QB Brock Purdy Thread

Originally posted by Ezekiel38:
Win #6 in impressive fashion playing the QB position and then we'll talk.

Don't curr about regular season. Jimmy was a liability in the playoffs and why we don't have #6 already.

Although I like what I've seen so far no doubt.

Jimmy didn't give up those points to KC in the Superbowl. Our defense couldn't hold the lead the offense got them. It's pretty f**king weak to try and solely blame Jimmy for that without mentioning the defense gave up the points that cost us the game.

Originally posted by Goatie:

Originally posted by Bay2Bay9erAllday:

Originally posted by CatchMaster80:

Originally posted by boast:

Originally posted by CatchMaster80:

Trey is the exact opposite. Everything Purdy has now Trey needs to learn. On the other hand, everything Trey has like athleticism and a strong arm can't be learned. Trey has a lot of room for impriovement where Brock might be about as good as he will ever be. That looks good right now but only time will tell if he can continue it.

pfft....Brock has the brain plasticity of a 23yo so he has plenty of room to improve. it's not like he's some 30yo dude.

How much better can his pocket awareness get? How much better can he get at finding open receivers? I'm not saying he can't improve. I'm just saying that Trey has much more room to improve since he's quite a ways behind right now. Trey looks like a rookie. Purdy looks like a guy that's been in the league for 2-3 years.

There is always room for improvement. He's a rookie after all, even if he's playing like a vet. Just because Trey has more room to improved due to the fact he's starting from scratch doesn't really say much.

It is like false economy isn't it? Yeah Purdy will improve only a little bit compared to Lance. In reality Purdy is already high on the scale but Lance is much lower. So if Lance improves a massive 50% and Purdy only improves 20% the end result would still be that Purdy is a better QB. If Lance improves 50% he still would not be as good as Jimmy G for a few years. Catchmaster's argument is not the best I have heard on here. But it is a good argument for a Lanceling. (irony)

Your improvement numbers are arbitrary. None of us knows how much Lance will improve or if Purdy will continue to play this well. Trey may only improve a little but he could make huge strides if he gets enough reps. You can't deny that we've seen many QBs have a few good starts and then begin to have problems. It's also just as common to see a young QB struggle for a year or even two before the light goes on. If Purdy continues to play at his current level and even improves some, then it will be hard for Trey to get the reps he needs. Kyle was willing to give him those reps thus t]years since he had decided to move on from an injured JG. Different story next year.

Two years from now we could have one good QB, two good QBs or none. The future is always an unknown. Just like the people that try to predict scores every week, nobody can predict how good a player will be in 2 years. We like to assume that he will improve but unfortunately that doesn't always happen. Things happen that nobody has control over. Things like injuries can set back a players progress. We saw it with Jimmy and we've seen it with Trey already.

I hope we end up with 2 good players that can guide the team when called upon. That would be ideal to have 2 young QBs that can play. Unfortunately one would probably leave for free agency or get traded. This is 2022 and QB depth is just a fantasy because of the cap and free agency.

Originally posted by Memphis9er:

Originally posted by Ezekiel38:
Win #6 in impressive fashion playing the QB position and then we'll talk.

Don't curr about regular season. Jimmy was a liability in the playoffs and why we don't have #6 already.

Although I like what I've seen so far no doubt.

Jimmy didn't give up those points to KC in the Superbowl. Our defense couldn't hold the lead the offense got them. It's pretty f**king weak to try and solely blame Jimmy for that without mentioning the defense gave up the points that cost us the game.

That hold on Bosa to set up that drive that started the comeback. In fact, all the holding that O line did the last 8 mintues of the game. The BS OPI on Kittle that took points off the board. The late hit out of bounds on Jimmy that was never called. That helmet to facemask hit on Jimmy that was never called. The defensive holding on the chiefs DB's that were never called. f**k the the chiefs and f**k the NFL and their refs.

