QB Brock Purdy Thread

Originally posted by bud49:

Originally posted by Kolohe:
Wait who the hell want's Rodgers over Purdy!!! WTF have you people been watching this season. Rodgers looks as bad as Cooper Rush!!!

And he's starting over Trey.

Rush is ahead of Trey? Ugh....

Originally posted by Montana:

Originally posted by RonnieLott:
Brock didn't win us the game either.

2 interceptions in the 4th quarter were a horror show.

Lol 377 yards 3 tds 116 passer rtg. What an Art the Clown-like horror show for Brock Purdy cause of those two ints.

The real horror show? Moody Two missed fgs, extra pt and what the hell was that onside kick?

Not to mention..defense was ass for the most part..even with Bosa doing as well as he did. Sorensen can't be creative. Hit the road, jack 🎶
Can't win games with a defense that weak and predictable. Rush four ..repeat repeat..no disguises..no blitzes..nothing. Gunna call him Vanilla Ice...Wilks was better..I mean..if you are gunna fire Wilks..get a good replacement for crying out loud. We get this doof lol.

3 weeks in a row. Ball in his hands in the 4th quarter and a chance to win the game and he throws a pick to end it. Once can be a fluke, twice can be a coincidence but 3 times is a trend and that's not to mention the Vikings game and the KC game where he threw backbreaking ints. Then there was last season against The Browns, Vikings and Cincy where he again threw backbreaking ints. And there was the superbowl were again ball in his hands and couldn't get it done. I am not saying he is a bad QB but he is not elite and if we pay him like he is it will set back the franchise.

Originally posted by LB49ers:

Originally posted by Montana:

Originally posted by RonnieLott:
Brock didn't win us the game either.

2 interceptions in the 4th quarter were a horror show.

Lol 377 yards 3 tds 116 passer rtg. What an Art the Clown-like horror show for Brock Purdy cause of those two ints.

The real horror show? Moody Two missed fgs, extra pt and what the hell was that onside kick?

Not to mention..defense was ass for the most part..even with Bosa doing as well as he did. Sorensen can't be creative. Hit the road, jack 🎶
Can't win games with a defense that weak and predictable. Rush four ..repeat repeat..no disguises..no blitzes..nothing. Gunna call him Vanilla Ice...Wilks was better..I mean..if you are gunna fire Wilks..get a good replacement for crying out loud. We get this doof lol.

3 weeks in a row. Ball in his hands in the 4th quarter and a chance to win the game and he throws a pick to end it. Once can be a fluke, twice can be a coincidence but 3 times is a trend and that's not to mention the Vikings game and the KC game where he threw backbreaking ints. Then there was last season against The Browns, Vikings and Cincy where he again threw backbreaking ints. And there was the superbowl were again ball in his hands and couldn't get it done. I am not saying he is a bad QB but he is not elite and if we pay him like he is it will set back the franchise.

What's your solution?

Originally posted by Cisco0623:

Originally posted by LB49ers:

Originally posted by Montana:

Originally posted by RonnieLott:
Brock didn't win us the game either.

2 interceptions in the 4th quarter were a horror show.

Lol 377 yards 3 tds 116 passer rtg. What an Art the Clown-like horror show for Brock Purdy cause of those two ints.

The real horror show? Moody Two missed fgs, extra pt and what the hell was that onside kick?

Not to mention..defense was ass for the most part..even with Bosa doing as well as he did. Sorensen can't be creative. Hit the road, jack 🎶
Can't win games with a defense that weak and predictable. Rush four ..repeat repeat..no disguises..no blitzes..nothing. Gunna call him Vanilla Ice...Wilks was better..I mean..if you are gunna fire Wilks..get a good replacement for crying out loud. We get this doof lol.

3 weeks in a row. Ball in his hands in the 4th quarter and a chance to win the game and he throws a pick to end it. Once can be a fluke, twice can be a coincidence but 3 times is a trend and that's not to mention the Vikings game and the KC game where he threw backbreaking ints. Then there was last season against The Browns, Vikings and Cincy where he again threw backbreaking ints. And there was the superbowl were again ball in his hands and couldn't get it done. I am not saying he is a bad QB but he is not elite and if we pay him like he is it will set back the franchise.

What's your solution?

Pay him around the 30 million mark which is close to the Baker contract. If he balks let him walk. I think Kyle has shown that with an average QB (see Jimmy G) he can win. And for what it's worth he is still under contract for next year.

Originally posted by LB49ers:

3 weeks in a row. Ball in his hands in the 4th quarter and a chance to win the game and he throws a pick to end it. Once can be a fluke, twice can be a coincidence but 3 times is a trend and that's not to mention the Vikings game and the KC game where he threw backbreaking ints. Then there was last season against The Browns, Vikings and Cincy where he again threw backbreaking ints. And there was the superbowl were again ball in his hands and couldn't get it done. I am not saying he is a bad QB but he is not elite and if we pay him like he is it will set back the franchise.

