QB Brock Purdy Thread

Originally posted by mayo49:
Letting him ride out the last year of his contract might not be the worst thing. He's going to get his bag from someone, the question for the Niners is, is this the best we can do for the money?

Who's lining up to pay Brock $250M? I disagree he would get his bag from someone else. We all know SF is gonna pay him this off season …the question I've brought up multiple times is, what if SF says to Brock to find a trade partner to give up the typical FQB compensation (couple 1sts) just to have the rights to pay you want you want (like we did with BA). I'll bet money there would be zero takers there.

Originally posted by NYniner85:

Originally posted by mayo49:
Letting him ride out the last year of his contract might not be the worst thing. He's going to get his bag from someone, the question for the Niners is, is this the best we can do for the money?

Who's lining up to pay Brock $250M? I disagree he would get his bag from someone else. We all know SF is gonna pay him this off season …the question I've brought up multiple times is, what if SF says to Brock to find a trade partner to give up the typical FQB compensation (couple 1sts) just to have the rights to pay you want you want (like we did with BA). I'll bet money there would be zero takers there.

On the open market he gets a 3 year 100M contract with an out after a year.

Originally posted by Jcool:

Originally posted by NYniner85:

Originally posted by mayo49:
Letting him ride out the last year of his contract might not be the worst thing. He's going to get his bag from someone, the question for the Niners is, is this the best we can do for the money?

Who's lining up to pay Brock $250M? I disagree he would get his bag from someone else. We all know SF is gonna pay him this off season …the question I've brought up multiple times is, what if SF says to Brock to find a trade partner to give up the typical FQB compensation (couple 1sts) just to have the rights to pay you want you want (like we did with BA). I'll bet money there would be zero takers there.

On the open market he gets a 3 year 100M contract with an out after a year.

I agree it would be something similar to what Baker got. Why does SF have to give him twice as much? That ain't his market and if SF wanted to be prove it they could go that route. I highly doubt they do that.

Originally posted by NYniner85:

Originally posted by Jcool:

Originally posted by NYniner85:

Originally posted by mayo49:
Letting him ride out the last year of his contract might not be the worst thing. He's going to get his bag from someone, the question for the Niners is, is this the best we can do for the money?

Who's lining up to pay Brock $250M? I disagree he would get his bag from someone else. We all know SF is gonna pay him this off season …the question I've brought up multiple times is, what if SF says to Brock to find a trade partner to give up the typical FQB compensation (couple 1sts) just to have the rights to pay you want you want (like we did with BA). I'll bet money there would be zero takers there.

On the open market he gets a 3 year 100M contract with an out after a year.

I agree it would be something similar to what Baker got. Why does SF have to give him twice as much? That ain't his market and if SF wanted to be prove it they could go that route. I highly doubt they do that.

It just depends on high highly they think of Brock. This year it's been exposed that he struggles in the wind and rain. We'll it's windy and rainy a lot in the fall and winter and a lot in San Francisco. So, that's something that has to be weighed in the whole thing. I know they like him, but do they love him enough to give him what he thinks his bag should be?

Originally posted by Yeti:

Originally posted by communist:
He would. Way too many teams in desperation at qb

I think he would go the Darnold, Mayfield, etc route. He would pick up a 1 or 2 year prove it deal, maybe even a backup deal.

That he was too good for. Darnold never been good, Purdy at least was awesome the last two years. Even this year he showed he is capable of being a solid starter but he simply is not a franchise qb, way too stupid for that.

Originally posted by communist:

Originally posted by Yeti:

Originally posted by communist:
He would. Way too many teams in desperation at qb

I think he would go the Darnold, Mayfield, etc route. He would pick up a 1 or 2 year prove it deal, maybe even a backup deal.

That he was too good for. Darnold never been good, Purdy at least was awesome the last two years. Even this year he showed he is capable of being a solid starter but he simply is not a franchise qb, way too stupid for that.

Communist brings up a good question. Is Brock a solid qb or is he elite? That's what they have to decide. He's going to get his bag, the question for the Niners is, are we satisified or do we explore for something better.

Originally posted by mayo49:
It just depends on high highly they think of Brock. This year it's been exposed that he struggles in the wind and rain. We'll it's windy and rainy a lot in the fall and winter and a lot in San Francisco. So, that's something that has to be weighed in the whole thing. I know they like him, but do they love him enough to give him what he thinks his bag should be?

