There are 191 users in the forums

QB Brock Purdy Thread

Shop Find 49ers gear online

QB Brock Purdy Thread

Dec 30, 2024 at 9:38 PM
  • Kolohe
  • Hall of Fame
  • Posts: 62,732
Originally posted by mv49erfan:
Originally posted by Darkness49ers:
Originally posted by mv49erfan:
It's easy to overreact to the interceptions. Purdy played a really good game, sailed a pass on the first pick and got the 2nd pick jumped. 2 mistakes. You know what didn't help? Kyle Shanahan calling TWO run plays in the entire 2nd half. TWO. T-W-O… and we were up 8 at half. Wtf is up with that? Maybe he doesn't throw those picks if the defense didn't know we were throwing 100%. We were not in any position where running the ball was out of question. No s**t he balled out in the first half… we were so balanced and had an effective run game with play action. Everybody chill tf out… He's still our guy.

Yes 2 mistakes that cost them the game.

Easy to put all the blame on the qb. Not forcing one single punt and giving up 40 points cost us the game. Jake moody leaving 7 total points out there didn't help. Kyle abandoning the run game cost us the game. Purdy deserves his share of the blame but wake up. We gave up 40 points.

Kyle also abandoning his misdirection and screen plays didn't help either.
Dec 30, 2024 at 9:38 PM
Originally posted by pd24:
Originally posted by _Goldblooded_:
Originally posted by pd24:
You can't rule out a UCL without an MRI. Pitchers pass tests all the time without an MRI then try and pitch the next game or after an IL stint and can't, then the MRI shows them a tear.

Even a small tear can cause discomfort are require surgery. A UCL injury isn't all torn or nothing.

He wouldn't be getting an MRI on his elbow for any other ligament or nerve. Lol

And he is getting an MRI tomorrow

With his history the bar for an elbow mri is low

Also you can't rule out anl UCL injury without an MRI. They don't think it is a UCL, but don't know. Hence the MRI


Really hope he is ok or it is going to be a very long offseason
Dec 30, 2024 at 9:40 PM
  • okdkid
  • Veteran
  • Posts: 23,258
Originally posted by Darkness49ers:
Originally posted by mv49erfan:
It's easy to overreact to the interceptions. Purdy played a really good game, sailed a pass on the first pick and got the 2nd pick jumped. 2 mistakes. You know what didn't help? Kyle Shanahan calling TWO run plays in the entire 2nd half. TWO. T-W-O… and we were up 8 at half. Wtf is up with that? Maybe he doesn't throw those picks if the defense didn't know we were throwing 100%. We were not in any position where running the ball was out of question. No s**t he balled out in the first half… we were so balanced and had an effective run game with play action. Everybody chill tf out… He's still our guy.

Yes 2 mistakes that cost them the game.

Defense did nothing. No stops. No punts. No turnovers. But he cost them the game? 3 passing TDs, 1 elite rushing TD, nearly 400 yards. Even with two picks that should be enough. Purdy has to be perfect every game. He can't do it by himself every week. He was doing it by himself for three quarters. Would be nice if the defense showed up.
[ Edited by okdkid on Dec 30, 2024 at 9:41 PM ]
Dec 30, 2024 at 9:42 PM
Originally posted by mv49erfan:
It's easy to overreact to the interceptions. Purdy played a really good game, sailed a pass on the first pick and got the 2nd pick jumped. 2 mistakes. You know what didn't help? Kyle Shanahan calling TWO run plays in the entire 2nd half. TWO. T-W-O… and we were up 8 at half. Wtf is up with that? Maybe he doesn't throw those picks if the defense didn't know we were throwing 100%. We were not in any position where running the ball was out of question. No s**t he balled out in the first half… we were so balanced and had an effective run game with play action. Everybody chill tf out… He's still our guy.

Those INT's are on the QB 💯. Could there have been more balance? Sure, but Shanahan didn't force those bad throws.
Dec 30, 2024 at 9:43 PM
Originally posted by swoosh6996:
Those INT's are on the QB 💯. Could there have been more balance? Sure, but Shanahan didn't force those bad throws.

