QB Brock Purdy Thread

Originally posted by Furlow:
Okay so you tag him for $46M, fully guaranteed and all of it against the salary cap for 2026. Makes signing anyone else that much more difficult. He plays the same or maybe slightly better than what he's been averaging - then what? Tag him again for $52M? The price will keep going up each year. Or we can secure him for 4-6 years at an average that will be very workable over the life of the contract. Can restructure later if necessary.

And if I'm Purdy, no way am I playing under the franchise tag. Just trade me. He's already earned his next contract based on his previous play and taking the team to two NFCCG's and a Super Bowl.

Originally posted by 49AllTheTime:

Originally posted by Furlow:

Originally posted by 49AllTheTime:

Originally posted by Furlow:
Projected franchise tag for 2025 for QB's is $42M. 2024 it's $38M. So for 2026 after Purdy's rookie contract expires, it'll be $46M-$48M. Like I said, we'd be LUCKY if he agreed to $50M.

Since many of you don't want to pay him that, do you suggest we just let him walk? What's your plan at QB after next season?

tagging him is an option

Okay so you tag him for $46M, fully guaranteed and all of it against the salary cap for 2026. Makes signing anyone else that much more difficult. He plays the same or maybe slightly better than what he's been averaging - then what? Tag him again for $52M? The price will keep going up each year. Or we can secure him for 4-6 years at an average that will be very workable over the life of the contract. Can restructure later if necessary.

And if I'm Purdy, no way am I playing under the franchise tag. Just trade me. He's already earned his next contract based on his previous play and taking the team to two NFCCG's and a Super Bowl.

Purdy will play under the tag..

but if we do sign him long term and he has another year like this.. our offense will be stagnant again.. then everyone will be happy about the big signing

Originally posted by Furlow:

Originally posted by 49AllTheTime:

Originally posted by Furlow:

Originally posted by 49AllTheTime:

Originally posted by Furlow:
Projected franchise tag for 2025 for QB's is $42M. 2024 it's $38M. So for 2026 after Purdy's rookie contract expires, it'll be $46M-$48M. Like I said, we'd be LUCKY if he agreed to $50M.

Since many of you don't want to pay him that, do you suggest we just let him walk? What's your plan at QB after next season?

tagging him is an option

Okay so you tag him for $46M, fully guaranteed and all of it against the salary cap for 2026. Makes signing anyone else that much more difficult. He plays the same or maybe slightly better than what he's been averaging - then what? Tag him again for $52M? The price will keep going up each year. Or we can secure him for 4-6 years at an average that will be very workable over the life of the contract. Can restructure later if necessary.

And if I'm Purdy, no way am I playing under the franchise tag. Just trade me. He's already earned his next contract based on his previous play and taking the team to two NFCCG's and a Super Bowl.

Purdy will play under the tag..

but if we do sign him long term and he has another year like this.. our offense will be stagnant again.. then everyone will be happy about the big signing

Not if we get rid of fat Deebo and add a route running WR. Plus Aiyuk back. And draft a pass catching TE and C who can actually not get blown backwards on every pass play. Offensive roster needs some tweaks to fit Purdy's skillset.

Originally posted by Furlow:
Not if we get rid of fat Deebo and add a route running WR. Plus Aiyuk back. And draft a pass catching TE and C who can actually not get blown backwards on every pass play. Offensive roster needs some tweaks to fit Purdy's skillset.

Originally posted by Montana:

Originally posted by Furlow:
Not if we get rid of fat Deebo and add a route running WR. Plus Aiyuk back. And draft a pass catching TE and C who can actually not get blown backwards on every pass play. Offensive roster needs some tweaks to fit Purdy's skillset.

Fat Deebo? Lol didn't he lose a chunk of weight? When he is good, he is pretty good. When he is a bit off..not so good.

Originally posted by KyleNoHotReads:
Why are people talking about the money as if it matters?

Have you people still not learned that every player on the team is going to get injured?

There are two types of 49er players: Players on Injured Reserve, and players who are going to be on injured reserve.

The Lenoir signing was stupid for this reason.

The only player you would sign long-term is the QB, since it's so important.

