QB Brock Purdy Thread

Originally posted by mayo49:

Originally posted by TD49ers:

Originally posted by NYniner85:

Originally posted by TD49ers:

Originally posted by NYniner85:
I mean objectively we should all agree he's better than Jimmy.

He's a solid starting QB in the NFL imo. he's gonna be massively overpaid and that's the problem.

You always advocate players maximizing their market value without repercussions......you were never concerned about overpaying players.....like BA...

SF let the market decide what BA's worth is…why can't they do the same with Brock?

tell me a team that's gonna give up top end draft capital and pay Brock $250M? None that's who. BA had multiple teams lining up to do that.

End of the day, it doesnt matter the how. So long as the players maximize their pay cheque, right? Food on the table.
Market of 5 or 1 is irrelevant. The impact is the same. Purdy clearly deserves it......

He's proven it already, Championship game and Super Bowl.

Purdy deserves it more than BA and Deebo that's for sure and he has more leverage since he is QB. Now do I want to give him 60 mill....no.

Originally posted by TD49ers:

Originally posted by mayo49:

Originally posted by TD49ers:

Originally posted by NYniner85:

Originally posted by TD49ers:

Originally posted by NYniner85:
I mean objectively we should all agree he's better than Jimmy.

He's a solid starting QB in the NFL imo. he's gonna be massively overpaid and that's the problem.

You always advocate players maximizing their market value without repercussions......you were never concerned about overpaying players.....like BA...

SF let the market decide what BA's worth is…why can't they do the same with Brock?

tell me a team that's gonna give up top end draft capital and pay Brock $250M? None that's who. BA had multiple teams lining up to do that.

End of the day, it doesnt matter the how. So long as the players maximize their pay cheque, right? Food on the table.
Market of 5 or 1 is irrelevant. The impact is the same. Purdy clearly deserves it......

He's proven it already, Championship game and Super Bowl.

Purdy deserves it more than BA and Deebo that's for sure and he has more leverage since he is QB. Now do I want to give him 60 mill....no.

It's the entertainment business; you'd be surprised what someone would pay to be the Show and everything that comes with it. Get it.

Championship in next 3 years. Keep the faith. Go, Niners, go!

Originally posted by Strwy2Hevn:

Originally posted by mayo49:

Originally posted by Strwy2Hevn:

Originally posted by mayo49:

Originally posted by Strwy2Hevn:
Let him test the market...

Like someone mentioned, with good offseason and a weak schedule, he'll tear it up next year.

Not if we go into his contract negotiations as dumb as the fans want us too.

Hate the game not the player.

I don't hate either one. Just the dumbass fans.

This 👆🏻. 👏🏻

Originally posted by mayo49:
Championship in next 3 years. Keep the faith. Go, Niners, go!

I like your optimism but I just can't see it. Hope I'm wrong

Originally posted by RJ_MacReady:

Originally posted by Strwy2Hevn:

Originally posted by mayo49:

Originally posted by Strwy2Hevn:

Originally posted by mayo49:

Originally posted by Strwy2Hevn:
Let him test the market...

Like someone mentioned, with good offseason and a weak schedule, he'll tear it up next year.

Not if we go into his contract negotiations as dumb as the fans want us too.

Hate the game not the player.

I don't hate either one. Just the dumbass fans.

This 👆🏻. 👏🏻

Got to love the spectators, we all want to be the players.

Originally posted by RJ_MacReady:

Originally posted by mayo49:
Championship in next 3 years. Keep the faith. Go, Niners, go!

I like your optimism but I just can't see it. Hope I'm wrong

I don't know, maybe just talking s**t. Can't lose hope. Tomorrow, tomorrow your only a day a way, lol.

Originally posted by NYniner85:
At least show the whole play lol. Dude threw the ball 15 yards behind the LOS to avoid pressure. Threw it at least 60 yards.

Refs did not cost the 49ers this game, but Nick Bosa was held on that key 3rd and 15 bomb from Pat Mahomes to Tyreek Hill pic.twitter.com/cltYi7SdGy

— Kevin Jones (@Mr_KevinJones) February 3, 2020

he can and does avoid pressure to let everyone get open. He doesn't need 5 steps to throw it 60 yards. Thats GOD GIVEN ability and you sound like a sour puss because of it.

Trying to come in here pretending to be an expert while poo pooing Mahomes is a good way to get laughed out of here. I'm almost ready to mute, because you offer nothing of value.

the whole no one uses C2 vs him is complete nonsense and trying to say that's not a thing only makes your debates more silly.

happy new year

It does not take elite ability to throw a fly ball 59 yards to centerfield for a receiver open by a country mile to camp out for. Yes, Brock Purdy couldn't throw it that far, but many QBs in the modern game could. That ball could have even been thrown 5 yards shorter and still been complete.

