QB Brock Purdy Thread

Originally posted by Jcool:

Originally posted by 49erFaithful6:

Originally posted by Overkill:
I'm out on giving this guy 60M. I accept it's probably going to happen, but I haven't seen enough to believe he can carry a team with that kind of cap hit. Even with the cap increasing, we're going to hit a wall somewhere. If he needs a solid supporting cast, which I believe he does, than we should pay him accordingly.

Purdy becoming the highest paid QB in the league may be inevitable since that's just how the league operates, though.

I'll be pulling for him on gameday regardless.

i'd pump breaks on him being highest paid for 2 reasons. 1 he ended up turning in a down year. that doesn't mean nothing. that means something and if the year is down, the deal should go down. 2, i don't know how much he could get on the open market. i don't know what team would just pony up $60m aav for this guy as QB1. i can't see any team doing that. i don't think teams would even want him as QB1. lot of QB1 jobs are filled, and those that aren't, teams want what they always want, those high end measurables. they would take a rook on a cost controlled deal over a guy with pick 262 traits at some absurd 60m aav. so we are probably the one team where brock is 'the man'.

I am sure it will be one those contracts that 90% of fans will see the headline of Brock Purdy signs 5 for 300M. Then 20 minutes later all the insides come out with 49ers can get out of this pretty cleanly after 3 years and 120M.

Originally posted by CatchMaster80:

Originally posted by Jason:

Brock will get 60+ in the offseason. He will not take nor will they offer him less. The second contract isn't based as much on what has been done on the rookie contract (though that has been nothing short of spectacular), it's based on potential.

It has nothing to do with potential. It's all about whether or not to pay him like a top 5 QB. The market has completely gone crazy and there's no reason he should be paid the highest amount in the NFL. NFL owners and the payers have lost their minds.

Originally posted by NYniner85:

Originally posted by 49erFaithful6:
shanny will pay brock what he seeks he's not playing hardball and finding a new QB1 8 years into his build. last time shanny got aggressive on QB1 he burned 3 ones on 4 starts.

No one said he needs to find anything right now. Brock isn't a FA. He can play out his deal then renegotiate or get tagged.

Paying someone stupid money just cause is no different then giving away a bunch of 1sts and only playing him in a couple random games

Originally posted by LasVegasWally:

Originally posted by NYniner85:

Originally posted by 49erFaithful6:
shanny will pay brock what he seeks he's not playing hardball and finding a new QB1 8 years into his build. last time shanny got aggressive on QB1 he burned 3 ones on 4 starts.

No one said he needs to find anything right now. Brock isn't a FA. He can play out his deal then renegotiate or get tagged.

Paying someone stupid money just cause is no different then giving away a bunch of 1sts and only playing him in a couple random games

Very good post NY!

Originally posted by 49erFaithful6:

Originally posted by LasVegasWally:

Originally posted by NYniner85:

Originally posted by 49erFaithful6:
shanny will pay brock what he seeks he's not playing hardball and finding a new QB1 8 years into his build. last time shanny got aggressive on QB1 he burned 3 ones on 4 starts.

No one said he needs to find anything right now. Brock isn't a FA. He can play out his deal then renegotiate or get tagged.

Paying someone stupid money just cause is no different then giving away a bunch of 1sts and only playing him in a couple random games

Very good post NY!

just not understanding of reality imo. didn't we pay BA after 3, nick after 3, deebo after 3 and on it goes? so on QB1, who makes nothing, we're just gonna tell him to shut up and like it? hard to see that.. i mean that may be what NY wants, but is it what will go down?

Originally posted by Furlow:

Originally posted by 49erFaithful6:

Originally posted by LasVegasWally:

Originally posted by NYniner85:

Originally posted by 49erFaithful6:
shanny will pay brock what he seeks he's not playing hardball and finding a new QB1 8 years into his build. last time shanny got aggressive on QB1 he burned 3 ones on 4 starts.

No one said he needs to find anything right now. Brock isn't a FA. He can play out his deal then renegotiate or get tagged.

Paying someone stupid money just cause is no different then giving away a bunch of 1sts and only playing him in a couple random games

Very good post NY!

just not understanding of reality imo. didn't we pay BA after 3, nick after 3, deebo after 3 and on it goes? so on QB1, who makes nothing, we're just gonna tell him to shut up and like it? hard to see that.. i mean that may be what NY wants, but is it what will go down?

NY is out of his mind with this "play out your contract" nonsense. That only works with fringe players, which clearly Purdy is not. He is absolutely not going to play out a lame duck year on this whack rookie contract and risk injury, nor will Kyle/Lynch even hint at that. Absurd discussion.

Originally posted by NYniner85:

Originally posted by DrEll:
The two times Kyle got "aggressive" with QB1 they ended up being losers (Jimmy, Trey). Maybe Shanahan should take the back seat on this one. Clearly he's not the best talent evaluator when it comes to quarterbacks so if he goes to Lynch / Jed and tells them to pay the man what he wants there's a good chance he screws us again.

my personal opinion is Kyle's stint in SF is about to end. Either he does it himself after this season (goes on a major bender, decides to call it quits so he can enter rehab), OR he does it the hard way by sinking this team in 2025 with his idiotic decisions / game plans. In any case, don't want his stench on this team beyond that so if we end up having to keep Brock at max contract at 60m and he's not worth it, then no thanks. Pay him what he's worth. If he's playing hardball like idiots eg BA, TW then either make him finish his contract next year or trade him…

Put your bias aside and realize Kyle isn't going anywhere. Time to move off that silly debate. Talk about something else, maybe something that's realistic.

Also the moment Brock is paid it all but solidifies Kyle being here even longer. You're gonna have to deal with it.

