There are 311 users in the forums
Originally posted by genus49:
Jimmy had a dominant defense around him every year they won those games. Jimmy in the offense the way it was this year would be pissing down his leg. Not a lot of playaction and low YAC....yikes.
Originally posted by SmokeyJoe:he likes to ignore reality
Originally posted by genus49:
Jimmy had a dominant defense around him every year they won those games. Jimmy in the offense the way it was this year would be pissing down his leg. Not a lot of playaction and low YAC....yikes.
Faithful will consistently reference Jimmy's play in 2017, but conveniently ignore his play in 2018 prior to the injury.
The guy is and was a turnover machine. He had enough skill that Kyle could handcuff him and have a successful offense anyway.
Originally posted by elguapo:i rather he got the ball out quicker to get that YAC like he used to.. people want to say separation.. but did you see how he was still throwing to guys barely open the last two seasons.. he's just thinking too much and needs to let it rip
Purdy may have regressed a little bit in some areas, but he also progressed in some areas. I don't believe his accuracy or his progressions got worse. I believe the pass protection was a huge issue and of course, BA and many of our other weapons weren't consistently out there not to mention the offensive player of the year. However, he got much better with his mobility and not relying on yards after catch, taking deep shots, so that's a plus.
Originally posted by SmokeyJoe:
Originally posted by genus49:
Jimmy had a dominant defense around him every year they won those games. Jimmy in the offense the way it was this year would be pissing down his leg. Not a lot of playaction and low YAC....yikes.
Faithful will consistently reference Jimmy's play in 2017, but conveniently ignore his play in 2018 prior to the injury.
The guy is and was a turnover machine. He had enough skill that Kyle could handcuff him and have a successful offense anyway.
Originally posted by 49ers808:
I still don't understand what Jimmy did in 2017 that was so special? Yes, he was better than Hoyer and Beathard, and yes we went 5-0. Context would show that we were in a lot of close games prior to that and just a tad better at QB would get us over that hump. 7 TDS - 5 Ints isn't exactly world beating or what some make that out to be from Jimmy; maybe I'm alone on that one?
Originally posted by 49ers808:What jimmy was able to do was convert a few more 3rd downs when we were awful at that. We were close to being a 11 win team that year
Originally posted by SmokeyJoe:
Originally posted by genus49:
Jimmy had a dominant defense around him every year they won those games. Jimmy in the offense the way it was this year would be pissing down his leg. Not a lot of playaction and low YAC....yikes.
Faithful will consistently reference Jimmy's play in 2017, but conveniently ignore his play in 2018 prior to the injury.
The guy is and was a turnover machine. He had enough skill that Kyle could handcuff him and have a successful offense anyway.
I still don't understand what Jimmy did in 2017 that was so special? Yes, he was better than Hoyer and Beathard, and yes we went 5-0. Context would show that we were in a lot of close games prior to that and just a tad better at QB would get us over that hump. 7 TDS - 5 Ints isn't exactly world beating or what some make that out to be from Jimmy; maybe I'm alone on that one?
Originally posted by 49AllTheTime:
What jimmy was able to do was convert a few more 3rd downs when we were awful at that. We were close to being a 11 win team that year
Originally posted by 49ers808:
I still don't understand what Jimmy did in 2017 that was so special? Yes, he was better than Hoyer and Beathard, and yes we went 5-0. Context would show that we were in a lot of close games prior to that and just a tad better at QB would get us over that hump. 7 TDS - 5 Ints isn't exactly world beating or what some make that out to be from Jimmy; maybe I'm alone on that one?
Originally posted by SmokeyJoe:how ever you want to call it.. wow, clutch.. but converting 3rd downs is important. It's what sent this year into disarray
Originally posted by 49AllTheTime:
What jimmy was able to do was convert a few more 3rd downs when we were awful at that. We were close to being a 11 win team that year
More 3rd downs. Had a couple clutch game winning drives. Made some wow plays mainly off his one elite skill (his quick release).
Originally posted by genus49:
Right...and never looked the same way again.
I watched all those games the same way you did. That Jags game was awesome at the time but the defense was also playing well during that run. Teams averaged 19.8 points per game in those 5 games and that number is inflated largely from the Jags game since they scored 33 after scoring 2 TDs within like 30 seconds. That game also had a defensive score on our end.
I'm not going to pretend Jimmy didn't play well in those games and didn't revitalize the team but it's also stupid to pretend Jimmy was the key to our winning his whole time here and ignore how often the defense was able to help close out wins, especially in 2019.
Originally posted by 49AllTheTime:
how ever you want to call it.. wow, clutch.. but converting 3rd downs is important. It's what sent this year into disarray
Originally posted by 49erFaithful6:
exactly. brock does a lot of things well. you are probably never gonna get mr everything that has all traits. those guys are generational guys. so we lean into what brock does well, and when you invest in QB with a big contract, get some real OL upgrade and WR upgrade. maybe we have to cut some vets and get younger to afford it, that's just how it works.
Originally posted by SmokeyJoe:same here.. everyone was excited on what's to come. I had no issues, no one had issues with the signing.
Originally posted by 49AllTheTime:
how ever you want to call it.. wow, clutch.. but converting 3rd downs is important. It's what sent this year into disarray
I was just adding on to your post/thoughts. I obviously agree 3rd down conversions are critical.
I was 100 percent on board with Jimmy getting the contract he got at the time. I also would argue it was a product of circumstance and timing and more than what he showed on the field. In hindsight, it was a mistake and should not be used to justify paying Brock a massive deal when the circumstances are completely different. We should learn from past mistakes.
Originally posted by NYniner85:
Nick mullens had a great game once as well lol.
no one needs to try and defend Jimmy. The truth came out end of the day. He's barely a startable
QB on a mid team. The film backs it up.