QB Brock Purdy Thread

Originally posted by Bringbackedjr:
Maybe watch some other qbs before ripping on Brock. Many have cj rated hire than bp.. did you watch the s**tshow last night? Seems Brock handles pressure better and is more accurate. The old man looked like s**t most of the night. Mahomes ain't lighting the world on fire. The negativity towards Brock is stunning….

Yeah I agree.

Originally posted by miked1978:
It amazes me we get a good QB and some are still not satisfied bc he isnt the GOAT.

Why are we comparing him to Mahomes? Mahomes will probably go down as one of the greatest QBs of all time. lets compare Brock to the CJ Strouds of the world. I find it interesting most casual fans will place Stroud above Brock but look how much Stroud struggled last night. 11/30 passing. If it was Brock the narrative would be he isnt good bc he doesnt have all his weapons.
__PRESENT

That's true.

I'm happy with Brock. People have short memories of what we went through. If you cannot see that he's good, well, whatever.

Originally posted by miked1978:
It amazes me we get a good QB and some are still not satisfied bc he isnt the GOAT.

Why are we comparing him to Mahomes? Mahomes will probably go down as one of the greatest QBs of all time. lets compare Brock to the CJ Strouds of the world. I find it interesting most casual fans will place Stroud above Brock but look how much Stroud struggled last night. 11/30 passing. If it was Brock the narrative would be he isnt good bc he doesnt have all his weapons.
__PRESENT

People put too much emphasis on stupid things when it comes to QB evaluations. Now with social media and general media coverage the fans want a QB who is loved by all and somehow care too much when people claim their guy wouldn't be as good on another team.

I don't give a flying F what people think about Brock being a system QB or claim he wouldn't be as good on team X. Know why I don't care? Cuz he's on the 49ers and hopefully for a long time.

Hypothetical situations don't move me and while it's nice to see fans and media acknowledge the greatness of our players it's not a must have. As long as Brock is playing well most of the time and helps us win games I don't care if he's considered a top 3/5/10 QB, etc...

Only time I care is when people are being down on the guy while ignoring facts and speak a bunch of nonsense.

Fact is Brock doesn't have to be Mahomes, Lamar, Allen, etc. He just has to be a great QB for US.

I still love Brock. I think he's been one of our best players this year, although there is always room for
improvement.

I hope we come out of the bye hungry and healthy, ready to make a point.

Originally posted by JenningsRoutes:

Originally posted by SteveWallacesHelmet:
YOU didnt argue with facts. LOL. Not a single thing you posted in that wall of text was a fact. Just baseless and/or biased opinions.

Really? So it's not a fact that Mahomes was 29th in air yards per completion last year, as well as 31st in air yards per completion this year?

It's not a fact that Purdy threw way behind Jennings on the touchdown at the back of the endzone against the Rams?

It's not a fact that Purdy has been underthrowing tons of deep balls this year?

You can't address anything I said because you have no argument.

You didn't mention the Mahomes stats at all until now. Not once.

Who cares if a touchdown pass was behind the receiver? It resulted in a touchdown. Literally THE best possible result of a pass. If a pass is underthrown but a better pass would have resulted in a better play, then by all means criticize it. But it was the best possible outcome so who cares?

Yes Purdy has underthrown passes this year and he has rightfully been criticized for them.

Anything else? Or are you into your third or fourth account for the week?

Originally posted by genus49:

Originally posted by miked1978:
It amazes me we get a good QB and some are still not satisfied bc he isnt the GOAT.

Why are we comparing him to Mahomes? Mahomes will probably go down as one of the greatest QBs of all time. lets compare Brock to the CJ Strouds of the world. I find it interesting most casual fans will place Stroud above Brock but look how much Stroud struggled last night. 11/30 passing. If it was Brock the narrative would be he isnt good bc he doesnt have all his weapons.
__PRESENT

People put too much emphasis on stupid things when it comes to QB evaluations. Now with social media and general media coverage the fans want a QB who is loved by all and somehow care too much when people claim their guy wouldn't be as good on another team.

I don't give a flying F what people think about Brock being a system QB or claim he wouldn't be as good on team X. Know why I don't care? Cuz he's on the 49ers and hopefully for a long time.