The Browns pick wasn't backbreaking, and he put us in position to win when it mattered. Moody is just awful

I agree with Vikings and Bengals games, but that was also games where OL got dominated without Trent. Even cmc couldn't do anything those weeks. Then in playoffs he was pretty damn clutch. Would've been nice if Kyle did the right thing and we got 4 downs on our possession like the Chiefs did. Either way driving the field twice to take the lead isn't bad imo

This year been bad. There's some completely on him and some that aren't, but he could be better through all of it. Something I think will help is installing a hurry up and really working on a two minute offense. We just drop straight back and run the same plays we have been. That's the time to get him on the move more with defined quick hitters. Just dropping straight back and trying to make the right read over and over, while the line lets untouched rushers through every other down isn't a formula for success

Originally posted by LB49ers:
3 weeks in a row. Ball in his hands in the 4th quarter and a chance to win the game and he throws a pick to end it. Once can be a fluke, twice can be a coincidence but 3 times is a trend and that's not to mention the Vikings game and the KC game where he threw backbreaking ints. Then there was last season against The Browns, Vikings and Cincy where he again threw backbreaking ints. And there was the superbowl were again ball in his hands and couldn't get it done. I am not saying he is a bad QB but he is not elite and if we pay him like he is it will set back the franchise.

Also, we lost by 6 pts..Moody cost us 7..we would have won. Would that have changed your mind at all..if we won against the Lions? Even with the ints?

Originally posted by LB49ers:
Pay him around the 30 million mark which is close to the Baker contract. If he balks let him walk. I think Kyle has shown that with an average QB (see Jimmy G) he can win. And for what it's worth he is still under contract for next year.

Originally posted by Montana:
Yeah, what is your solution?

Also, we lost by 6 pts..Moody cost us 7..we would have won. Would that have changed your mind at all..if we won against the Lions? Even with the ints?

Like I had said before. Pay him the the 30 to maybe 40 million dollar range. But to make him in the top three is crazy. and no beating the loins would not have changed my mind, In fact watching this season has shown me who he is. This is the kind of team you get when you pay a QB top dollar, one elite weapon then a lot of role guys. I don't think Brock can carry a team. Look at Baker's contract, look at Hurts' contract they are similar which allow them to keep better players around them.

Originally posted by LB49ers:
Like I had said before. Pay him the the 30 to maybe 40 million dollar range. But to make him in the top three is crazy. and no beating the loins would not have changed my mind, In fact watching this season has shown me who he is. This is the kind of team you get when you pay a QB top dollar, one elite weapon then a lot of role guys. I don't think Brock can carry a team. Look at Baker's contract, look at Hurts' contract they are similar which allow them to keep better players around them.

As it pertains to Brock I think we should keep in mind he is young, and will learn/grow in the system. Also this was really the first year after the league seeing him so it's not surprising that they would throw some new stuff at him, let's see if he can adapt. With that said I don't think we should break the bank for him at least not yet.

Originally posted by LB49ers:

Pay him around the 30 million mark which is close to the Baker contract. If he balks let him walk. I think Kyle has shown that with an average QB (see Jimmy G) he can win. And for what it's worth he is still under contract for next year.

Originally posted by Montana:

Originally posted by LB49ers:
3 weeks in a row. Ball in his hands in the 4th quarter and a chance to win the game and he throws a pick to end it. Once can be a fluke, twice can be a coincidence but 3 times is a trend and that's not to mention the Vikings game and the KC game where he threw backbreaking ints. Then there was last season against The Browns, Vikings and Cincy where he again threw backbreaking ints. And there was the superbowl were again ball in his hands and couldn't get it done. I am not saying he is a bad QB but he is not elite and if we pay him like he is it will set back the franchise.

Also, we lost by 6 pts..Moody cost us 7..we would have won. Would that have changed your mind at all..if we won against the Lions? Even with the ints?

If you're going to play what if then you need to remember that the Lions kicker missed 2 extra points as well. Even if he makes one they still win 42-41

Originally posted by CatchMaster80:
If you're going to play what if then you need to remember that the Lions kicker missed 2 extra points as well. Even if he makes one they still win 42-41

Meh but Moody is a third round pick..shouldn't he make those? Another draft bust. Disaster.

Originally posted by 49ers9797:

Colin Cowherd thinks the #49ers CANNOT win a Super Bowl if they pay Brock Purdy $50M a year:

"There's only one thing that guarantees you can't win Super Bowls. Paying a B quarterback A money."

Comparing Purdy's situation to Dak Prescott's.pic.twitter.com/P8dmyZy9ew

— Dov Kleiman (@NFL_DovKleiman) December 31, 2024

Not sure what Love has done to be in that first grouping.

Hmm....dude even included Matt Stafford. Gotta ask TheWooLick about this one as compared to Jimmy.

Woo??

nm