QB Brock Purdy Thread

Originally posted by Kolohe:
So $40 million wouldn't be saying you're hitching your wagon, but $50 million is.....okay make sense.

WTF is going on here!!!!

I mean if it's a 5 yr deal that's an extra $50M and that can go a long way when talking about signing folks and GTD $.

I've said I think he's closer to Mayfield vs the elite level guys. Baker just got a 3yr $100M deal. I feel like that would make more sense, gives Brock generational wealth, gives SF opportunity to put talent around him and give both sides the opportunity to evaluate the future. He balls out he's can get an extension in two yrs…make a f**k ton more.

What's funny is we've made a Mayfield comparison but with Mayfield being slightly better due to him having that killer/come from behind skillset which some laughed at.

Well again Brock had a shot in the 4th to lead a drive/wun it and again couldn't get it done, throwing a pick to seal the game.

It's a pattern folks...and again I will have to make the Mayfield comp BUT Mayfield being better. Hopefully the front office pays him in the Mayfield terrority but less $$$.

Originally posted by JC_916:
What's funny is we've made a Mayfield comparison but with Mayfield being slightly better due to him having that killer/come from behind skillset which some laughed at.

Well again Brock had a shot in the 4th to lead a drive/wun it and again couldn't get it done, throwing a pick to seal the game.

It's a pattern folks...and again I will have to make the Mayfield comp BUT Mayfield being better. Hopefully the front office pays him in the Mayfield terrority but less $$$.

Mayfield also has a cannon vs Purdys pea shooter

Originally posted by ComeOnDeberg:
Brock Purdy has shown from last year that he is terrible in less than perfect weather conditions.

I was just thinking this. Once you factor that in he's definitely mid, maybe even lower.

Originally posted by D0PEMAN:

Originally posted by ComeOnDeberg:
Brock Purdy has shown from last year that he is terrible in less than perfect weather conditions.

I was just thinking this. Once you factor that in he's definitely mid, maybe even lower.

Of course. Imagine playing a SB where the weather just happens to be s**tty. Having Brock behind center would be a huge disadvantage. I don't want to go into games looking at the weather to decide our fate. The whole WEBZONE was posting weather forecasts pregame. That's telling

I really like Brock but it's good to be honest. He saved us from the Lance bust and is better than Garoppolo but I've seen multiple games where he can't put the team over THAT hump and this team needs someone that can.

The team can not and must not give him the bag!

I know it's unpopular but Shanahan needs to swallow some ego and bring in a humbled Rodgers for 1 year.

Brock is the best QB the Niners have had in years but that doesn't make him elite. In realirty he's not as talented physiically as Alex Smith who was handicapped by constant coaching cjanges and lack of weapons around him. He had some but nothing like what Brock has. JG had comparable results to Brock ut hwe all know what his limitations were. Plus he couldn't stay healthy. The 49ers got lucky when they took Brock in the 7th round but he's not a franchise QB.He's good and even very good at times. Unfortunatley he's about as good as this team will get unless they end up with a top 5 pick in a good QB draft or sign a free agent.

Originally posted by Phoenix49ers:

Originally posted by OnTheClock:

It was one of the most horrific decisions of the year. In one of the biggest moments, the guy choked. I'm really freaking tired of this.

He's trying to do too much. In college he got himself in trouble trying to play hero ball the same way. He had open receivers throughout the night that he passed over because he was locked on to someone else and was throwing into coverage too often.

I agree, and it's concerning that it's still a problem. He admitted he threw it without even knowing where Jennings was. I feel like Jimmy had a lot of success in close games here because he'd take the short options unless something was clearly open deep.

Jimmy would have a lot of WTF throws when he tried to scramble or was under pressure and didn't want to get hit. Brock is killing the team with greedy throws and he's done it all year. I hate to be that guy.. But it feels like it's just who he is, and it's starting to feel like it's not something we can fix. A better OL doesn't fix this issue.

I love all Purdy's attributes.. Except that one. But if this is how it's going to be, I don't think I can accept that as our franchise guy. His natural talent is not on the level of the top guys in this league. And when we need to hit certain plays, or protect the ball in tight games, a franchise QB can't continually let his team down there.

He did it twice against AZ. He did it against Seattle. He did it three times against KC. He did it again last night. At some point, if you don't f-----g learn from your mistakes, you need to be replaced. I'm still sour from the loss. I had a lot of belief in the kid, but I've lost a lot of faith in him. Not all of it, but a lot of it.

Originally posted by NYniner85:

Originally posted by Kolohe:
So $40 million wouldn't be saying you're hitching your wagon, but $50 million is.....okay make sense.

WTF is going on here!!!!

I mean if it's a 5 yr deal that's an extra $50M and that can go a long way when talking about signing folks and GTD $.

