Originally posted by Phoenix49ers:
Its a nonsense take. The 49ers in the 80s didn't have a salary cap to deal with. They had an owner willing to outspend everyone and thus they could afford backups better than quite few starters. In spite of that, they still blew quite a few winnable playoff games. In 1985, 86 and 87 they got bounced from the playoffs in just a single game, losing by double digits in all of those. Montana got worked over good by Parcells, Belichick and the Giants.
By the time Young took over, the cap was in place, the gap was greatly narrowed in terms of talent and you had a front office that began making a lot of questionable decisions that further stripped the team of talent.
By the time you got to 1995 and Shanahan was gone, you had no Ricky Watters and a completely one dimensional offense where Marc Trestman had to lean heavily on a short passing game because the RBs were awful and teams took advantage of that, playing the pass and daring the 49ers to run on them.
If anything, it's comparable to how badly the Packers have bungled and mismanaged the roster with Aaron Rodgers. The Packers of the mid to late 90s era were the opposite. They had a great offensive minded coach in Holmgren, a very good run game, a very talented defense led by Reggie White and LeRoy Butller. They were built to take out the 49ers and they did it successfully.
The only year after 1994 where the 49ers had a truly complete roster was 1998 and then Garrison Hearst blew out his knee on the first series of the NFCCG.
Superb post, that is pretty much as I recall those events too. Knew the game was over when Hearst left the field. there were so many matches in the mid-late 90s when I just knew the 49ers were just not good enough all around but still very watchable. Some tough losses in the '80s too. A shocking loss to the (Vikings 87 was it?) Joe got benched as I recall and Young came on pretty well, they were expected to win, was unwell for a week after that loss. Those were days without Sky TV coverage. Used to listen in Scotland to AFN at all hours in the morning, radio reception was desperately poor, can still hear Hank Stram and Jack Buck's superb commentary when the reception was good but sometimes. Joe has em at the 20 and...then waves of interference with like some Opera singers on acid and a backing group of Polish newsreaders! Sometimes wait ten minutes for the outcome of the play! That's dedication for you!