Brock avoids pressure to let guys get open too. That's not unusual in modern football. Traditional QB play isn't a thing anymore. The game is unrecognizable. It's been dumbed down so that dumb QBs can succeed. Modern football teams run college schemes.

We used to have a word for QBs like the guys people think are elite these days. They were called, "busts." Nearly every "physical tools" guy busted every year for decades.

They couldn't handle the complexity of offensive schemes.

That's out the window, and fans go nuts every time they see a QB run around like an idiot and chuck some laser that would've been picked off or gotten a receiver crushed 20 years ago.

The Queefs worship on here is ridiculous. Do you think 49ers fans in the 90s used to give all this undeserved reverence to the COWBOYS? I can tell you for a fact, it was the exact opposite.

49ers fans would say Emmitt Smith was a product of his offensive line, and Michael Irvin pushed off all the time, and Troy Aikman was a product of both of them, even though they just disregarded both of them.

But now 49ers fans can't even question the supposed "greatness" of a QB who ranks 33rd in air yards per completion in a league of 32 starting QBs, and who was outplayed by the opposing QB in every SB he has played?

As for your other posts about 2 high vs. Stat Paddy: Simple watching of the games shows otherwise. Articles written by dorks who don't understand football are meaningless.

Originally posted by bud49:
I was listening to sports talk the other morning and they gave a couple examples of teams that gave market value to QB's and are still able to have a good team. Lamar Jackson, Jalen Hurts etc. I think if the organization is good at the top they can cope and deal with the cap in a way where the team can still be competitive.

Its a b******t excuse. If you draft well, you can continue to put a good team around a QB you just have to be more forward thinking and decisive on who you keep and let go.

Originally posted by TD49ers:
End of the day, it doesnt matter the how. So long as the players maximize their pay cheque, right? Food on the table.
Market of 5 or 1 is irrelevant. The impact is the same. Purdy clearly deserves it......

You think a 7th rd pick who's been making $900k hasn't maximized his situation lol?

the market is now irrelevant lol? You were b***hing about BA all off season and the market said he's worth what he got…let Brock try to maximize his market by asking teams his worth like BA did? You think teams are all gonna line up to pay him Dak money? You damn well know they aren't.

this isn't about Brock not getting "paid" it's about getting paid appropriately. Which is lets the market show his worth.

Originally posted by TD49ers:
According to all your other comments on this matter...Yes. This exactly what you advocate for.

lol not even close. Trying wayyyy to hard to find a gotcha moment. Try again

Originally posted by mayo49:
He's proven it already, Championship game and Super Bowl.

So why didn't Jimmy get paid elite money when he was a FA? Proven NFCC and SB?

Originally posted by Strwy2Hevn:
Let him test the market...

Why not? Why can't you do what you did with BA this off season? Let the market dictate his worth?

Tell me who's lining up to pay him Dak cash? You damn well know it's no one. So why the hell should SF have to fork over that type of money?

Originally posted by NYniner85:

Originally posted by TD49ers:
End of the day, it doesnt matter the how. So long as the players maximize their pay cheque, right? Food on the table.
Market of 5 or 1 is irrelevant. The impact is the same. Purdy clearly deserves it......

You think a 7th rd pick who's been making $900k hasn't maximized his situation lol?

the market is now irrelevant lol? You were b***hing about BA all off season and the market said he's worth what he got…let Brock try to maximize his market by asking teams his worth like BA did? You think teams are all gonna line up to pay him Dak money? You damn well know they aren't.

this isn't about Brock not getting "paid" it's about getting paid appropriately. Which is lets the market show his worth.

It's not about what someone wants, it's about reality, NY. Someone is going to give him what he wants or close to it. Everything in the world is inflated, brother, nothing different here.

Originally posted by NYniner85:

Originally posted by TD49ers:
End of the day, it doesnt matter the how. So long as the players maximize their pay cheque, right? Food on the table.
Market of 5 or 1 is irrelevant. The impact is the same. Purdy clearly deserves it......

You think a 7th rd pick who's been making $900k hasn't maximized his situation lol?

the market is now irrelevant lol? You were b***hing about BA all off season and the market said he's worth what he got…let Brock try to maximize his market by asking teams his worth like BA did? You think teams are all gonna line up to pay him Dak money? You damn well know they aren't.

this isn't about Brock not getting "paid" it's about getting paid appropriately. Which is lets the market show his worth.

Paid appropriately....100% agreed. not sure why you do?