I've said I think he's closer to Mayfield vs the elite level guys. Baker just got a 3yr $100M deal. I feel like that would make more sense, gives Brock generational wealth, gives SF opportunity to put talent around him and give both sides the opportunity to evaluate the future. He balls out he's can get an extension in two yrs…make a f**k ton more.

Honestly, I'm not worried what they give Brock or how they do his contract. Paraag and John Lynch will always see to it that the team is protected. After all the money they gave Trent Williams, CMC and Aiyuk this off season they still have the best cap situation in the league. How about we worry about other things like getting an O-line fixed before the start of next season.

Originally posted by Kolohe:
Honestly, I'm not worried what they give Brock or how they do his contract. Paraag and John Lynch will always see to it that the team is protected. After all the money they gave Trent Williams, CMC and Aiyuk this off season they still have the best cap situation in the league. How about we worry about other things like getting an O-line fixed before the start of next season.

yup. coach and QB are set for next season. all about OL and weapons. get the dead weight off this roster, ahem.. deebo..

Originally posted by CatchMaster80:
Brock is the best QB the Niners have had in years but that doesn't make him elite. In realirty he's not as talented physiically as Alex Smith who was handicapped by constant coaching cjanges and lack of weapons around him. He had some but nothing like what Brock has. JG had comparable results to Brock ut hwe all know what his limitations were. Plus he couldn't stay healthy. The 49ers got lucky when they took Brock in the 7th round but he's not a franchise QB.He's good and even very good at times. Unfortunatley he's about as good as this team will get unless they end up with a top 5 pick in a good QB draft or sign a free agent.

he's not elite, but he's good enough to get your team to a SB, which is more than can be said for 30 other teams.

Fans seem to think if we dump Brock, the next Josh Allen is walking though the door. Even if we did have a top 5 pick, is Shadeur Sanders gonna get us back to overtime in the SB vs Mahomes?

Brock is a system QB. He's proven that with the right elements, we can lead the league in scoring with him, score 30+ a game, and go to a SB.
The challenge now is to get those elements in place.

Or we can keep dumping QB's until the next Josh Allen comes to save us, but we'll be waiting around for awhile.

Originally posted by Niner4ever:
I really like Brock but it's good to be honest. He saved us from the Lance bust and is better than Garoppolo but I've seen multiple games where he can't put the team over THAT hump and this team needs someone that can.

The team can not and must not give him the bag!

I know it's unpopular but Shanahan needs to swallow some ego and bring in a humbled Rodgers for 1 year.

Is that being honest? Jimmy G was more consistent here and while Lance just seems to be not an NFL player. He hasn't really played much since 2019. I have no idea if he could have put it together if he had started a full season. Rodgers is done. Father time comes for us all.

Originally posted by 49erFaithful6:

Originally posted by Kolohe:
Honestly, I'm not worried what they give Brock or how they do his contract. Paraag and John Lynch will always see to it that the team is protected. After all the money they gave Trent Williams, CMC and Aiyuk this off season they still have the best cap situation in the league. How about we worry about other things like getting an O-line fixed before the start of next season.

yup. coach and QB are set for next season. all about OL and weapons. get the dead weight off this roster, ahem.. deebo..

That's the problem. I know they can get creative with salaries but sooner or later that money needs to be paid. They can't keep trying to win with one high paid tackle and 4 scrubs. They need to get some real talent and they'll want to get paid. How long will it be before O linemen start asking for more since they're tasked with protecting these multi million dollar QBs. These players are just like everyone else they want to be treated fairly.

Originally posted by CatchMaster80:
That's the problem. I know they can get creative with salaries but sooner or later that money needs to be paid. They can't keep trying to win with one high paid tackle and 4 scrubs. They need to get some real talent and they'll want to get paid. How long will it be before O linemen start asking for more since they're tasked with protecting these multi million dollar QBs. These players are just like everyone else they want to be treated fairly.

shanny has to show his worth. if you look at rams, they have a paid QB veteran, and they drafted puka, verse, turner, fiske, williams, corum, avila and on it goes. draft is one thing, coaching the kids up to be studs is another. that's where a coach needs to earn the paycheck. it isn't just x's and o's it's talent development also.

Originally posted by 49erFaithful6:

Originally posted by CatchMaster80:
That's the problem. I know they can get creative with salaries but sooner or later that money needs to be paid. They can't keep trying to win with one high paid tackle and 4 scrubs. They need to get some real talent and they'll want to get paid. How long will it be before O linemen start asking for more since they're tasked with protecting these multi million dollar QBs. These players are just like everyone else they want to be treated fairly.

shanny has to show his worth. if you look at rams, they have a paid QB veteran, and they drafted puka, verse, turner, fiske, williams, corum, avila and on it goes. draft is one thing, coaching the kids up to be studs is another. that's where a coach needs to earn the paycheck. it isn't just x's and o's it's talent development also.

We did the same