QB Brock Purdy Thread

Originally posted by CatchMaster80:
This is why I never get excited over a college player when they show his highlights during the combine. Of course they're going to show the good stuff and not the bad stuff. Same for the workouts. We know that players shed weight so they can run quicker times and actually train for the combine. They've become illusionists.

Illusionists. well said.

Originally posted by 49ersRing:

Originally posted by Memphis9er:

Originally posted by random49er:

Originally posted by 49ersRing:
Why are we debating Cam's resume? It doesn't seem that relevant beyond him being a former NFL QB. Nobody brings up JTO's or Chase Daniels' careers when their opinions get posted here.

He made it relevant by denigrating the subject of this thread. Ring knows this, he's not that dim. All you need to know about Cam is that down by four points in the Superbowl, he decided not to even try to dive on a loose ball that might very well have given his team a chance to win the game. He was always a celf-centered type, and though he was a great athlete, he was mediocre, at best, as a qb.

It's still not relevant. His point was weak and inconsistent on its own, his career doesn't really matter.

You're delusional if you don't think Cam was trying to paint himself as a "game changer" and insert himself into the comparison. Acting like he's watching film and actually analyzing these QB's lol.

Originally posted by tankle104:

Originally posted by Heroism:

Originally posted by tankle104:
Aw will you share your franchise qb with the rest of us 49er lovers?! PLEASE! WE NEED THIS! We are trapped in a glass box of emotion!

aw idk how to make gifs post in here hahaha

Yes, you do.

Originally posted by tankle104:

Originally posted by Young2Owens:
Brock haters at this point just sound like size queens. "MuSt bE 8 oR mORe iNCheS!"
When in reality most women prefer an above average 6 inches that hits all the spots with finesse. A "bedroom managing" unit if you will, but still long enough to occasionally go deep.

Brock has def shown that he knows how to get the balls deep 😎

Bedroom manager? lolol

As long as he "manages" the Niners to a Super Bowl win

Originally posted by NinerTy:
As long as he "manages" the Niners to a Super Bowl win

He will manage to win super bowl mvp 😈

Originally posted by Furlow:
You're delusional if you don't think Cam was trying to paint himself as a "game changer" and insert himself into the comparison. Acting like he's watching film and actually analyzing these QB's lol.

Cam was a "game changer". Right now if you insert Cam in a college program that program would be in contention for the chip because of the systems they run. You have to change your gameplan to account for him offensively and defensively. You can't play Cam the same way you would a pocket passer. That is changing the game. Now, that said, that doesn't mean that will work on the NFL level consistently over a long period of years. You can change the game but once folk adapt, if you have not evolved you will be left behind.

Cam's opinion is biased and as an NFL MVP, and NFCCG winner, a Heisman winner and a National Championship game winner he can say his opinion and I don't have to like it but I have to respect his right to speak it

Originally posted by Pillbusta:

Originally posted by Furlow:
You're delusional if you don't think Cam was trying to paint himself as a "game changer" and insert himself into the comparison. Acting like he's watching film and actually analyzing these QB's lol.

Cam was a "game changer". Right now if you insert Cam in a college program that program would be in contention for the chip because of the systems they run. You have to change your gameplan to account for him offensively and defensively. You can't play Cam the same way you would a pocket passer. That is changing the game. Now, that said, that doesn't mean that will work on the NFL level consistently over a long period of years. You can change the game but once folk adapt, if you have not evolved you will be left behind.

Cam's opinion is biased and as an NFL MVP, and NFCCG winner, a Heisman winner and a National Championship game winner he can say his opinion and I don't have to like it but I have to respect his right to speak it

So what you're saying is, since Cam isn't a good enough processor to run a real NFL offense, you have to use a college-style offense to have success with thim, thus "changing the game," as in forcing you to change how you play against defenses to a sub-optimal strategy which requires your superior athletes to win with athleticism?

Originally posted by Pillbusta:
Cam was a "game changer". Right now if you insert Cam in a college program that program would be in contention for the chip because of the systems they run. You have to change your gameplan to account for him offensively and defensively. You can't play Cam the same way you would a pocket passer. That is changing the game. Now, that said, that doesn't mean that will work on the NFL level consistently over a long period of years. You can change the game but once folk adapt, if you have not evolved you will be left behind.