Down and distance matters as well. Some of this simply boils down to being upset we didn't run on first down in spots.
Dec 30, 2024 at 9:44 PM
Originally posted by Kolohe:
Originally posted by Darkness49ers:
Originally posted by mv49erfan:
It's easy to overreact to the interceptions. Purdy played a really good game, sailed a pass on the first pick and got the 2nd pick jumped. 2 mistakes. You know what didn't help? Kyle Shanahan calling TWO run plays in the entire 2nd half. TWO. T-W-O… and we were up 8 at half. Wtf is up with that? Maybe he doesn't throw those picks if the defense didn't know we were throwing 100%. We were not in any position where running the ball was out of question. No s**t he balled out in the first half… we were so balanced and had an effective run game with play action. Everybody chill tf out… He's still our guy.

Yes 2 mistakes that cost them the game.

I'd say it help cost the game but didn't cost the game. The defense still has to stop them from scoring, it's not like Brock Purdy threw two pick-sixes.

We'll have to see but Aikman said they rolled out of the single high and made him a robber. Brock stare down and he read it whole way
Dec 30, 2024 at 9:45 PM
Originally posted by _Goldblooded_:
Originally posted by pd24:
You can't rule out a UCL without an MRI. Pitchers pass tests all the time without an MRI then try and pitch the next game or after an IL stint and can't, then the MRI shows them a tear.

Even a small tear can cause discomfort are require surgery. A UCL injury isn't all torn or nothing.

He wouldn't be getting an MRI on his elbow for any other ligament or nerve. Lol

And he is getting an MRI tomorrow

With his history the bar for an elbow mri is low

I'm hoping that internal brace that's still in there kept things together from tearing again.
Dec 30, 2024 at 9:45 PM
  • pd24
  • Veteran
  • Posts: 9,127
Originally posted by SmokeyJoe:
Originally posted by swoosh6996:
Those INT's are on the QB 💯. Could there have been more balance? Sure, but Shanahan didn't force those bad throws.

Down and distance matters as well. Some of this simply boils down to being upset we didn't run on first down in spots.

The 1st one wasn't a down and distance, he just air mailed it over the WR.

I didn't see the 2nd one, but I believe it was a 1st or second down in DET territory
Dec 30, 2024 at 9:47 PM
Originally posted by pd24:
The 1st one wasn't a down and distance, he just air mailed it over the WR.

I didn't see the 2nd one, but I believe it was a 1st or second down in DET territory

Im referencing the run/pass split, not Brock's ints.
Dec 30, 2024 at 9:47 PM
Originally posted by okdkid:
Originally posted by Darkness49ers:
Originally posted by mv49erfan:
It's easy to overreact to the interceptions. Purdy played a really good game, sailed a pass on the first pick and got the 2nd pick jumped. 2 mistakes. You know what didn't help? Kyle Shanahan calling TWO run plays in the entire 2nd half. TWO. T-W-O… and we were up 8 at half. Wtf is up with that? Maybe he doesn't throw those picks if the defense didn't know we were throwing 100%. We were not in any position where running the ball was out of question. No s**t he balled out in the first half… we were so balanced and had an effective run game with play action. Everybody chill tf out… He's still our guy.

Yes 2 mistakes that cost them the game.

Defense did nothing. No stops. No punts. No turnovers. But he cost them the game? 3 passing TDs, 1 elite rushing TD, nearly 400 yards. Even with two picks that should be enough. Purdy has to be perfect every game. He can't do it by himself every week. He was doing it by himself for three quarters. Would be nice if the defense showed up.

We knew the defense was going to struggle. Purdy throwing back breaking INT's, especially with the chance to go up 2 scores, is ultimately what cost the game. He's got to cut down on the bad throws. He's had too many this season.
Dec 30, 2024 at 9:48 PM
Originally posted by SmokeyJoe:
Originally posted by swoosh6996:
Those INT's are on the QB 💯. Could there have been more balance? Sure, but Shanahan didn't force those bad throws.

Down and distance matters as well. Some of this simply boils down to being upset we didn't run on first down in spots.