The question to ask is whether or not Brock's the guy, not nitpicking over how much he makes. I don't care if it takes $100 million per year. If he's the guy, you pay him.

No other player should ever be signed to a long-term contract. They are going to get injured. Only Kyle and fans don't realize this.

Not to mention, the other players are vastly overrated. The current game is all about scheme and the QBs running the scheme. That's basically it.

I'm not saying other players can't slightly enhance things, but it's nowhere near as important as people think.

No skill guys are carrying QBs to anything. Unless you go back to Randy Moss, that's just not how it works. The SYSTEM - the scheme and play calling - is what makes or breaks units.

Jimmy Garoppolo had his best games playing with Marquis Goodwin, Kendrick Bourne, Trent Taylor, Aldrick Robinson, Garrett Celek, and a rookie George Kittle, as well as Carlos Hyde.

Defense is also about scheme. The 49ers have had a million different corners, many of them seemingly no names, and they've always been good as a cover unit. Safeties these days just have to know the scheme and not be out of position.

Originally posted by 49erFaithful6:

Originally posted by Montana:

Originally posted by Furlow:
Not if we get rid of fat Deebo and add a route running WR. Plus Aiyuk back. And draft a pass catching TE and C who can actually not get blown backwards on every pass play. Offensive roster needs some tweaks to fit Purdy's skillset.

Fat Deebo? Lol didn't he lose a chunk of weight? When he is good, he is pretty good. When he is a bit off..not so good.

fat deebo rings true to these eyes. he gets on the end around and he's huffing and puffing and going out of bounds for no gain

Originally posted by Montana:

Originally posted by Furlow:
Not if we get rid of fat Deebo and add a route running WR. Plus Aiyuk back. And draft a pass catching TE and C who can actually not get blown backwards on every pass play. Offensive roster needs some tweaks to fit Purdy's skillset.

Fat Deebo? Lol didn't he lose a chunk of weight? When he is good, he is pretty good. When he is a bit off..not so good.

Originally posted by Furlow:

Originally posted by Montana:

Originally posted by Furlow:
Not if we get rid of fat Deebo and add a route running WR. Plus Aiyuk back. And draft a pass catching TE and C who can actually not get blown backwards on every pass play. Offensive roster needs some tweaks to fit Purdy's skillset.

Fat Deebo? Lol didn't he lose a chunk of weight? When he is good, he is pretty good. When he is a bit off..not so good.

He lost weight before the season. Clearly he's gaining weight during the season and is not as fast nor as explosive as he used to be. Plus he's never been a good route runner who get separation vs. man coverage.

Originally posted by 9erson3:
He can't make up stats. Last is last. Kyle is not adjusting.

Originally posted by Schulzy:

Originally posted by Jcool:
Shanahan does it every game. Purdy is missing them.

Show me an easy throw Kyle schemed up for Purdy yesterday.

Not a check-down. Not the play on the goal line.

Go ahead.

Originally posted by 49AllTheTime:
Every game has multiple plays like this. We even had one to a wide open Persall in the endzone that would have put the game away.

like I've mentioned a lot this year, Purdy is just not seeing the field like has in the past

Not buying the talk that the 49ers WRs aren't separating. They're open. A lot. Check out Deebo and Jennings on this play. QB checks it down because the center can't hold his block for 2 seconds. That's not a WR or coaching issue. Good play by Purdy, but the explosives are there. pic.twitter.com/qhY5F5IVw0

— Kyle Posey (@KP_Show) November 19, 2024

Originally posted by Leathaface:

Originally posted by 49AllTheTime:
Every game has multiple plays like this. We even had one to a wide open Persall in the endzone that would have put the game away.

like I've mentioned a lot this year, Purdy is just not seeing the field like has in the past

Not buying the talk that the 49ers WRs aren't separating. They're open. A lot. Check out Deebo and Jennings on this play. QB checks it down because the center can't hold his block for 2 seconds. That's not a WR or coaching issue. Good play by Purdy, but the explosives are there. pic.twitter.com/qhY5F5IVw0

— Kyle Posey (@KP_Show) November 19, 2024

You used a play where Purdy has pressure in his face in 1.5 seconds to highlight that he isn't seeing the field like last year?