QB Brock Purdy Thread

Originally posted by Giedi:

Originally posted by Pillbusta:

Originally posted by Giedi:

Originally posted by YACBros85:
Cam Newton was a 1 read and run QB who's career faded just as quickly as his athleticism.

Very similar to Kaepernick in that regard.

Because of the way that Cam actually won NFL MVP and how he was able to stand up to SEA I would have to give Cam the edge. Cam was running QB power on SEA defensive front breaking tackle extending plays and breaking their backs during his peak looking like a man playing amongst boys out there. He was not an elite pocket QB processor but he had his time to shine and he did so he has his right to his opinion wrong as it may be

Cam was no steve young, though. Cam, to me, was a glorified running back playing QB. He can do the Kaepernick read option stuff because it's a one read offense. Either run it or throw it. Simple offense. Cam, no doubt, was a great *athlete* with an Olympian physique. But was he a real QB at the levels of the best? Nawwww.....

As much as we can say Cam Newton wasn't that great as a conventional QB, the guy was an MVP in 2015 and took his team to the Super Bowl. He's an example that, yes, you CAN make it work with a superlative athletic QB and scheme. I'm just not sure if a guy can play hero ball QB like that have sustained success.

I think that, as some have already said, I think you need to evolve. Cam did end up losing in the Super Bowl to an (elite) Broncos defense that made him play conventional QB. We just throttled the Eagles two weeks ago, forcing Jalen Hurts to play as a conventional QB, and he couldn't do it. Steve Young himself was running around making plays in his early career, but I think his career really took off when he learned to play the QB position... where he could truly stretch defenses with his arm AND legs.

A QB like Brock Purdy, who has the arm strength and the ability to read an NFL defense... he's going to be able to have success at QB for a very long time. He barely has 1 full season under his belt. It's exciting to see how he can grow as a QB in the years to come.

Originally posted by tankle104:

Everyone pushing the "Brock Purdy is just a byproduct of an elite supporting cast"-narrative just totally neglects to mention that he has a bottom-5 offensive line

I legit thought numbers like this would be impossible playing behind an OL this bad. Only Joe Burrow comes close pic.twitter.com/kR6spYnI0r

— Scott Barrett (@ScottBarrettDFB) December 12, 2023

Regarding offensive Line play, maybe they weren't doing too well early in the season, but I don't think that's accurate now. I think the OLine, currently, is rounding into shape. I think they are becoming one of the better pass protection OLines in the NFL as their reps with each other increase. The main reason is that they are communicating better and not blowing the handoff assignments on blitzes and stunts. I've not really seen any DLines consistently dominating the 49er OLines. Physically, the 49er OLine isn't going to blow DLines off the ball, but they don't need to in this system. As for pass protection, yeah, they can get better - for sure. But as your post states, Brock doesn't need a lot of time to get the ball out.

Don't get me wrong though, I wanted a OLine pick in Latu's place, and I will be downright pissed next year if ShanaLynch doesn't try to pick an understudy for Trent Williams.

Originally posted by jonnydel:

Originally posted by Jeepzilla:
Does anyone have anything recent from Kurt Warner on Brock?
I've been looking and have not found anything recent.

Just would like to hear his opinion.

This whole thread and some of Kurt's RT's on it are all RE the Brock conversation. Just follow him on X

Ok I'll bite, so what does a game changer look like? How many ways can you change a game? Is making MORE good decisions & making MORE accurate throws game-changing or game-managing? https://t.co/4cnNuhnBxJ

— Kurt Warner (@kurt13warner) December 13, 2023

Thanks!!

Originally posted by SanDiego49er:


FIRST THINGS FIRST | He's getting enough flowers - Nick wents reasons NOT to give Brock Purdy MVP

It's just a gag to get fired up niners fans commenting on his s**t. Not even he believes the s**t he spews.

Originally posted by Memphis9er:

Originally posted by SanDiego49er:


FIRST THINGS FIRST | He's getting enough flowers - Nick wents reasons NOT to give Brock Purdy MVP

It's just a gag to get fired up niners fans commenting on his s**t. Not even he believes the s**t he spews.