Completely abandoning the run game is setting your qb up for failure. Deebo and guerendo collectively averaged 4.5 ypc. The lions kept running the entire game, even when they were down. We had 18 carries to their 33. And the game was 1 score for basically all 60 mins. When the defense knows what you're doing, it makes it that much harder to operate offensively. It's a shame Purdy is going to face the brunt of this when Kyle left him out to dry. And I love Kyle.
Dec 30, 2024 at 9:50 PM
Originally posted by Kolohe:
Originally posted by mv49erfan:
Originally posted by Darkness49ers:
Originally posted by mv49erfan:
It's easy to overreact to the interceptions. Purdy played a really good game, sailed a pass on the first pick and got the 2nd pick jumped. 2 mistakes. You know what didn't help? Kyle Shanahan calling TWO run plays in the entire 2nd half. TWO. T-W-O… and we were up 8 at half. Wtf is up with that? Maybe he doesn't throw those picks if the defense didn't know we were throwing 100%. We were not in any position where running the ball was out of question. No s**t he balled out in the first half… we were so balanced and had an effective run game with play action. Everybody chill tf out… He's still our guy.

Yes 2 mistakes that cost them the game.

Easy to put all the blame on the qb. Not forcing one single punt and giving up 40 points cost us the game. Jake moody leaving 7 total points out there didn't help. Kyle abandoning the run game cost us the game. Purdy deserves his share of the blame but wake up. We gave up 40 points.

Kyle also abandoning his misdirection and screen plays didn't help either.

As is typical, football is the most complimentary team sport there is. Yes, all of those above factored into the outcome. If just about any one was different, the outcome could have been different.
Dec 30, 2024 at 9:50 PM
Originally posted by pd24:
The 1st one wasn't a down and distance, he just air mailed it over the WR.

I didn't see the 2nd one, but I believe it was a 1st or second down in DET territory

the 2nd is a classic brock problem or red flag. he's lobbing with anticipation into what he feels is open space. he floats it out there, it give the D time to react as it's in the air. so he plays fast mentally yet the pass is slow, lobbed, or floated. also they are gonna pack that middle if that's his heat map of where he throws. i recall a lot oh jimmy likes the middle, well now brock does. what is up with that?
Dec 30, 2024 at 9:50 PM
  • pd24
  • Veteran
  • Posts: 9,127
Originally posted by SmokeyJoe:
Originally posted by pd24:
The 1st one wasn't a down and distance, he just air mailed it over the WR.

I didn't see the 2nd one, but I believe it was a 1st or second down in DET territory

Im referencing the run/pass split, not Brock's ints.

Ohh. Agree with that. The 1st 2 TD drives was something I wanted us to do all season and dominate teams playing bully ball. Then we went away from it.
Dec 30, 2024 at 9:51 PM
Originally posted by okdkid:
Originally posted by Darkness49ers:
Originally posted by mv49erfan:
It's easy to overreact to the interceptions. Purdy played a really good game, sailed a pass on the first pick and got the 2nd pick jumped. 2 mistakes. You know what didn't help? Kyle Shanahan calling TWO run plays in the entire 2nd half. TWO. T-W-O… and we were up 8 at half. Wtf is up with that? Maybe he doesn't throw those picks if the defense didn't know we were throwing 100%. We were not in any position where running the ball was out of question. No s**t he balled out in the first half… we were so balanced and had an effective run game with play action. Everybody chill tf out… He's still our guy.

Yes 2 mistakes that cost them the game.

Defense did nothing. No stops. No punts. No turnovers. But he cost them the game? 3 passing TDs, 1 elite rushing TD, nearly 400 yards. Even with two picks that should be enough. Purdy has to be perfect every game. He can't do it by himself every week. He was doing it by himself for three quarters. Would be nice if the defense showed up.

Defense stopped them on 4th down? Defense held them to a FG on two drives. Our defense was doing better than theirs until the picks started. Those picks changed the momentum and we never recovered.
Search
YouTube
Flipboard
Threads
✕
Search Share 49ersWebzone