Cam's opinion is biased and as an NFL MVP, and NFCCG winner, a Heisman winner and a National Championship game winner he can say his opinion and I don't have to like it but I have to respect his right to speak it

He has every right to state his opinion, but his place in football is somewhat irrelevant. I have just as much right to oppose his opinon and I haven't played a down in any organized football league. In fact, that his opinion is so off in this regard should be enough proof that their resume carries little weight.

Originally posted by RickyRoma:

Originally posted by Pillbusta:
Cam was a "game changer". Right now if you insert Cam in a college program that program would be in contention for the chip because of the systems they run. You have to change your gameplan to account for him offensively and defensively. You can't play Cam the same way you would a pocket passer. That is changing the game. Now, that said, that doesn't mean that will work on the NFL level consistently over a long period of years. You can change the game but once folk adapt, if you have not evolved you will be left behind.

Cam's opinion is biased and as an NFL MVP, and NFCCG winner, a Heisman winner and a National Championship game winner he can say his opinion and I don't have to like it but I have to respect his right to speak it

He has every right to state his opinion, but his place in football is somewhat irrelevant. I have just as much right to oppose his opinon and I haven't played a down in any organized football league. In fact, that his opinion is so off in this regard should be enough proof that their resume carries little weight.

Saying someone shouldn't have an opinon because they didn't play, Ike weren't very successful, is stupid. Lol everyone is entitled to an opinon - whether we like it or not. Most "analyst" or talking heads, never played anytbjng outside of high school.

but just as I think someone who didn't play can have a dumbass opinon, or poor understanding of football as a whole. Same can be said for guys who played. Just like normal jobs - a lot of players are dumb as a rock.

I've worked with guys who have years of experience and a masters, they were worthless and fired. People need to stop putting a lot of these ex players on a pedestal.

like lebron said "most guys in the nba don't really know how to play basketball". That goes for football too

Originally posted by tankle104:

like lebron said "most guys in the nba don't really know how to play basketball".

Makes sense. The NBA product has been s**t for decades.

Originally posted by NinerTy:
As long as he "manages" the Niners to a Super Bowl win

Exactly.. are we going to be discussing this nonsense for the next decade? It's almost worse than the Jimmy sucks Jimmy a winner BS.

Originally posted by RickyRoma:

Originally posted by tankle104:

like lebron said "most guys in the nba don't really know how to play basketball".

Makes sense. The NBA product has been s**t for decades.

A lot of these guys are just super athletic and can get by with that until they're drafted. They don't really hone their craft or know much outside of their roles.

like a lot of WRs just know where to go or how to get open based on a few guys on the defensive sides movements - they don't know what the entire defense is doing or why.

most players couldn't be coaches. I'm not trying to knock or denigrate anyone - its just the reality.

In real estate development - not everyone on the team understands what is going on during the whole project. They just know their role and what to do. It's just life in general.

Originally posted by tankle104:
A lot of these guys are just super athletic and can get by with that until they're drafted. They don't really hone their craft or know much outside of their roles.

That's because they spend all their time weight lifting/training/pumping themselves up with drugs/etc. and don't spend much time on the fundamentals of the game. It's why in football for instance, blocking and tackling are as poor as it's ever been. Even with the advancement in tech with the gloves that receivers have, the drops are more frequent.

The subsequent product is a poorer one....but I guess it doesn't matter. The bottom line $ have never been better.

Originally posted by RickyRoma:

Originally posted by tankle104:
A lot of these guys are just super athletic and can get by with that until they're drafted. They don't really hone their craft or know much outside of their roles.

That's because they spend all their time weight lifting/training/pumping themselves up with drugs/etc. and don't spend much time on the fundamentals of the game. It's why in football for instance, blocking and tackling are as poor as it's ever been. Even with the advancement in tech with the gloves that receivers have, the drops are more frequent.

The subsequent product is a poorer one....but I guess it doesn't matter. The bottom line $ have never been better.

Lol idk if I agree with everytbing you're saying but I see what you're saying.

i blame college programs, TBH. A lot of them just don't teach the fundamentals and rely on just the raw talent. Outside of Alabama, Michigan, and Georgia - I feel most players are super underdeveloped.

look at USC. I mean do they even coach on defense? It's insane