QB Brock Purdy Thread

Originally posted by CatchMaster80:

Originally posted by boast:

Originally posted by FootballExpert49ers:
Burrow: Good, but his stiffness in the pocket is a problem and leads to sacks. Bengals fans blame their offensive line every year, but the sacks are on him.

Allen: His horrible footwork comes up every now and then and he goes through phases where he can't hit the broad side of a barn.

Lamar: Not a real quarterback.

Stroud: The Texans have wide open receivers all over the field and he's still not doing much this year. Not much smarter than Vince Young.

Daniels: Product of his receivers in college. Think he'll end up being a bust.

thanks for once again proving your screen name is nothing but satire.

youre no expert.

Jackson not a real QB? He has the 2nd most passing yards ths year with only 3 INTs. His passer rating is 116. Looks like a QB to me.

yeah that moronic post is moronic.

Originally posted by 49AllTheTime:

Originally posted by Cisco0623:
I hear you, but I will play devils advocate here. Hopefully Brock considers how the 49ers approach the o line and how that will affect his decisions etc lol

49ers before FA & Draft: Hey Brock we want to beef up the OL to protect you, but we will need cap space to do it.
Brock: IDGAF gimme all the monies

months later...Brock: Hey why didn't you protect me !

Life's a b***h lol

Originally posted by Cisco0623:

Originally posted by 49AllTheTime:

Originally posted by Cisco0623:
I hear you, but I will play devils advocate here. Hopefully Brock considers how the 49ers approach the o line and how that will affect his decisions etc lol

49ers before FA & Draft: Hey Brock we want to beef up the OL to protect you, but we will need cap space to do it.
Brock: IDGAF gimme all the monies

months later...Brock: Hey why didn't you protect me !

Life's a b***h lol

lol, this premise doesn't ring true. brock is making less than any QB1 of all time if you look at percentage of cap. and we aren't building up the line now. so this is lip service. why not do it when you have all the cap space?

Brock Purdy's "terrible" season so far:

QBR - 7th
Passer rating - 14th
Passing yard per game - 13th (20th in attempts)
Yards per attempt - 4th
Air yards per attempt - 2nd
Passing touchdowns - 19th
Total touchdowns - 13th

Originally posted by 49erFaithful6:

Originally posted by Cisco0623:

Originally posted by 49AllTheTime:

Originally posted by Cisco0623:
I hear you, but I will play devils advocate here. Hopefully Brock considers how the 49ers approach the o line and how that will affect his decisions etc lol

49ers before FA & Draft: Hey Brock we want to beef up the OL to protect you, but we will need cap space to do it.
Brock: IDGAF gimme all the monies

months later...Brock: Hey why didn't you protect me !

Life's a b***h lol

lol, this premise doesn't ring true. brock is making less than any QB1 of all time if you look at percentage of cap. and we aren't building up the line now. so this is lip service. why not do it when you have all the cap space?

That was what we've been saying the last two years (and even before Purdy). They simply don't prioritize o line. Hopefully that philosophy changes, but I am not holding my breath.

Originally posted by SmokeyJoe:
The LOL was because you said something ridiculously stupid. Here it is again:

Tyreek Hill went to Miami and now Tua's numbers look like Stat Paddy's used to.

You can narrow it down to YPA and maybe one or two other very basic stats if you like, but this isn't remotely close to accurate when looking at QB statistics overall. Tua's production isn't better than Mahomes post Hill, and isn't even close to Mahomes with Hill.

You obviously don't know what you're talking about. You make it very clear by believing Brock is the clear best QB in the NFL, let alone the other wildly stupid things you've said (like the above example).

*Here's Mahomes basic stat line in his first season without Hill:
5250 yards
41 Passing TDs
12 Ints
67.1 completion percentage
8.1 YPA
105 passer rating
79 QBR
Super Bowl Champion too.

Tua has never sniffed a year like this. Not remotely close.*

How cute, you don't understand football stats.

Cumulative passing yards are meaningless. You must think Drew Bledsoe was amazeballs in 1994.

Touchdowns are also meaningless when the average air yards of said touchdowns is 4.5 yards and you're throwing screens and shovel passes that should be scored as handoffs if the league wants to be serious.

Tua's yards per attempt in 2022 and 2023: 8.9 and 8.3

Rating: 105.5 and 101.1.

69.3% completion last year. Completion percentage is also meaningless for Stat Paddy because he's on dink and dunk planet, hitting the ocean from a rowboat off Andy Reid's pick routes that get guys wide open. He learned that from Mike Holmgren, by the way, who used to scheme wide open stuff for Montana and Young.

"SB champion"...needed the most blatant rigging by the refs you'll ever see. Let's be real. Stat Paddy does lead in certain metrics:

He is by far the leader in interceptions called back by a penalty.

He leads in clutch penalties against the opponent, as well as no calls on his own team on blatant penalties in the clutch.

He leads in defenders standing around and not trying to hit him because they're afraid of getting a penalty.

He also leads in NFL PR propaganda pretending that he's actually impressive.

Originally posted by CatchMaster80:
Jackson not a real QB? He has the 2nd most passing yards ths year with only 3 INTs. His passer rating is 116. Looks like a QB to me.

You're never going to convince me that a joke like him is a real QB. His mechanics are laughable. He has Vince Young intelligence. The only reason he succeeds is teams are so afraid of his legs that it opens things up for him to hit the ocean from a rowboat. He underthrows wide open deep balls by 10 yards.

Originally posted by FootballExpert49ers:
How cute, you don't understand football stats.

