LISTEN: Are The 49ers Done? →

There are 162 users in the forums

QB Brock Purdy Thread

Shop Find 49ers gear online
Originally posted by OnTheClock:
I agree. He has put up way too many stinkers to be considered a star QB now.

There's absolutely no excuse for the pile of sh** he put out there today.

This is absurd. Watch other QBs. No one has perfect games this year.
He missed out on two easy touchdowns today due to lack of arm strength. Kittle and Crowning we're both wide open and should have been TDs, but Purdy under threw both passes.

The Interceptions we're just the Icing on the cake In what can only be described as an ugly performance from Brock.
Originally posted by captveg:
Originally posted by OnTheClock:
I agree. He has put up way too many stinkers to be considered a star QB now.

There's absolutely no excuse for the pile of sh** he put out there today.

This is absurd. Watch other QBs. No one has perfect games this year.

Some of this has to be on Shanahan. He has totally changed his game plan from run to pass.

empty sets, limited rpo's. the opposition DL know its a pass and tee off.

he's not doing Purdy any favours.
Originally posted by Montana:
Originally posted by thl408:
Originally posted by Hoovtrain:
Originally posted by tankle104:

You obviously can't compare their situations apples to apples, but it's still interesting. I didn't think I'd see Brock have better stats than mahommes. Lol pretty damn cool, IMO.

I tend to forget he's only 1 1/2 years in. Wild

I couldn't believe the reads and throws he was making last season as a rookie. It was veteran-like from the beginning how he stayed calm to read the field, especially zone and how he used his eyes to move defenders. By the third game, I was convinced it wasn't a fluke because it was consistent and not considered 'flashing'. He can still get better. As DCs show him more things, he'll learn.

It doesn't surprise me at all to see those stats and stats that surpass Mahomes. Mahomes is a pretty darn good qb but honestly, he got pretty damn lucky with those Superbowls. The one where we played..KC wasn't the better team..they didn't shine..just the 7 mins of hell happened lol. And I have been saying it since the NFC Champ Game, we would have won against the Eagles..no question..had it not been for the injury.

I also have had no doubt that we would have our 6th ring had we faced KC. Our D would have had an injured Mahomes for lunch. And I believe BP was the better qb at the time. Yes, over Mahomes.


Love the guy -- especially for the value we got him at -- but can we please stop with these insane comparisons to Mahomes after today?

You don't have to be comparable to a great QB to be a good QB.
Originally posted by BYisGod:
Originally posted by RonnieLott:
Do we really want to mortgage our future by signing Brock to a long-term deal?

You can go out into the open market and find someone who can at least look competent.

Brock looks like he was the last player picked in the draft.

I'm not sure we want t go chips in on Brock.

He has too many meltdown games.

To me, you absolutely can't give him $60 million. He isn't worth that money. Kyle made Jimmy look serviceable FFS
Lol, he will get 60, either with us or elsewhere
Originally posted by communist:
Lol, he will get 60, either with us or elsewhere

60 from somewhere else at this point? You're dreaming.
Purdy played as bad as his cold sore on his lip today......
Originally posted by BYisGod:
Originally posted by RonnieLott:
Do we really want to mortgage our future by signing Brock to a long-term deal?

You can go out into the open market and find someone who can at least look competent.

Brock looks like he was the last player picked in the draft.

I'm not sure we want t go chips in on Brock.

He has too many meltdown games.

To me, you absolutely can't give him $60 million. He isn't worth that money. Kyle made Jimmy look serviceable FFS


Originally posted by communist:
Originally posted by BYisGod:
Originally posted by RonnieLott:
Do we really want to mortgage our future by signing Brock to a long-term deal?

You can go out into the open market and find someone who can at least look competent.

Brock looks like he was the last player picked in the draft.

I'm not sure we want t go chips in on Brock.

He has too many meltdown games.

To me, you absolutely can't give him $60 million. He isn't worth that money. Kyle made Jimmy look serviceable FFS
Lol, he will get 60, either with us or elsewhere

2 missed td's on a noodle arm. They were both near walk in's. No way 60m.
Originally posted by captveg:
Originally posted by OnTheClock:
I agree. He has put up way too many stinkers to be considered a star QB now.

There's absolutely no excuse for the pile of sh** he put out there today.

This is absurd. Watch other QBs. No one has perfect games this year.

Yeah but this one is especially ugly… i love the kid but this was not good.
Originally posted by random49er:
Originally posted by communist:
Lol, he will get 60, either with us or elsewhere

60 from somewhere else at this point? You're dreaming.

He's a more confident, head strong Jimmy
Originally posted by TWD_Fan:
This might have been Purdy's worst game as a pro. Missed out on 2 TDs by underthrowing open receivers downfield. The first one to Kittle was especially painful because if that play had been a touchdown, our offense would have been off the field and Ayuk hadn't gotten hurt. He also threw 2 unnecessary picks on well-defended third down plays. As they say, sometimes it's better to settle for a field goal ...
the one to Kittle was thrown from one leg, iirc. Couldn't do that better.
But the second one was inexcusable, yes.

The second pick seemed to be on Bell. the third one his arm was hit, it's like a deflected int.
Originally posted by OnTheClock:
I love Brock, but he's starting to remind me of Dak honestly. Good but not good enough to seal it. The scoring position INTs were abominable.

I think he's more comparable to Dak than Pat as of today, that's for sure.
fact: Mahomes was not that much better today. However, no one would hate on him.
nm
[ Edited by random49er on Oct 20, 2024 at 4:22 PM ]
Share 49ersWebzone