Anyone think he has a shot at rookie of the year? He got the weekly award and I'm not overly impressed with Garrett Wilson or Seattle's RB

Originally posted by CatchMaster80:
Your improvement numbers are arbitrary. None of us knows how much Lance will improve or if Purdy will continue to play this well. Trey may only improve a little but he could make huge strides if he gets enough reps. You can't deny that we've seen many QBs have a few good starts and then begin to have problems. It's also just as common to see a young QB struggle for a year or even two before the light goes on. If Purdy continues to play at his current level and even improves some, then it will be hard for Trey to get the reps he needs. Kyle was willing to give him those reps thus t]years since he had decided to move on from an injured JG. Different story next year.

Two years from now we could have one good QB, two good QBs or none. The future is always an unknown. Just like the people that try to predict scores every week, nobody can predict how good a player will be in 2 years. We like to assume that he will improve but unfortunately that doesn't always happen. Things happen that nobody has control over. Things like injuries can set back a players progress. We saw it with Jimmy and we've seen it with Trey already.

I hope we end up with 2 good players that can guide the team when called upon. That would be ideal to have 2 young QBs that can play. Unfortunately one would probably leave for free agency or get traded. This is 2022 and QB depth is just a fantasy because of the cap and free agency.

Preseason will be interesting. If Purdy keeps playing at his current level, I would expect him to be the fromt runner for the starting job at least until part way through the preseason. Lance will get the majority of preseason reps in. that scenario and that is exactly what he needs. By the end of preseason, either Purdy will be the clear cut starter, or Lance will have shown enough for there to be a debate about who should start. I can't wait to see how it plays out. This team is in great shape either way.

Pepsi zero sugar rookie of the week cause he aint sweet!

Originally posted by justjim77:
Anyone think he has a shot at rookie of the year? He got the weekly award and I'm not overly impressed with Garrett Wilson or Seattle's RB

My guess is no since he's only played a few games. I think they give out those awards before the post season so that would be a really small sample.

Originally posted by iLLEST209ER:
Pepsi zero sugar rookie of the week cause he aint sweet!

Couldn't they just call it Pepsi Rookie of The Week. Do they really need to advertise their zero sugar brand?

Originally posted by YACBros85:

Originally posted by Memphis9er:

Originally posted by Ezekiel38:
Win #6 in impressive fashion playing the QB position and then we'll talk.

Don't curr about regular season. Jimmy was a liability in the playoffs and why we don't have #6 already.

Although I like what I've seen so far no doubt.

Jimmy didn't give up those points to KC in the Superbowl. Our defense couldn't hold the lead the offense got them. It's pretty f**king weak to try and solely blame Jimmy for that without mentioning the defense gave up the points that cost us the game.

That hold on Bosa to set up that drive that started the comeback. In fact, all the holding that O line did the last 8 mintues of the game. The BS OPI on Kittle that took points off the board. The late hit out of bounds on Jimmy that was never called. That helmet to facemask hit on Jimmy that was never called. The defensive holding on the chiefs DB's that were never called. f**k the the chiefs and f**k the NFL and their refs.

But…. It's the same NFL and refs that are gonna pave the way to #6 this year. The entire league loves our story and Brock's, not to mention what this does for the draft itself. The league wants this almost as bad as we do.

Originally posted by CatchMaster80:

Originally posted by justjim77:
Anyone think he has a shot at rookie of the year? He got the weekly award and I'm not overly impressed with Garrett Wilson or Seattle's RB

My guess is no since he's only played a few games. I think they give out those awards before the post season so that would be a really small sample.

Apparently there's no requirement for how many games played so there's a chance. Meawhile, whos the front runner? I don't believe any offensive rookie is making as much noise as BP.

Originally posted by Oregon49erfan:

Originally posted by CatchMaster80:
Your improvement numbers are arbitrary. None of us knows how much Lance will improve or if Purdy will continue to play this well. Trey may only improve a little but he could make huge strides if he gets enough reps. You can't deny that we've seen many QBs have a few good starts and then begin to have problems. It's also just as common to see a young QB struggle for a year or even two before the light goes on. If Purdy continues to play at his current level and even improves some, then it will be hard for Trey to get the reps he needs. Kyle was willing to give him those reps thus t]years since he had decided to move on from an injured JG. Different story next year.