Cumulative passing yards are meaningless. You must think Drew Bledsoe was amazeballs in 1994.

Touchdowns are also meaningless when the average air yards of said touchdowns is 4.5 yards and you're throwing screens and shovel passes that should be scored as handoffs if the league wants to be serious.

Tua's yards per attempt in 2022 and 2023: 8.9 and 8.3

Rating: 105.5 and 101.1.

69.3% completion last year. Completion percentage is also meaningless for Stat Paddy because he's on dink and dunk planet, hitting the ocean from a rowboat off Andy Reid's pick routes that get guys wide open. He learned that from Mike Holmgren, by the way, who used to scheme wide open stuff for Montana and Young.

"SB champion"...needed the most blatant rigging by the refs you'll ever see. Let's be real. Stat Paddy does lead in certain metrics:

He is by far the leader in interceptions called back by a penalty.

He leads in clutch penalties against the opponent, as well as no calls on his own team on blatant penalties in the clutch.

He leads in defenders standing around and not trying to hit him because they're afraid of getting a penalty.

He also leads in NFL PR propaganda pretending that he's actually impressive.

You making an incorrect statement and then discounting applicable parts of that statement has nothing to do with my understanding of statistics. It's just your terrible argument falling flat on its face. Mahomes has been statistically better than Tua without Hill and was light years better statistically with him.

Originally posted by SmokeyJoe:

Originally posted by FootballExpert49ers:
How cute, you don't understand football stats.

Cumulative passing yards are meaningless. You must think Drew Bledsoe was amazeballs in 1994.

Touchdowns are also meaningless when the average air yards of said touchdowns is 4.5 yards and you're throwing screens and shovel passes that should be scored as handoffs if the league wants to be serious.

Tua's yards per attempt in 2022 and 2023: 8.9 and 8.3

Rating: 105.5 and 101.1.

69.3% completion last year. Completion percentage is also meaningless for Stat Paddy because he's on dink and dunk planet, hitting the ocean from a rowboat off Andy Reid's pick routes that get guys wide open. He learned that from Mike Holmgren, by the way, who used to scheme wide open stuff for Montana and Young.

"SB champion"...needed the most blatant rigging by the refs you'll ever see. Let's be real. Stat Paddy does lead in certain metrics:

He is by far the leader in interceptions called back by a penalty.

He leads in clutch penalties against the opponent, as well as no calls on his own team on blatant penalties in the clutch.

He leads in defenders standing around and not trying to hit him because they're afraid of getting a penalty.

He also leads in NFL PR propaganda pretending that he's actually impressive.

You making an incorrect statement and then discounting applicable parts of that statement has nothing to do with my understanding of statistics. It's just your terrible argument falling flat on its face. Mahomes has been statistically better than Tua without Hill and was light years better statistically with him.

You have to be really dumb or just trolling if you think Tua is better.

Originally posted by SmokeyJoe:
You making an incorrect statement and then discounting applicable parts of that statement has nothing to do with my understanding of statistics. It's just your terrible argument falling flat on its face. Mahomes has been statistically better than Tua without Hill and was light years better statistically with him.

No. No he has not. He has been statistically worse, as shown by yards per attempt. Throwing a gorillion balls does not mean you are "statistically better," unless you think Drew Bledsoe was statistically better than Steve Young in 1994.

Mahomes has downright mediocre numbers the last two years that are nowhere close to Tua's.

Also, Terry Bradshaw, Howie Long, and Rex Ryan all compared Brock Purdy to Joe Montana. Doesn't that imply they think he might be the best QB in football?

Originally posted by GoreGoreGore:
You have to be really dumb or just trolling if you think Tua is better.

his posts are worse than this season

Originally posted by GoreGoreGore:
You have to be really dumb or just trolling if you think Tua is better.

OF COURSE he's better.

Stat Paddy is 32nd in air yards per attempt and 32nd in air yards per completion.

How is this still not sinking in? Stat Paddy is the ultimate product of a system.

I know you've been brainwashed by NFL PR department propaganda, but it's time to pull your head out of your ass.

Did you know that in 2023, for the majority of the season, Stat Paddy was further behind Brock Purdy in yards per attempt than Ryan Leaf was behind Steve Young in 1998?

Originally posted by sick9erfan:
The fact is that Brock is a very young QB who is having a down year, he's put a ton of good play on tape. many of the top Qbs in the league hadn't hit their stride by Brocks age. Solidify the line and he is a 10+ win QB every single year, everybody struggles in this league. He will probably never be a top 5 guy but he is top 10 all day and twice on sundays. To quote Aaron RELAX!

Wonder if these people feel the same way about Stroud this year

Originally posted by FootballExpert49ers:
No. No he has not. He has been statistically worse, as shown by yards per attempt. Throwing a gorillion balls does not mean you are "statistically better," unless you think Drew Bledsoe was statistically better than Steve Young in 1994.

Mahomes has downright mediocre numbers the last two years that are nowhere close to Tua's.

Also, Terry Bradshaw, Howie Long, and Rex Ryan all compared Brock Purdy to Joe Montana. Doesn't that imply they think he might be the best QB in football?

You could have said Tua has been better in YPA since Hill was with Miami. That would be accurate, though fairly meaningless given it's a single statistic. What you said again was:

Tyreek Hill went to Miami and now Tua's numbers look like Stat Paddy's used to.

This isn't remotely close to accurate. Not since Hill has left KC and not even close when he was there.

I'm sorry that you're so invested in Purdy that it leads you to say really stupid things like this.