QB Brock Purdy Thread

Niners shouldn't pay him more than 40mil a year

Originally posted by Hoovtrain:
Needs to be infinitely better.

No doubt he will be. This year is an off year, it is what it is.

Originally posted by ninerfan4life:
Niners shouldn't pay him more than 40mil a year

And if you give him an extra $10 mil what does that mean, absolutely nothing.

Originally posted by niners94:
The offensive line is severely impacting his play. They better upgrade it. Neglecting it this year is probably the biggest reason why they're under performing.

It's a multilayer issue. While the OL hasn't been dominant. Brock has held onto the ball almost longer than any QB in the league.

he's not processing quickly, he's not throwing those anticipatory throws like he did so consistently in the past. I'm sure not having his best separator out there has hurt.

if you watch the film you will see guys open and check downs there though. He's trying to act like Mahomes or some s**t. He ain't that and needs to get back to what works for him.

Originally posted by Kolohe:

Originally posted by ninerfan4life:
Niners shouldn't pay him more than 40mil a year

And if you give him an extra $10 mil what does that mean, absolutely nothing.

It means he doesn't get that C we think he needs or depth on his oline. Every decision has consequences and this team has gone through a stretch of making nearly every decent role player on this team the highest paid in the league and that is going to catch up to us hard.

Originally posted by NYniner85:

Originally posted by niners94:
The offensive line is severely impacting his play. They better upgrade it. Neglecting it this year is probably the biggest reason why they're under performing.

It's a multilayer issue. While the OL hasn't been dominant. Brock has held onto the ball almost longer than any QB in the league.

he's not processing quickly, he's not throwing those anticipatory throws like he did so consistently in the past. I'm sure not having his best separator out there has hurt.

if you watch the film you will see guys open and check downs there though. He's trying to act like Mahomes or some s**t. He ain't that and needs to get back to what works for him.

DC's in this league are also figuring his play and how to counter. If he doesn't evolve he's as good as done

Originally posted by NYniner85:

Originally posted by niners94:
The offensive line is severely impacting his play. They better upgrade it. Neglecting it this year is probably the biggest reason why they're under performing.

It's a multilayer issue. While the OL hasn't been dominant. Brock has held onto the ball almost longer than any QB in the league.

he's not processing quickly, he's not throwing those anticipatory throws like he did so consistently in the past. I'm sure not having his best separator out there has hurt.

if you watch the film you will see guys open and check downs there though. He's trying to act like Mahomes or some s**t. He ain't that and needs to get back to what works for him.

I wonder if it's his arm, and a lack of faith in it? he does have it in a wrap on the sidelines after every offensive series. If I'm the 49ers I am weary of a big contract not only on his play this year but also on his arm issue.

Originally posted by Kolohe:
And if you give him an extra $10 mil what does that mean, absolutely nothing.

Why do you want to hitch our wagon to a guy who needs a stacked roster? We're not gonna have that for quite a while. He can't throw in inclement weather. You don't think we can get that for a lot cheaper?

can't we just admit that he was the last pick of the draft for a reason?

Originally posted by jcs:

Originally posted by Kolohe:

Originally posted by ninerfan4life:
Niners shouldn't pay him more than 40mil a year

And if you give him an extra $10 mil what does that mean, absolutely nothing.

It means he doesn't get that C we think he needs or depth on his oline. Every decision has consequences and this team has gone through a stretch of making nearly every decent role player on this team the highest paid in the league and that is going to catch up to us hard.

Why not? his cap hit won't fully take up all the cap space, they just got another $17 million when they were already leading the league in cap space. This team has been so good at managing the cap, you think they're just gonna blow it up and not think of anything else!!

Originally posted by maximusdecimus:

Originally posted by Kolohe:
And if you give him an extra $10 mil what does that mean, absolutely nothing.

Why do you want to hitch our wagon to a guy who needs a stacked roster? We're not gonna have that for quite a while. He can't throw in inclement weather. You don't think we can get that for a lot cheaper?

can't we just admit that he was the last pick of the draft for a reason?

So $40 million wouldn't be saying you're hitching your wagon, but $50 million is.....okay make sense.

WTF is going on here!!!!

Originally posted by Kolohe:
So $40 million wouldn't be saying you're hitching your wagon, but $50 million is.....okay make sense.

WTF is going on here!!!!

Ppl making a fuss not realizing our bed is already made

Originally posted by Montana:
I mean, that is the competitor in him, wanting to make the big play and sometimes that can lead to losing the sight of, I guess.."the grey area" of things. Just take what's there. Like I said, he knows how to do that. He knows how to balance things out but sometimes, that competitor side can get the best of people's decisions. Sometimes, those gutsy, willed decisions can really work out, sometimes, yeah, it's hero ball. Just trying to do too much. Sometimes we don't need the dawg, we just need to make a completion to keep going down the field.

He did the same stuff in college and it was a reason his draft stock plummeted….

Everyone plays 2 high vs Mahomes and instead of him trying to force s**t downfield, he's taking what's there. Same thing with Allen and Burrow. The difference is they can make those crazy tight window throws deep IF that option is there. Brock's simply not that gifted as a thrower. Is what it is.

Brock has the 3rd highest time to throw right now, he's not getting rid of the ball. He's not processing quickly and making bad decisions because of it.

I love the dawg mindset and the gunslinger mentality….you gotta have that gun to make it work though and that's never gonna be a real thing for him.

He's gotta be a quick processing QB who throws super accurate balls. He's more of a rhythm passer that needs the scheme to make it all work (similar to Goff). He does have a little bit of an ability to scramble and extend plays when it's needed. It's never gonna be some special talent for him though.

Overall he's gotten away from whats worked and he's become inconsistent. s**t has to change.

Brock Purdy has shown from last year that he is terrible in less than perfect weather conditions.

Originally posted by NYniner85:

Originally posted by Montana:
I mean, that is the competitor in him, wanting to make the big play and sometimes that can lead to losing the sight of, I guess.."the grey area" of things. Just take what's there. Like I said, he knows how to do that. He knows how to balance things out but sometimes, that competitor side can get the best of people's decisions. Sometimes, those gutsy, willed decisions can really work out, sometimes, yeah, it's hero ball. Just trying to do too much. Sometimes we don't need the dawg, we just need to make a completion to keep going down the field.

He did the same stuff in college and it was a reason his draft stock plummeted….

Everyone plays 2 high vs Mahomes and instead of him trying to force s**t downfield, he's taking what's there. Same thing with Allen and Burrow. The difference is they can make those crazy tight window throws deep IF that option is there. Brock's simply not that gifted as a thrower. Is what it is.

Brock has the 3rd highest time to throw right now, he's not getting rid of the ball. He's not processing quickly and making bad decisions because of it.

I love the dawg mindset and the gunslinger mentality….you gotta have that gun to make it work though and that's never gonna be a real thing for him.

He's gotta be a quick processing QB who throws super accurate balls. He's more of a rhythm passer that needs the scheme to make it all work (similar to Goff). He does have a little bit of an ability to scramble and extend plays when it's needed. It's never gonna be some special talent for him though.

Overall he's gotten away from whats worked and he's become inconsistent. s**t has to change.

Agree with everything you sad and IMO a totally fair assessment. Most noticeable is the statement in bold.