Two years from now we could have one good QB, two good QBs or none. The future is always an unknown. Just like the people that try to predict scores every week, nobody can predict how good a player will be in 2 years. We like to assume that he will improve but unfortunately that doesn't always happen. Things happen that nobody has control over. Things like injuries can set back a players progress. We saw it with Jimmy and we've seen it with Trey already.

I hope we end up with 2 good players that can guide the team when called upon. That would be ideal to have 2 young QBs that can play. Unfortunately one would probably leave for free agency or get traded. This is 2022 and QB depth is just a fantasy because of the cap and free agency.

Preseason will be interesting. If Purdy keeps playing at his current level, I would expect him to be the fromt runner for the starting job at least until part way through the preseason. Lance will get the majority of preseason reps in. that scenario and that is exactly what he needs. By the end of preseason, either Purdy will be the clear cut starter, or Lance will have shown enough for there to be a debate about who should start. I can't wait to see how it plays out. This team is in great shape either way.

Sounds reasonable. The debate will continue as long as both are on the team unless Trey is a total bust or becomes the dominant QB that Kyle envisioned when he drafted him.

Originally posted by SLCNiner:

Originally posted by YACBros85:

Originally posted by Memphis9er:

Originally posted by Ezekiel38:
Win #6 in impressive fashion playing the QB position and then we'll talk.

Don't curr about regular season. Jimmy was a liability in the playoffs and why we don't have #6 already.

Although I like what I've seen so far no doubt.

Jimmy didn't give up those points to KC in the Superbowl. Our defense couldn't hold the lead the offense got them. It's pretty f**king weak to try and solely blame Jimmy for that without mentioning the defense gave up the points that cost us the game.

That hold on Bosa to set up that drive that started the comeback. In fact, all the holding that O line did the last 8 mintues of the game. The BS OPI on Kittle that took points off the board. The late hit out of bounds on Jimmy that was never called. That helmet to facemask hit on Jimmy that was never called. The defensive holding on the chiefs DB's that were never called. f**k the the chiefs and f**k the NFL and their refs.

But…. It's the same NFL and refs that are gonna pave the way to #6 this year. The entire league loves our story and Brock's, not to mention what this does for the draft itself. The league wants this almost as bad as we do.

We'll see.

Originally posted by linkboy:

Originally posted by CatchMaster80:
Did anyone watch the Oregon-NC game last night? North Carolina ran that play where Purdy faked a pass to the left, spun and faked to the right and threw a pass down the n=middle to Kittle for a TD. It looked exactly the same. Of course the announcers were giving Carolina credit for calling such an ingenious play. I guess Gus Johnson doesn't watch many NFL games.

That's not a new play, Walsh ran it with Steve Young back in 87.

Kyle got Kittle TD play from Bill Walsh. So cool. pic.twitter.com/IAnyLi5isE

— Ross Tucker (@RossTuckerNFL) December 16, 2022

So even on that note, Kyle can't take credit for designing it.

Called it at the perfect time though.

Jones!

Originally posted by D0PEMAN:

Originally posted by CatchMaster80:

Originally posted by justjim77:
Anyone think he has a shot at rookie of the year? He got the weekly award and I'm not overly impressed with Garrett Wilson or Seattle's RB

My guess is no since he's only played a few games. I think they give out those awards before the post season so that would be a really small sample.

Apparently there's no requirement for how many games played so there's a chance. Meawhile, whos the front runner? I don't believe any offensive rookie is making as much noise as BP.

There's not any requirements for any of these awards. They're usually popularity contests. I have no idea how any other rookies are doing but if there's one in the east coast region he'll have the advantage.

Originally posted by SlipAndSlideBosa:

Originally posted by iLLEST209ER:
Pepsi zero sugar rookie of the week cause he aint sweet!

Couldn't they just call it Pepsi Rookie of The Week. Do they really need to advertise their zero sugar brand?

They get both brand and product advertisements with one sponsorship. Smart move with their advertising spend. I hear Pepsi Zero is as sweet as sugar.