QB Brock Purdy Thread

Originally posted by 49erFaithful6:

Originally posted by Dshearn:
y'all are tripping on the Brock hate....

this season did not shake out....and there is a bunch of places I would point before I point at Brock.

yeah Brock is not superman, but he is a dude you can get high end results from if you build around him. Not that different than Brees or Joe....hell Purdy looks kinda similar to 2006 Brady without the defense and the 100 plus starts to lean back on.

This team still has some talent on the roster, they just have to cut out the fat, rebuild the line.... and recenter the offense on the QB

let's get real on this. comparing to brees or joe? or brady? you just comp'd purdy to like 10 super bowls right here.

Originally posted by captveg:

Originally posted by 49erFaithful6:

Originally posted by Dshearn:
y'all are tripping on the Brock hate....

this season did not shake out....and there is a bunch of places I would point before I point at Brock.

yeah Brock is not superman, but he is a dude you can get high end results from if you build around him. Not that different than Brees or Joe....hell Purdy looks kinda similar to 2006 Brady without the defense and the 100 plus starts to lean back on.

This team still has some talent on the roster, they just have to cut out the fat, rebuild the line.... and recenter the offense on the QB

let's get real on this. comparing to brees or joe? or brady? you just comp'd purdy to like 10 super bowls right here.

Controversial take: I don't think Montana would win many SBs in this era. He probably gets 1 like Brees. Just look at Burrow - the guy is not sniffing another SB anytime soon despite being awesome. Pocket QBs just don't have the rules in their favor anymore. It's all about getting that ref call by playing backyard football.

Originally posted by 49erFaithful6:
montana was hardly a pocket QB. that's one reason walsh liked him. he could run and throw on the run.

lions are crushing it this year, and goff is a statue. brady won every sb basically, and was a pocket QB. i can't say i agree with you. we don't do or want a lot of backyard ball here. let richardson do that stuff. if anything brock was doing that too much his run around routine. pro football is best played on schedule. the routes, the protection is all on a schedule.

Originally posted by Pillbusta:

Originally posted by 49erFaithful6:
montana was hardly a pocket QB. that's one reason walsh liked him. he could run and throw on the run.

lions are crushing it this year, and goff is a statue. brady won every sb basically, and was a pocket QB. i can't say i agree with you. we don't do or want a lot of backyard ball here. let richardson do that stuff. if anything brock was doing that too much his run around routine. pro football is best played on schedule. the routes, the protection is all on a schedule.

You've got to have a playmaker at QB in todays game and it's time we dealt with that fact

Kyle was wrong and that's why he hasn't won. He thought he could scheme past talent but he can't. Time to own up to it and go get us a playmaker at QB and we have to not pay so many guys as they're champions when they're clearly not

Originally posted by 49erFaithful6:
detroit is basically #1 in the power ranks with a statue. Brock is a playmaker i would say no question. he's a bit like kyler in his mobility, not as much speed downfield but qbs don't use that a ton. he can keep plays alive like murray.

Originally posted by Pillbusta:

Originally posted by 49erFaithful6:
detroit is basically #1 in the power ranks with a statue. Brock is a playmaker i would say no question. he's a bit like kyler in his mobility, not as much speed downfield but qbs don't use that a ton. he can keep plays alive like murray.

Goff was number 1 overall or at least a very high draft choice if i remember correctly. He's a tall statuesque QB with his only limitation being his mobility. He's not getting balls batted down in the manner Brock has been

I like Brock but I'm not for paying him $60M

Originally posted by JC_916:

AGAIN FOR ALL THE PEOPLE IN THE BACK --- like I've said many times on here DO NOT PAY PURDY 60+ MILLION PER YEAR.

Let him play out his rookie deal then yes tag his ass. He doesn't like it sit him.

For all the people who were so against this...did this game change your mind???? Ok maybe it will be next week's game that will finally change it. See ya then...

Originally posted by dj43:
Comparing this year to last is a fool's errand. At the start of the season, the best WR he has was #3 last year and no CMC. Piersall has been NO help. No speed to open up the field.

He is the same guy he was last year but the team around him is a big step down from last year.

Originally posted by kyleburkle:
I believe jimmy was better at least he made us dangerous over the top and he was quick on his release

Originally posted by kyleburkle:

Originally posted by lamontb:
Now this is just crazy

I dunno jimmy won alot if games had multiple strong years his problem was injury

But injury is shanahan specialty

Originally posted by communist:

Originally posted by kyleburkle:

Originally posted by lamontb:
Now this is just crazy

I dunno jimmy won alot if games had multiple strong years his problem was injury

But injury is shanahan specialty

No, his problem was his quality. In particular: Noodle arm, no balls.

Originally posted by 49erFaithful6:

Originally posted by Dshearn:
y'all are tripping on the Brock hate....

this season did not shake out....and there is a bunch of places I would point before I point at Brock.

yeah Brock is not superman, but he is a dude you can get high end results from if you build around him. Not that different than Brees or Joe....hell Purdy looks kinda similar to 2006 Brady without the defense and the 100 plus starts to lean back on.

This team still has some talent on the roster, they just have to cut out the fat, rebuild the line.... and recenter the offense on the QB

let's get real on this. comparing to brees or joe? or brady? you just comp'd purdy to like 10 super bowls right here.