LISTEN: Talking 49ers With NFL Network's Cynthia Frelund →

There are 145 users in the forums

QB Brock Purdy Thread

Shop Find 49ers gear online
Originally posted by Kolohe:
Originally posted by 5thSFG:
Originally posted by Kolohe:
Originally posted by 5thSFG:
Originally posted by Kolohe:
Originally posted by SmokeyJoe:
Originally posted by Kolohe:
Um yes you do get paid on what you have done in your rookie contract or previous contract. Which is why players holdout. Tell me, did you think Aiyuk got paid for this season or what he did the two previous seasons? Did Trent Williams, CMC and Nick Bosa holdout for what they were gonna do or did they holdout for what they did?

You don't make sense bro.

To be fair, your post implied that he had done enough in 1.5 seasons to deserve that big money deal… almost as if what happens this season doesn't matter.

He can play himself out of that kind of contract this year, and possibly next depending on what happens this offseason.

He has done enough and even with the way he has played this season he still deserves it. Do you expect Brock to all of a sudden turn into Ryan Leaf anytime soon? Brock is on pace for another 4,000 yard season. And if all these other QB's who haven't done s**t in the playoffs got paid then no question Brock Purdy has earned it!!!

You get paid for potential performance, not prior performance. Obviously. It's the entire reason dudes hold out for guaranteed money… they know an injury diminishes their future potential.

So how do teams pay their players coming off rookie contract? Is it the potential they have shown from PRIOR PERFORMANCE? Or do teams disregard what they've done in previous years and just say oh yah he can play, he looks the part, laser rocket arm, pay him? Lol

Yes prior performance matters. But the bolded above, a statement you made to support your argument, is just plain silly.

aiyuk got his contract based off what the team thought his value would be over the period of the contract. His previous level of play is one factor to consider, as is his age, his coach ability, his raw talent etc etc. "we were thinking you were worth $25million, but you played so well last season, we'll give you $30"…. That's not a thing

and it won't be a thing for purdy. He'll get the contract they think he'll be worth next year and beyond, and they'll use the last couple years as data to pull from.

edit: I don't think you're dumb. I think we're probably saying the same thing but differently

Lol more contradiction. You sit here disagreeing with me to the fullest then tell me "Prior performance does matter". Lmfao

👍🏻.

irrelevant conclusion. If you re-read, slowly, youll probably be able to decipher what I wrote plainly.

but, like I said, it doesn't matter and I'm prepared to move on
  • Kolohe
  • Hall of Fame
  • Posts: 61,724
Nevermind I don't think you're dumb either.
All I have to say is that Dak was way overpaid and I am loving it
Originally posted by Kolohe:
I still disagree, because he's shown more times than he hasn't that he still can play. You're gonna discount 9 games over what he has already accomplished? Sure his poor play may factor in his upcoming contract but do you actually think by a lot?

I wouldn't discount anything. That's my entire point. To look at the body of work in totality… not a stretch of games where he played extremely well or poorly. We still have a good chunk of games to add into that evaluation*
[ Edited by SmokeyJoe on Oct 28, 2024 at 6:34 PM ]
Originally posted by Kolohe:
Nevermind I don't think you're dumb either.

I probably commented to hastily without scrolling up for full context. Apologies. Have a good evening
Originally posted by Montana:
All I have to say is that Dak was way overpaid and I am loving it

This couldn't be more true
Originally posted by Montana:
All I have to say is that Dak was way overpaid and I am loving it

He's an elite backup
  • Kolohe
  • Hall of Fame
  • Posts: 61,724
Originally posted by 5thSFG:
Originally posted by Kolohe:
Nevermind I don't think you're dumb either.

I probably commented to hastily without scrolling up for full context. Apologies. Have a good evening

Nah its all good brotha!!
In sports, just like with any product or service, value is defined by what the market is willing to pay. If the 49ers choose to undervalue Brock Purdy and offer him less than other teams would, it's only fair to let him test his true market worth. I'm confident there are at least five teams, if not more, that would willingly offer him $60 million without needing to see him take another snap.
Let's just draft a new QB every three years and stay on rookie contract forever.

Originally posted by investasi:
In sports, just like with any product or service, value is defined by what the market is willing to pay. If the 49ers choose to undervalue Brock Purdy and offer him less than other teams would, it's only fair to let him test his true market worth. I'm confident there are at least five teams, if not more, that would willingly offer him $60 million without needing to see him take another snap.

Definitely true. Maybe they let him test the market in a way, not unlike Lamar's situation with Baltimore.
He won't test the market. You all have seen what this guy can be. He sat for almost a year. Hasn't really even got out of 2nd grade yet in games played. He will be fine and he is fine. The first game he has his killer stats again the nay-sayers will flip on a dime. Typical,
[ Edited by 9erson3 on Oct 28, 2024 at 7:19 PM ]
  • titan
  • Veteran
  • Posts: 7,945
We got Brock for the next 10+ years. Go Niner
Originally posted by Montana:
All I have to say is that Dak was way overpaid and I am loving it
G1
When this play happened live, I thought Kyle had dialed up a triple option.

[ Edited by Heroism on Oct 28, 2024 at 8:47 PM ]
Share 49ersWebzone