There are 93 users in the forums

QB Brock Purdy Thread

Shop Find 49ers gear online
Originally posted by SanDiego49er:

Good Lord..who the hell picked that song? Lol Give the dude something better than that haha
  • thl408
  • Moderator
  • Posts: 33,018
Originally posted by Wubbie:
Originally posted by tankle104:
Originally posted by Wubbie:
Originally posted by tankle104:
I think the only other videos of his I've watched were of guys who had bad days. Lol so I expected the criticism - I believe one was Justin fields. I watched it tk see what he said about fields processing.

doesn't bother me either way, I love Brock. I just find it weird how he constantly knocks things about kyles system or how Brock does something, when they're clearly two of the best at what they are doing in the league.

Just because they're the best in the league doesn't mean that things can't be pointed out, critiqued, and improved on.
Shanahan himself is famous amongst his players for being able to dissect a play and could potentially go for an hour on just one play if he wanted.

I mean more along the lines of "I hate how he runs 7 step drops. He should never do it. Shouldn't be part of a playbook" etc. it's one thing to say a play was poorly executed but it's another to say that the play design etc is bad.

For that critique in particular, his take is reasonable: 7 step drops are less popular these days, with teams opting for quicker drops, play action, and designed movement out of the pocket, so that teams can better protect the QB. Historically, we haven't had the best luck in terms of QB health, and it's reasonable to point out that we have play designs that do potentially expose the QB.

But I think he's fair as well. I think the last study, he pointed out that we had wide edges in our pass protection, so he said that was fine.

The only thing that annoys me in his film studies is that he constantly nags about the CMC shuffle motion out of the backfield. Complains about it weekly. At that point, why don't you find out what the reasoning is for.

I think Kyle explained what is for, that "bumper motion" that CMC does while aligned 6 yards into the backfield. It's so that CMC has a clean release into the route and isn't chipped by the edge player.
Originally posted by D0PEMAN:
makes u wonder....what IS brock's ceiling?

Originally posted by Montana:
Originally posted by SanDiego49er:

Good Lord..who the hell picked that song? Lol Give the dude something better than that haha

I don't know I definitely teared up and cried like a b**ch. It definitely worked whatever they were going for
Originally posted by Silky:
I don't know I definitely teared up and cried like a b**ch. It definitely worked whatever they were going for

Hmm different song and maybe I would have gotten a little misty eyed. That song was too cringe Hallmark for me. My ears bled. Meh, I can barely get through the vid..that voice is terrible lol
[ Edited by Montana on Dec 22, 2023 at 9:55 AM ]
  • Giedi
  • Veteran
  • Posts: 33,368
Originally posted by Silky:
Originally posted by Montana:
Originally posted by SanDiego49er:

Good Lord..who the hell picked that song? Lol Give the dude something better than that haha

I don't know I definitely teared up and cried like a b**ch. It definitely worked whatever they were going for

Fantastic summary of his MVP trajectory.
Originally posted by thl408:
I think Kyle explained what is for, that "bumper motion" that CMC does while aligned 6 yards into the backfield. It's so that CMC has a clean release into the route and isn't chipped by the edge player.

That was about 2 weeks ago in the Papa interview, JTO hasn't mentioned it in his video since lol
Originally posted by SanDiego49er:
Originally posted by Jcool:

Should have kept it and made $202,000. Who would have thought in July 2023? Wow. I thought he would be good. But maybe not this good and this quick. Especially coming off the elbow injury. But here we are. The favorite for the MVP.
his gameplay hasn't changed or dropped off at the end of last year. so theoretically should have been no change in the coming year.

only if i lived closer to a sportsbook
  • Giedi
  • Veteran
  • Posts: 33,368
Originally posted by Montana:
Originally posted by D0PEMAN:
makes u wonder....what IS brock's ceiling?


Give him an all-pro offensive line, and we should find out.
Just have to chime in here as I see some harping on O'Sullivan: haven't watched the latest video, but prior to that, which is like 5 of them, he actually basically says that Purdy is better than Shanahan's playcalling and design. He points out the mistakes he makes, which of course he does, but man when he makes insane throws/decisions, he gives him all the credit in the world. I think the guy LOVES Purdy, so idk wtf y'all talking about, but then again some of you just spit nonsense for a living. San Diego is nice btw, watched the last game at Bubs.
Originally posted by Dirtydonedirtcheap69:
Just have to chime in here as I see some harping on O'Sullivan: haven't watched the latest video, but prior to that, which is like 5 of them, he actually basically says that Purdy is better than Shanahan's playcalling and design. He points out the mistakes he makes, which of course he does, but man when he makes insane throws/decisions, he gives him all the credit in the world. I think the guy LOVES Purdy, so idk wtf y'all talking about, but then again some of you just spit nonsense for a living. San Diego is nice btw, watched the last game at Bubs.
Jt is full of s**t lol

he continuously says he doesn't know whats the play or it's intent but bashes Kyle's scheming on perfectly set up plays.. dude is a tool
  • thl408
  • Moderator
  • Posts: 33,018
Originally posted by qnnhan7:
Originally posted by thl408:
I think Kyle explained what is for, that "bumper motion" that CMC does while aligned 6 yards into the backfield. It's so that CMC has a clean release into the route and isn't chipped by the edge player.

That was about 2 weeks ago in the Papa interview, JTO hasn't mentioned it in his video since lol

Yes. Papa interview. Now that there are other, better film analysts cutting up Brock, I stopped watching JTO's.
Originally posted by 49AllTheTime:
Originally posted by Dirtydonedirtcheap69:
Just have to chime in here as I see some harping on O'Sullivan: haven't watched the latest video, but prior to that, which is like 5 of them, he actually basically says that Purdy is better than Shanahan's playcalling and design. He points out the mistakes he makes, which of course he does, but man when he makes insane throws/decisions, he gives him all the credit in the world. I think the guy LOVES Purdy, so idk wtf y'all talking about, but then again some of you just spit nonsense for a living. San Diego is nice btw, watched the last game at Bubs.
Jt is full of s**t lol

he continuously says he doesn't know whats the play or it's intent but bashes Kyle's scheming on perfectly set up plays.. dude is a tool

Might be mirror time bro, he always explains why he has a criticism and spends TONS of time highlighting the EPIC s**t we do. You sound like an over sensitive fan to me, something the Seahawks have plenty of, and something we need LESS of.
BTW…are we as Niner fans seriously claiming Shanahan is infallible? I mean…come on.
Originally posted by thl408:
Originally posted by qnnhan7:
Originally posted by thl408:
I think Kyle explained what is for, that "bumper motion" that CMC does while aligned 6 yards into the backfield. It's so that CMC has a clean release into the route and isn't chipped by the edge player.

That was about 2 weeks ago in the Papa interview, JTO hasn't mentioned it in his video since lol

Yes. Papa interview. Now that there are other, better film analysts cutting up Brock, I stopped watching JTO's.

I haven't seen one better. He's better than our Johnny, and that's no slight on Johnny, who's obviously great. Agree to disagree.
Share 49ersWebzone