He's another dips**t that ranks college QBs above Brock on his QB mountain rankings. Personally, I enjoy all the disrespect because I just know it adds fuel to Purdys already burning 🔥

Originally posted by 49ers808:

Originally posted by Memphis9er:

Originally posted by SanDiego49er:


FIRST THINGS FIRST | He's getting enough flowers - Nick wents reasons NOT to give Brock Purdy MVP

It's just a gag to get fired up niners fans commenting on his s**t. Not even he believes the s**t he spews.

He's another dips**t that ranks college QBs above Brock on his QB mountain rankings. Personally, I enjoy all the disrespect because I just know it adds fuel to Purdys already burning 🔥

The naysayers in the media are just falling back on "oh, he didn't look good in the three game stretch, so yeah!"

But I have yet to see an analyst say "Look at these throws and plays. He's missing guys. He's off the mark here." (because there really aren't a lot of those).
Meanwhile, any one that looks on the film can see that he's playing at a high level.

Originally posted by 49ers808:

Originally posted by Memphis9er:

Originally posted by SanDiego49er:


FIRST THINGS FIRST | He's getting enough flowers - Nick wents reasons NOT to give Brock Purdy MVP

It's just a gag to get fired up niners fans commenting on his s**t. Not even he believes the s**t he spews.

He's another dips**t that ranks college QBs above Brock on his QB mountain rankings. Personally, I enjoy all the disrespect because I just know it adds fuel to Purdys already burning 🔥

He's an idiot. I hate that guy.

Originally posted by Wubbie:

Originally posted by 49ers808:

Originally posted by Memphis9er:

Originally posted by SanDiego49er:


FIRST THINGS FIRST | He's getting enough flowers - Nick wents reasons NOT to give Brock Purdy MVP

It's just a gag to get fired up niners fans commenting on his s**t. Not even he believes the s**t he spews.

He's another dips**t that ranks college QBs above Brock on his QB mountain rankings. Personally, I enjoy all the disrespect because I just know it adds fuel to Purdys already burning 🔥

The naysayers in the media are just falling back on "oh, he didn't look good in the three game stretch, so yeah!"

But I have yet to see an analyst say "Look at these throws and plays. He's missing guys. He's off the mark here." (because there really aren't a lot of those).
Meanwhile, any one that looks on the film can see that he's playing at a high level.

Its gotten to a point where they aren't even making a case for why they believe Dak deserves MVP over Brock. They are simply exhausting all the played out excuses for why Brock doesn't deserve it. None of which proves that Dak is having a better season.

Originally posted by YACBros85:

Originally posted by Wubbie:

Originally posted by 49ers808:

Originally posted by Memphis9er:

Originally posted by SanDiego49er:


FIRST THINGS FIRST | He's getting enough flowers - Nick wents reasons NOT to give Brock Purdy MVP

It's just a gag to get fired up niners fans commenting on his s**t. Not even he believes the s**t he spews.

He's another dips**t that ranks college QBs above Brock on his QB mountain rankings. Personally, I enjoy all the disrespect because I just know it adds fuel to Purdys already burning 🔥

The naysayers in the media are just falling back on "oh, he didn't look good in the three game stretch, so yeah!"

But I have yet to see an analyst say "Look at these throws and plays. He's missing guys. He's off the mark here." (because there really aren't a lot of those).
Meanwhile, any one that looks on the film can see that he's playing at a high level.

Its gotten to a point where they aren't even making a case for why they believe Dak deserves MVP over Brock. They are simply exhausting all the played out excuses for why Brock doesn't deserve it. None of which proves that Dak is having a better season.

What blows my mind is that, when you look at the stats, they're very similar, except that Dak has an extra NINETY throws over Brock. That's like playing an extra three games to get the same yardage and touchdowns. Brock is playing so much more efficiently, especially in the intermediate and deep areas of the field.

Originally posted by Wubbie:

Originally posted by 49ers808:

Originally posted by Memphis9er:

Originally posted by SanDiego49er:


FIRST THINGS FIRST | He's getting enough flowers - Nick wents reasons NOT to give Brock Purdy MVP

It's just a gag to get fired up niners fans commenting on his s**t. Not even he believes the s**t he spews.

He's another dips**t that ranks college QBs above Brock on his QB mountain rankings. Personally, I enjoy all the disrespect because I just know it adds fuel to Purdys already burning 🔥

The naysayers in the media are just falling back on "oh, he didn't look good in the three game stretch, so yeah!"

