I'm sure Brock is way more concerned with winning the SB than the MVP award. If they win the SB he probably will win the SB MVP.
Brock is probably way too concerned about beating the Cards than anything else.
He's on the air talking about his rehab. He feels his arm is stronger because of all the rehab exercises he did. He said he will continue those same exercises from now on to keep his arm strong. He said he never really threw the deep ball much in college and the deep pass is a new part of his game. That helps explain why the scouting reports downgraded him.
Brian Baldinger on Brock Purdy:
— Coach Yac 🗣 (@Coach_Yac) December 12, 2023
"If you're not talking about him as a superstar then you stopped watching & you're not open minded to what a superstar is in this business. It's the hardest position to play in football & he's got a mastery in it right now."
via: @957thegame 🔥 pic.twitter.com/oJ1s0KD9m0
Originally posted by GoreGoreGore:
Originally posted by tankle104:
Originally posted by Crown:
Originally posted by tankle104:
Will Brock Purdy win the MVP? Yes, unless he falls off over the last month. Here are the top QB seasons by ANY/A among QBs with at least 10 wins. pic.twitter.com/ZDTN6Kw8AH
— Football Perspective (@fbgchase) December 11, 2023
Not directed at you Tankle but I have zero interest in all the MVP hype.
I want a superbowl win period. MVP is meaningless to me.
Superbowl MVP would be nice of course.
I feel like. I won't be upset if he doesn't get it but I do think he's deserving an I love seeing our guys stack accolades. I'll be really bummed if he gets it and we don't win it all.
id be very happy if all he won was the super bowl mvp (meaning we won it all).
Only one QB past 25 years has the SB and MVP same season. Mahomes
Young and Steve have bone done it as well. Purdy so far likes breaking or tying their records.
Originally posted by Giedi:
Originally posted by SlipAndSlideBosa:
Originally posted by CatchMaster80:
I'm sure Brock is way more concerned with winning the SB than the MVP award. If they win the SB he probably will win the SB MVP.
Brock is probably way too concerned about beating the Cards than anything else.
He's on the air talking about his rehab. He feels his arm is stronger because of all the rehab exercises he did. He said he will continue those same exercises from now on to keep his arm strong. He said he never really threw the deep ball much in college and the deep pass is a new part of his game. That helps explain why the scouting reports downgraded him.
Its funny that the harder a player works on his game - he gets better!
Also that injury may have been a blessing in disguise by giving him exercises to grow his arm strength. If not for the injury - yeah we might have won a Superbowl, but forego future ones becuase his arm isn't as strong as it could be, but for those exercises.
Sort of how losing all those QBs to injuries last year uncovered our future franchise quarterback.
Originally posted by VaBeachNiner:
The beginning of greatness.
Originally posted by 49erFaithful6:
Originally posted by VaBeachNiner:
The beginning of greatness.
that's all Mason's fault
Originally posted by captveg:
Originally posted by 49erFaithful6:
Originally posted by VaBeachNiner:
The beginning of greatness.
that's all Mason's fault
Was also a positive yardage play.