Originally posted by DrEll:

Originally posted by NYniner85:

Originally posted by DrEll:
The two times Kyle got "aggressive" with QB1 they ended up being losers (Jimmy, Trey). Maybe Shanahan should take the back seat on this one. Clearly he's not the best talent evaluator when it comes to quarterbacks so if he goes to Lynch / Jed and tells them to pay the man what he wants there's a good chance he screws us again.

my personal opinion is Kyle's stint in SF is about to end. Either he does it himself after this season (goes on a major bender, decides to call it quits so he can enter rehab), OR he does it the hard way by sinking this team in 2025 with his idiotic decisions / game plans. In any case, don't want his stench on this team beyond that so if we end up having to keep Brock at max contract at 60m and he's not worth it, then no thanks. Pay him what he's worth. If he's playing hardball like idiots eg BA, TW then either make him finish his contract next year or trade him…

Put your bias aside and realize Kyle isn't going anywhere. Time to move off that silly debate. Talk about something else, maybe something that's realistic.

Also the moment Brock is paid it all but solidifies Kyle being here even longer. You're gonna have to deal with it.

If next year we don't make the playoffs, ain't no amount of excuses from you guys (injuries, refs, bad weather) that's gonna protect him. I suspect he'll be fired, or even better do us a favor and just pull a Campbell and leave….

you're just convinced that next year we'll be a juggernaut once again because magically the team will be 100% uninjured. That's just not going to be the case…

Originally posted by 49AllTheTime:
Idgaf what we pay him, just do your job

Originally posted by DrEll:

Originally posted by NYniner85:

Originally posted by DrEll:
The two times Kyle got "aggressive" with QB1 they ended up being losers (Jimmy, Trey). Maybe Shanahan should take the back seat on this one. Clearly he's not the best talent evaluator when it comes to quarterbacks so if he goes to Lynch / Jed and tells them to pay the man what he wants there's a good chance he screws us again.

my personal opinion is Kyle's stint in SF is about to end. Either he does it himself after this season (goes on a major bender, decides to call it quits so he can enter rehab), OR he does it the hard way by sinking this team in 2025 with his idiotic decisions / game plans. In any case, don't want his stench on this team beyond that so if we end up having to keep Brock at max contract at 60m and he's not worth it, then no thanks. Pay him what he's worth. If he's playing hardball like idiots eg BA, TW then either make him finish his contract next year or trade him…

Put your bias aside and realize Kyle isn't going anywhere. Time to move off that silly debate. Talk about something else, maybe something that's realistic.

Also the moment Brock is paid it all but solidifies Kyle being here even longer. You're gonna have to deal with it.

If next year we don't make the playoffs, ain't no amount of excuses from you guys (injuries, refs, bad weather) that's gonna protect him. I suspect he'll be fired, or even better do us a favor and just pull a Campbell and leave….

you're just convinced that next year we'll be a juggernaut once again because magically the team will be 100% uninjured. That's just not going to be the case…

Originally posted by DrEll:

Originally posted by NYniner85:

Originally posted by DrEll:
The two times Kyle got "aggressive" with QB1 they ended up being losers (Jimmy, Trey). Maybe Shanahan should take the back seat on this one. Clearly he's not the best talent evaluator when it comes to quarterbacks so if he goes to Lynch / Jed and tells them to pay the man what he wants there's a good chance he screws us again.

my personal opinion is Kyle's stint in SF is about to end. Either he does it himself after this season (goes on a major bender, decides to call it quits so he can enter rehab), OR he does it the hard way by sinking this team in 2025 with his idiotic decisions / game plans. In any case, don't want his stench on this team beyond that so if we end up having to keep Brock at max contract at 60m and he's not worth it, then no thanks. Pay him what he's worth. If he's playing hardball like idiots eg BA, TW then either make him finish his contract next year or trade him…

Put your bias aside and realize Kyle isn't going anywhere. Time to move off that silly debate. Talk about something else, maybe something that's realistic.

Also the moment Brock is paid it all but solidifies Kyle being here even longer. You're gonna have to deal with it.

If next year we don't make the playoffs, ain't no amount of excuses from you guys (injuries, refs, bad weather) that's gonna protect him. I suspect he'll be fired, or even better do us a favor and just pull a Campbell and leave….

you're just convinced that next year we'll be a juggernaut once again because magically the team will be 100% uninjured. That's just not going to be the case…

Originally posted by Furlow:

Originally posted by 49erFaithful6:

Originally posted by LasVegasWally:

Originally posted by NYniner85:

Originally posted by 49erFaithful6:
shanny will pay brock what he seeks he's not playing hardball and finding a new QB1 8 years into his build. last time shanny got aggressive on QB1 he burned 3 ones on 4 starts.

No one said he needs to find anything right now. Brock isn't a FA. He can play out his deal then renegotiate or get tagged.

Paying someone stupid money just cause is no different then giving away a bunch of 1sts and only playing him in a couple random games

Very good post NY!

just not understanding of reality imo. didn't we pay BA after 3, nick after 3, deebo after 3 and on it goes? so on QB1, who makes nothing, we're just gonna tell him to shut up and like it? hard to see that.. i mean that may be what NY wants, but is it what will go down?

NY is out of his mind with this "play out your contract" nonsense. That only works with fringe players, which clearly Purdy is not. He is absolutely not going to play out a lame duck year on this whack rookie contract and risk injury, nor will Kyle/Lynch even hint at that. Absurd discussion.

Originally posted by Afrikan:
Oh yes he will.

He is not going to take the chance of another QB coming in here to take advantage of all these weapons and this QB friendly offensive system. Be it another QB draft pick (that has similar intangibles to Brock), or a surprise released QB FA, or a QB already on this team.

THAT is how Brock got to be the starter, and in the position he is in today. Took full advantage of being the QB of this stacked offense and showed how the offense can/should look.