But I have yet to see an analyst say "Look at these throws and plays. He's missing guys. He's off the mark here." (because there really aren't a lot of those).
Meanwhile, any one that looks on the film can see that he's playing at a high level.

It's pure stupidity and you're right, if these people actually watched the games, he wasn't as bad as they make it out to be, I'm talking the games in its entirety. Sucks that Moody missed the kick cause I'm not sure that whole narrative would be as extreme as it is

Louis Riddick Disagrees With Cam Newton's Assessment Of Brock Purdy | 12/13/23

This one is much better and right on.

Originally posted by Wubbie:

Originally posted by YACBros85:

Originally posted by Wubbie:

Originally posted by 49ers808:

Originally posted by Memphis9er:

Originally posted by SanDiego49er:


FIRST THINGS FIRST | He's getting enough flowers - Nick wents reasons NOT to give Brock Purdy MVP

It's just a gag to get fired up niners fans commenting on his s**t. Not even he believes the s**t he spews.

He's another dips**t that ranks college QBs above Brock on his QB mountain rankings. Personally, I enjoy all the disrespect because I just know it adds fuel to Purdys already burning 🔥

The naysayers in the media are just falling back on "oh, he didn't look good in the three game stretch, so yeah!"

But I have yet to see an analyst say "Look at these throws and plays. He's missing guys. He's off the mark here." (because there really aren't a lot of those).
Meanwhile, any one that looks on the film can see that he's playing at a high level.

Its gotten to a point where they aren't even making a case for why they believe Dak deserves MVP over Brock. They are simply exhausting all the played out excuses for why Brock doesn't deserve it. None of which proves that Dak is having a better season.

What blows my mind is that, when you look at the stats, they're very similar, except that Dak has an extra NINETY throws over Brock. That's like playing an extra three games to get the same yardage and touchdowns. Brock is playing so much more efficiently, especially in the intermediate and deep areas of the field.

What blows my mind even more is when you compare the schedules, Dallas played an easy schedule. Let's see how Dak does on these last few games. The only media head that brings up the opponents that I've seen is Brou when he's debating Nick Wright. Says Dak played a bunch of tomato cans

Brock Purdy is the 66th highest paid QB in the NFL. That is all.

Originally posted by Phoenix49ers:
Brock Purdy is the 66th highest paid QB in the NFL. That is all.

Originally posted by 49ers808:

Originally posted by Wubbie:

Originally posted by YACBros85:

Originally posted by Wubbie:

Originally posted by 49ers808:

Originally posted by Memphis9er:

Originally posted by SanDiego49er:


FIRST THINGS FIRST | He's getting enough flowers - Nick wents reasons NOT to give Brock Purdy MVP

It's just a gag to get fired up niners fans commenting on his s**t. Not even he believes the s**t he spews.

He's another dips**t that ranks college QBs above Brock on his QB mountain rankings. Personally, I enjoy all the disrespect because I just know it adds fuel to Purdys already burning 🔥

The naysayers in the media are just falling back on "oh, he didn't look good in the three game stretch, so yeah!"

But I have yet to see an analyst say "Look at these throws and plays. He's missing guys. He's off the mark here." (because there really aren't a lot of those).
Meanwhile, any one that looks on the film can see that he's playing at a high level.

Its gotten to a point where they aren't even making a case for why they believe Dak deserves MVP over Brock. They are simply exhausting all the played out excuses for why Brock doesn't deserve it. None of which proves that Dak is having a better season.

What blows my mind is that, when you look at the stats, they're very similar, except that Dak has an extra NINETY throws over Brock. That's like playing an extra three games to get the same yardage and touchdowns. Brock is playing so much more efficiently, especially in the intermediate and deep areas of the field.

What blows my mind even more is when you compare the schedules, Dallas played an easy schedule. Let's see how Dak does on these last few games. The only media head that brings up the opponents that I've seen is Brou when he's debating Nick Wright. Says Dak played a bunch of tomato cans

That's true!
If Dak and the Cowboys still put up W's and convincing victories in this next stretch of games, I will say that "Yes, Dak and the Cowboys are worthy of this hype and it'll be a good game in the NFCCG."

But until then, I really think that the Cowboys are just punching down at inferior competition.