He's gonna get paid and should. He shouldn't be demanding Dak cash. I hope they can agree on something that can help the team put good players around him and he can still get paid….theres gotta be some middle ground there.

Purdy is not elite . . . he need to take less money to keep star players around him IF he wants to win it all and go down in 49er history as a well to do QB. If not, he'll join the ranks of mediocrity that seems to be 49er QB's of late. He'll get paid, the question is should he get top tier money for being elite or is he just solid? He is just solid . . . functional or serviceable is a better word. Give him a contract that reflects that and allows us to keep other players around him which he needs. Hopefully he sees that . . .

Originally posted by NYniner85:

Originally posted by mayo49:
It just depends on high highly they think of Brock. This year it's been exposed that he struggles in the wind and rain. We'll it's windy and rainy a lot in the fall and winter and a lot in San Francisco. So, that's something that has to be weighed in the whole thing. I know they like him, but do they love him enough to give him what he thinks his bag should be?

He's gonna get paid and should. He shouldn't be demanding Dak cash. I hope they can agree on something that can help the team put good players around him and he can still get paid….theres gotta be some middle ground there.

Yep, I think they come to a common ground. Brock is at a good place, he knows that. He won't ask for an amount that's going to keep the team and him, from being competitive.

Originally posted by AJinUT:
Purdy is not elite . . . he need to take less money to keep star players around him IF he wants to win it all and go down in 49er history as a well to do QB. If not, he'll join the ranks of mediocrity that seems to be 49er QB's of late. He'll get paid, the question is should he get top tier money for being elite or is he just solid? He is just solid . . . functional or serviceable is a better word. Give him a contract that reflects that and allows us to keep other players around him which he needs. Hopefully he sees that . . .

Solid or elite, he's going to get paid by what the market bears.

Originally posted by mayo49:

Originally posted by NYniner85:

Originally posted by mayo49:
It just depends on high highly they think of Brock. This year it's been exposed that he struggles in the wind and rain. We'll it's windy and rainy a lot in the fall and winter and a lot in San Francisco. So, that's something that has to be weighed in the whole thing. I know they like him, but do they love him enough to give him what he thinks his bag should be?

He's gonna get paid and should. He shouldn't be demanding Dak cash. I hope they can agree on something that can help the team put good players around him and he can still get paid….theres gotta be some middle ground there.

Yep, I think they come to a common ground. Brock is at a good place, he knows that. He won't ask for an amount that's going to keep the team and him, from being competitive.

I mean we will see…money and agents change s**t.

Originally posted by mayo49:
Solid or elite, he's going to get paid by what the market bears.

If SF let the market dictate his worth, he would be in for a rude awakening imo

Originally posted by NYniner85:

Originally posted by mayo49:
Solid or elite, he's going to get paid by what the market bears.

If SF let the market dictate his worth, he would be in for a rude awakening imo

That won't happen with Shanahan. I wonder how badly a new HC would want him, and what percent of his cap he'd be willing to pay for him. Or would he just tell Lynch to draft somebody.

If you don't want to pay Brock, I suggest the most likely route is to change the head coach. Brock has a prove it year left on his contract.

Originally posted by NYniner85:

Originally posted by mayo49:
Letting him ride out the last year of his contract might not be the worst thing. He's going to get his bag from someone, the question for the Niners is, is this the best we can do for the money?

Who's lining up to pay Brock $250M? I disagree he would get his bag from someone else. We all know SF is gonna pay him this off season …the question I've brought up multiple times is, what if SF says to Brock to find a trade partner to give up the typical FQB compensation (couple 1sts) just to have the rights to pay you want you want (like we did with BA). I'll bet money there would be zero takers there.

The problem with this scenario is the team giving up assets then having to pay him. That would be the biggest reason why there would be zero takers.

Then there is the issue with what others teams that could be in the market are committing to their current QB situation.

On the open Market Brock would get north of 50 million.

Originally posted by NYniner85:

Originally posted by mayo49:
Solid or elite, he's going to get paid by what the market bears.

If SF let the market dictate his worth, he would be in for a rude awakening imo

They've made good decisions (Brock) and bad (Lance). Let's hope for the best.