Hypothetical situations don't move me and while it's nice to see fans and media acknowledge the greatness of our players it's not a must have. As long as Brock is playing well most of the time and helps us win games I don't care if he's considered a top 3/5/10 QB, etc...

Only time I care is when people are being down on the guy while ignoring facts and speak a bunch of nonsense.

Fact is Brock doesn't have to be Mahomes, Lamar, Allen, etc. He just has to be a great QB for US.

Well said and I agree 100%

Originally posted by tankle104:
I still love Brock. I think he's been one of our best players this year, although there is always room for
improvement.

I hope we come out of the bye hungry and healthy, ready to make a point.

Will always love for some of the best 49ers football I have seen. Came out like a bull out of the gate and kicked ass.

Watching Stroud, I just dnt understand the hype of this guy. Not better than Purdy at all really.

Originally posted by Montana:

Originally posted by tankle104:
I still love Brock. I think he's been one of our best players this year, although there is always room for
improvement.

I hope we come out of the bye hungry and healthy, ready to make a point.

Will always love for some of the best 49ers football I have seen. Came out like a bull out of the gate and kicked ass.

Watching Stroud, I just dnt understand the hype of this guy. Not better than Purdy at all really.

Judging Stroud after 1 bad game with his top 2 receivers are out. Is like judging Purdy after the Chiefs game.

Originally posted by tankle104:
I still love Brock. I think he's been one of our best players this year, although there is always room for
improvement.

I hope we come out of the bye hungry and healthy, ready to make a point.

Hard to tell.....especially when you disappear after a poor performance/loss.

Originally posted by Hysterikal:

Originally posted by Montana:

Originally posted by tankle104:
I still love Brock. I think he's been one of our best players this year, although there is always room for
improvement.

I hope we come out of the bye hungry and healthy, ready to make a point.

Will always love for some of the best 49ers football I have seen. Came out like a bull out of the gate and kicked ass.

Watching Stroud, I just dnt understand the hype of this guy. Not better than Purdy at all really.

Judging Stroud after 1 bad game with his top 2 receivers are out. Is like judging Purdy after the Chiefs game.

Yeah while watching the game I thought sorta funny how a QB looks a little average when their top Offensive weapons are out. Reminds me of another certain QB that gets raked over the coals by the media in the same circumstance.

Originally posted by SanDiego49er:

Originally posted by Bringbackedjr:
Maybe watch some other qbs before ripping on Brock. Many have cj rated hire than bp.. did you watch the s**tshow last night? Seems Brock handles pressure better and is more accurate. The old man looked like s**t most of the night. Mahomes ain't lighting the world on fire. The negativity towards Brock is stunning….

Yeah I agree.

Fun fact - Purdy has more fantasy points than Stroud

Originally posted by bud49:

Originally posted by Hysterikal:

Originally posted by Montana:

Originally posted by tankle104:
I still love Brock. I think he's been one of our best players this year, although there is always room for
improvement.

I hope we come out of the bye hungry and healthy, ready to make a point.

Will always love for some of the best 49ers football I have seen. Came out like a bull out of the gate and kicked ass.

Watching Stroud, I just dnt understand the hype of this guy. Not better than Purdy at all really.

Judging Stroud after 1 bad game with his top 2 receivers are out. Is like judging Purdy after the Chiefs game.

Yeah while watching the game I thought sorta funny how a QB looks a little average when their top Offensive weapons are out. Reminds me of another certain QB that gets raked over the coals by the media in the same circumstance.

this is it right here.

Originally posted by RickyRoma:
Hard to tell.....especially when you disappear after a poor performance/loss.

It could be that he doesn't feel like talking about football and players after losses. Wouldn't be unique.

Originally posted by RickyRoma:

Originally posted by tankle104:

I still love Brock. I think he's been one of our best players this year, although there is always room for
improvement.

I hope we come out of the bye hungry and healthy, ready to make a point.

Hard to tell.....especially when you disappear after a poor performance/loss.

Stroud has been looking bad for a good month even before losing Diggs.

Purdy did have one terrible game and one sub-par one, but otherwise has been solid at minimum, to great.